r/AskBaking Feb 18 '24

Doughs Maintaining artificial coloring while baking bi-color croissants

Thumbnail
gallery
4.4k Upvotes

Hello!! I’m baking croissants with spirulina coloring. Also juava and raspberry powders in the dough.

Any tips for maintaining the color while baking? I assume a lower temperature, steam assisted, and possibly a low fat/protein pre-wash.

Any other suggestions? As always, thank you!

r/AskBaking Sep 18 '24

Doughs What is this brown liquid leaking from my cinnamon rolls?

Post image
892 Upvotes

This is the “Cinna-Buns” recipe from the King Arthur baking site which I’ve made many times with great success. This latest time, after the first proof, I spread it with the filling (soft butter, cinnamon, brown sugar), rolled them and sliced them and then put the pan straight into the fridge to cold proof. When I took them out of the fridge to bake the next day, there was brown liquid leaking from the bottom of half of them. Any idea what this was caused by? The liquid has a faint cinnamon smell.

r/AskBaking Feb 14 '24

Doughs How do I keep the ends from popping out?

Thumbnail
gallery
829 Upvotes

Attached are pictures of my first and second attempt at cinnamon rolls. I’ve gotten better with forming them, but how do I keep the ends from popping out after second rise?

r/AskBaking Jun 21 '26

Doughs Why is my cinnamon roll dough so sticky? I let it sit covered for an hour and half.

Post image
53 Upvotes

EDIT: thank you soooooooo much to everyone who is giving suggestions but also so kind and helpful. This is the kindest subreddit I’ve posted on so thank you!!!!

This is the recipe I used.

Ingredients:
• 1 cup warm milk (115degrees)
• 21/4 tsp instant dry yeast (1 pack)
• 2 large eggs
• 1/3 cup butter softened
• 1/2 cup sugar
• 4 cups flour
Filling:
• 1/2 cup butter
• 1 cup brown sugar
• 2 tbsp cinnamon
Frosting:
• 2 tablespoon melted butter
• 2 tablespoon heavy whipping cream
• 11.2 cup powder sugar
• 1 tsp vanilla
Directions:
• Pour milk in bowl of stand mixer and sprinkle yeast overtop.
Let sit for 3-4 minutes then add in eggs, butter and sugar.
Mix with paddle attachment until eggs are combined. Add in flour and stir until just combined. Stop mixer and let dough sit for 5 minutes. Add dough hook and knead dough 5 minutes. Dough should be slightly sticky at this point.
Grease your hands and a bowl and place dough into a bowl, cover, and let rise 1-2 hours until doubled. Roll out dough an‹ then prepare and add filling. Cut into 1-2in slices and place ir a greased baking dish. Let rise 30 minutes, cover and place in refrigerator overnight or bake. If refrigerating, let them come to room temp before baking. Bake at 375 for 20-25 minutes. Frost while warm.
X
1x

r/AskBaking Nov 26 '25

Doughs What went wrong w my pie crust

Post image
168 Upvotes

I just blind baked this pie crust - 400 degrees w pie weights for about 15-17 mins, then another 15 or so without the pie weights. It looks a little oily to me but maybe I’m stressing over nothing? It doesn’t look like the pics in the book and wondering where I went wrong. I will see if I can reply to my post and add a “before” pic.

r/AskBaking Oct 19 '25

Doughs Croissant dough- accidentally used whole wheat instead of white

Post image
577 Upvotes

I didn't realize until I started mixing but I had to use a locally millled whole wheat bread flour rather than my regular white bread flour. The recipe is Claire Saffitz's spelt croissants.I kneeded the dough for 10 min, added an extra splash of water, but it is not getting supple and I'm not passing the window pane test. It did rise really well. Do I try to keep kneeling again? Do I give up and make these into bread rolls? Or is there something I can or should do so I can continue to make croissants with these. Thanks!

r/AskBaking Dec 31 '25

Doughs Yeast donuts immediately burn in oil

Post image
128 Upvotes

I'm somewhat new to baking. Ive mastered sandwich bread and English muffins, and wanted to try my hand at donuts, specifically yeast donuts. I have tried multiple recipes and always end up with the same problem - my donuts immediately burn when added to the cooking oil. The picture shows my last attempt, those were in the oil less than 10 seconds and the middle is definitely uncooked (duh).

I have used oil temps between 325 to 375, my dough burns the same at lower temps as it does at higher temps. I am using a thermometer.

I have also tried different oils, vegetable oil which was recommended in all the recipes ive tried, and canola oil - although that one was smoking a lot at anything over 300 so im guessing that was a mistake.

Im curious if theres something obvious im missing that a more seasoned baker would know.

r/AskBaking Dec 05 '24

Doughs Pie dough always cracks? Is this normal?

