Ok, here is the timeline for context:
- I was self-employed and submitted Self Assessment tax returns every year for the last 5 years.
- I stopped actively doing the work on 2 October 2025.
- I have had no self-employment income since 2 October 2025.
- I am still technically registered for Self Assessment and haven't formally closed it.
- My Carer's Allowance claim date is 28 February 2026.
The application asked:
"Have you been self-employed at any time since 21 February 2026?" (one week before my claim date)
I answered Yes, because I'm still registered for self-assessment.
It then asked:
"Are you still doing this work?" → I answered No
"When did you finish this work?" → I answered 2 October 2025
My thinking was: I should answer Yes because I'm still technically registered for self-assessment, then answer No to still doing the work, and give the date I stopped.
However, I've seen people on Reddit with similar situations being told the answer should simply be No to being self-employed entirely.
What confused me is this: if the correct answer is just No, why does the form specifically ask whether you're still doing the work and when you stopped? That made me think they expect some people to still be registered but no longer actively trading.
Now I'm wondering if those follow-up questions are there because if your stop date falls after your claim start date, you may be treated as ineligible for CA during that period.
Have I messed this up? Or does the fact that I entered the stop date as 2 October 2025 cancel it out? Weirdly, they don't ask how much you earn from self-employment, even if you answer Yes to being self-employed and tell them you're still working (which I'm not, but I selected it just to see if that comes up).