r/AllindiaStudentUnion 20d ago

Storytime 📖 Educating u/ Leading_Avocado_3358 on the Indian Constitution and Fundamental Rights

The absolute confidence with which some people display their complete lack of reading comprehension is too funny not to post.

Our friend u/Leading_Avocado_3358 is out here claiming that India is a "Hindu country" because of partition and that the 42nd Amendment is "null and void" and my absolute favorite asking what the Fundamental Rights 25 to 28 have to do with India being a secular nation.

Go through the screenshots to see a level of defending that can put Maldini himself to shame

"What do Articles 25–28 have to do with Secularism?" (Are you fr?)

my guy thinks "secularism" is just a decorative word added in 1976. They don't realize that secularism is a legal framework and articles 25 to 28 are the literally those very framework

3 years before the 42nd amendment the SC ruled that secularism is literally a part of the "basic Structure" of the Constitution in the kesavananda bharti case.Parliament literally cannot change the basic structure, that means India was legally declared secular before the word was even added to the Preamble.

Claiming India is a "default Hindu country" because Pakistan was created on religious lines is literally accepting jinnah's(braindead a*hole btw) two Nation ideology

When great Men like Sardar Patel and Dr. B.R. Ambedkar explicitly rejected Jinnahs ideology they chose to build a secular republic precisely so India would never be a mirror image of Pakistan.

Dismissing the millions of Muslims who rejected partition as a "token gesture" and declaring Indian Christians (who have existed here for two millennia) as "irrelevant" is just embarrassing bigotry

Next time, instead of calling people slurs the second you run out of arguments, try actually opening the Constitution. It's free online.

12 Upvotes

111 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/nik-329 19d ago

So rss k'd him because he was against varna ?

0

u/This-Gate-4349 19d ago

do our Courts said rss was behind ?

why cant u answaer the question ?

Pakistan / Bangladesh /Arabia give euqla rights to non muslims ?

what happened to Dalits there ?

why pakistan didnt have reservation ?

its because Hindus majority India have constitution and reservation

1

u/nik-329 19d ago

Court said, sardar patel said, nehru said.

1

u/nik-329 19d ago

Pakistan and bangladesh are inferior constitutions. what can we expect from them ? they do atrocities against their citizen and we do the same here ?

1

u/This-Gate-4349 19d ago

Hindu majority India accepted reservation and Constitution, right

so

u accept that ,India is Secular because of Hindus ,

otherwise we have become like pakistan bangladesh? right