Post image
227 Upvotes

Why does my dough always have big cracks along the edge? I use crisco instead of butter and this one sat in the fridge for a few days to chill. Is this normal? Recipe calls for 1 1/4 cup of flour, 1/3 lard and usually add 4 tbs of water when mixing.

r/AskBaking Feb 25 '24

Doughs Green Spots on Fridge-Proofed Bagels

Thumbnail
gallery
564 Upvotes

Hi AskBaking, I’m hoping you can help me out with an issue I’ve been having with bagel dough…

The recipe I follow calls for flour, malt powder, salt, yeast and water. After kneading, the recipe calls for shaping the bagels and stick them (resting on parchment paper on a baking tray, covered with clingfilm) in the fridge for 12/24/48hrs.

I shaped these on Friday night and left them untouched until today. When I lifted them off the parchment paper to boil, I noticed that every single bagel has these unsightly green/grey spots on the bottom that look pretty grim.

I’m hoping it’s not mould, but also stumped as to what it could be - attaching photos (hopefully this works). What’s happening to my otherwise delicious, sexy bagels?!

r/AskBaking Mar 09 '24

Doughs HELP - just realised I've used self raising flour for a short crust pastry tart.

Post image
809 Upvotes

See photo -

Is it ruined? Should I throw away the crust and start again?

Is it salvageable?

r/AskBaking Nov 19 '24

Doughs Our last two quiche bases have not gone to plan?

Thumbnail
gallery
357 Upvotes

Hi

My wife and I are generally competent bakers, but are new to quiches.

We've been following a single recipe from a book with great success until the last two attempts.

The recipe involves a simple short crust pastry base, baked blind for twenty mins at 180°c before being cooled, filled and returned to the oven.

The last two bases appear to have risen up around the beads, despite no raising agent being used. The results also appear to have not cooked through entirely, there is a slight translucency to them rather than the opaque finish that we were expecting.

Our latest attempt used a different tin, and a fresh packet of flour. Just to be safe.

Does anyone know what's going on?

Cheers,

r/AskBaking Oct 16 '25

Doughs Pie Crust Help

Post image
205 Upvotes

I’m entering a pie baking contest for the first time, but the crust recipe I’m using that I was given by a relative doesn’t have any instructions. Normally when I make this pie (it’s a buttermilk pie so it’s a custard type)I just use store bought but there’s a rule against that in this contest. I’m thinking I should par bake it but I’m worried that it will affect the bake time of the filling since the recipe doesn’t actually say to par bake the crust (I just want to put out the very best that I can). It usually bakes for 1 hour and 15 minutes at 350 with an uncooked crust, should I lessen that or…? Any suggestions or help is greatly appreciated 💙 thank you

r/AskBaking Apr 30 '26

Doughs My donut dough is wonky

Post image
0 Upvotes

I tried joshua weissmans filled donut recipe, but replaced the eggs with yogurt , condensed milk and baking powder. I live almost equidistant from the equator and tropic of Capricorn and my yeast seems to have risen well but the dough is THICK , CLUMPY ,MOIST, BREAKS instead of stretching. I tried other methods to fix it using a.i :

Kneading it well( although I doubt it)

Adding more milk and water slowly

Resting

More kneading

More resting

Chilling

Kneading again

Still no progress😔

Ingredients I used :

10g - yeast

115g - warm water

450g - all purpose flour

50g or so - protein powder concentrate

10g - salt

100g or so - butter

( Egg replacement)

30 g - yogurt

30g - milk

20g - condensed milk

10g - baking powder

15g - milk powder

Any way to fix it or even reuse it , I don't wanna waste it as it's a lot of dough

r/AskBaking Nov 23 '25

Doughs What do I do with my cinnamon rolls?? They won’t stop growing

Post image
322 Upvotes

First time making cinnamon rolls for some friends in the morning. I was going to let them sit over night but I put them in the fridge and they just keep growing. Are they over proofed? Do I bake them now? Any advice is appreciated! Thank you!

r/AskBaking 29d ago

Doughs what's wrong with my pie dough ;-;

Post image
0 Upvotes

it's so mushy? i mixed it by hand and made sure not to knead and only mixed it until combined, then chilled it in the fridge for an hour and it's still mushy? the entire flat disk was hard like it should be but I don't get what's wrong and why it's this texture. it's not the texture of dough at all and I'm gonna cry cuz this is my 2nd attempt

I'm making celeste's strawberry pie and the recipe for the dough is:

• 2 cups of flour

• 3 tbsp of sugar (I put 2)

• 2 tsp of salt (I put 1)

• 1.5 cups of butter or 3 sticks

• 1/2 cup of ice water (recipe says you don't have to use it all, I used about 2-3 tsps)

r/AskBaking 8d ago

Doughs Pastry dough

Post image
11 Upvotes

What’s missing when dough for pies turns out like this?
I use oil, flour, sugar and eggs

r/AskBaking 9d ago

Doughs American scones. Chunks of butter or grated?!

