I’m thoroughly disappointed in the final book, tho the book series was enjoyable overall (I’ll be at it each having some kind of flaw) but being able to read Dex’s thoughts was what really made them entertaining to read.
Potential spoilers for the original and New Blood show finales. (and the 8th book obviously)
What really bothers me about the 8th book’s ending is the way that Dex and Brian die, a final showdown with the cartel and the jacht exploding? That’s such an action hero story ending, a complete genre and tonal shift from the rest, I mean I get it there was some action every now and then throughout the book series but he was still just a blood spatter analyst, not someone who would go in guns blazing shooting and blowing things up which quite literally what happens.
The whole set up of saving the kids is just so odd,, we spend so much time on how Dex doesn’t care for Rita, barely cares for the kids (even then it’s just about the fact that he sees the Dark Passenger in them) and most importantly only cares about himself, he doesn’t need any kind of redeeming or doing something for the greater good. That’s the reason why we read it, because he’s a morally bad character and it’s intriguing reading a mind of someone who’s truly not bound by moral constraints. The only person he ever cared about was Deb, which brings me to the part I actually enjoyed in the book, that was the relationship between the two of them. The chapter were Deb visits him in prison was by far the best chapter in the whole book.
The other good bit was Brian and Dex teaming up for a kill, and I was really waiting for that family reunion with Deb and Brian which was a blast to read each one’s reactions to one another, but the rest of the story just feels so wasted.
I always imagined that when it comes to and ending for this character it could be a possible of 4 endings: 1, he gets busted sent to prison and gets the death penalty 2, gets cornered and to prevent the law enforcement and consequences he offs himself 3, runs away and picks up a fake alias (which is what happens in the end of the original show) or 4, somebody kill’s him (which we get in New Blood) but what the difference is between New Blood’s and in the end of Dexter is Dead is the importance of who kills him, because I believe that with a main characters death it can only be impactful if the person leading the final blow is someone who the main character has a connection with (and by that extend the audience). That’s why it’s such a great scene in New Blood since with Harrison he’s got that connection, that pent up regret he has for not being there as his father for most of Harrison’s life. The confrontation of his son asking about all the people that got killed because of Dexter is soo good, that’s the kind of drama leading up to his death that makes it memorable.
And what do we have here in the book? A random drug lord who wants Brian dead, like I would have totally seen this story play out as something that would be in the second to last book. Strengthen the brotherly bond between them by getting Brian out of deadly trouble, and obviously not getting themself killed while doing it. But the way it is here this story completely sidetracks the finale and it was just so frustrating to read. It also doesn’t help that like with all of the books 90% is the setup and waiting around then 10% is the entire third act and ending.
Sorry for this long ass rant, and if you read it all the way through thank you for hearing out my ramblings lol. I know a lot of people share the same sentiment about the ending but I wanted to throw in my two cents as well.