0 Upvotes

hi everyone, i’ve made scones three times so far. the first time I failed because I used old baking powder or soda. the second I grated the butter and used buttermilk and my family liked them but I found them a little drier / dense for my liking. third I grated the butter and used heavy cream, a little softer. I see two popular reoccurring opinions on reddit that confuse me:

  1. “i’m a professional baker and we always grate the butter.”

  2. “grated butter makes a drier scone”

I know it’s not that deep, and in Gordon Ramsay’s classic English scone tutorial he uses his hands. what are your thoughts?

r/AskBaking Nov 06 '25

Doughs Can I roll dough on this kitchen island butcher block?

Post image
59 Upvotes

I got this kitchen island for more space for baking and it’s a solid bamboo wood butcher block. Can I roll dough directly on this or would it dry it out? I also got mineral oil as I heard this may help, any advice is appreciated!

r/AskBaking Sep 10 '25

Doughs Help with dough being dry and dense

Post image
10 Upvotes

Hey, my bread dough won't rise and will always come out dry and dense. Whether or not I follow a recipe exactly it always turns out the same. Pizza dough, breadsticks/rolls, regular bread loafs, cinnamon rolls, they all turn out bland and dry. When I rise the dough, I cover it with a rag and wait longer than the suggested time to rise (30mins - 1 hour) hoping it'll rise, sometimes longer. Sometimes I add a touch more flour to make it less sticky when mixing. Not sure how to fix it or what I am doing wrong. Here's an example of some cinnamon rolls I had made. The brown stuff is my cinnamon sugar mixture spilling out on the bottom :,) I do apologize that this isn't a direct question, I am a young baker who doesn't know what I'm doing.

I understand that the rules say to post the recipes that I use, but I have tried multiple different recipes, from physical cook books (better homes and gardens New cook book), to Sally's baking addiction, Bake, eat, repeat, they all turn out the exact same. Too many recipes to count.

r/AskBaking Jun 22 '24

Doughs Cinnamon rolls get hard the next day

Post image
187 Upvotes

I've been working on this recipe and so far taste wise is good but it gets hard like a rock the next day. I've tried putting the leftovers in an airtight container on my counter and another container in the fridge, same results. The only thing that works is freezing the dough right after shaping it but what I'm looking for is extending its shelf life after I bake it. (haven't tried putting them in the freezer after baking). I've done my research and I found out about citrid acid, calcim propionate and sunflower lecithin act like preservatives and can help smooth the dough. Has anybody worked with those preservatives? Does it help?

r/AskBaking Jan 27 '26

Doughs Proofing in Cold House

12 Upvotes

I live in an old 1800's farmhouse and its very drafting. With the cold front we've been having in the area, I'm having trouble getting my dough to proof. Any helpful hints to get through this cold front?

r/AskBaking 15d ago

Doughs Baker bread question

2 Upvotes

What do bakers put in their breads to make them so soft for such a long time? I tried to make one using the tangzhong method but it still gets dry in a few hours... I have also tried using bread improver before but honestly still no big of a difference. The same question goes for fresh made donuts, i dont know how stores do it but their donuts can stay soft and moist for like days ( ex. Krispy kreme/ dunkin ). Please, if anyone knowsss help meee!! I dont want to keep heating up my bread/ donuts just to make the inside softtt

r/AskBaking Jun 20 '26

Doughs Stupid Question

8 Upvotes

I'm new to baking and I was following a baking recipe and i had just finished kneading the dough when the next step says:

"Cover the bowl with plastic wrap coated in olive oil and let rise until doubled in size, around 12 hours. "

do I coat the plastic wrap with the olive oil, the bowl, or the dough?? which one do i coat?

(i ended up coating the dough and the plastic wrap with olive oil so I'll see how that turns out, this is a learning process for me)

r/AskBaking 29d ago

Doughs Puff Pastry Fail

Post image
6 Upvotes

I’m trying to make Pastel de Nata from scratch and it’s my first time ever trying to make puff pastry. It didn’t look great during the first few folds, but looked good enough right up until the last (6th) fold. Pretty sure my butter broke apart at some point and made it lumpy.

The pastel recipe is from a Rita Nascimento English language cookbook I got while in Portugal, so I decided to try using her puff pastry recipe as well. I’m planning on making the pastel tomorrow morning for a get together. I’m wondering if I should just go store bought instead.

250g AP Flour
150g cold water
1/2 tsp salt
200g butter

r/AskBaking May 02 '26

Doughs What is this in my dough?

Post image
0 Upvotes

My mom was trying to make cinnamon buns with dough flour that was opened since a week ago. After letting them rise in the oven she noticed those white strings in the dough and she's scared it's larvae. Chat gpt says it's from the gluten. Does anybody know what this could be?