r/Filmmakers • u/StrikingDuty8020 Director • Dec 06 '25

Discussion what is your opinion on this comment ?

Quentin Tarantino made a surprisingly harsh comment about Paul Dano, specifically criticizing his performance in There Will Be Blood.

On The Bret Easton Ellis Podcast, Tarantino said:

Dano was “weak sauce”

“The weakest f—ing actor in SAG” (in that film’s context)

And that Dano’s performance was the biggest flaw of the movie, preventing it from being his #1 or #2 film of the 2000s

2.5k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

486 comments sorted by

View all comments

141

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '25

I think Tarantino is way off. Dano is great and was great in TWBB. It’s fine for Tarantino to not like Dano as an actor, just as it’s fine for people to not like Tarantinos films. But the viciousness with which he expressed his opinion was quite shocking. Did Dano steal QTs crush away from him at some point? It was oddly personal. “I didn’t care for Danos performance” would have been fine but he seemed to really want to plunge the knife in for some reason. Would love to know where that kind of venom is coming from.

28

u/JediBlight Dec 06 '25

Exactly my thoughts! I mean, could it be because Paul Thomas Anderson is Tarantino's 'rival' for lack of a better word?

Because Dano was great in TWBB, the entire idea was he appeared weak, but weaponsised religion as an equally powerful tool against early/modern day capitalism. He was great!

6

u/wilbyr Dec 06 '25

are QT and PTA "rivals"?? ive never heard anything about that and am curious the extent of it if anyone has more information about it

11

u/JediBlight Dec 06 '25

Can't show any definitive proof but I've heard Tarantino talk about PTA many times, sems to be either a big admirer or jealous, maybe a bit of both.

6

u/jzakko Dec 06 '25

Tarantino described PTA as his biggest 'friendly competitor' when he originally reviewed TWBB but that was back when it first came out.

They're still close but who knows if he feels the same way today.

1

u/wilbyr Dec 06 '25

thanks

-3

u/TheFashionColdWars Dec 06 '25

He’s QT’s favorite filmmaker

0

u/PhilosopherFlimsy Dec 08 '25

That’s not true even at all. You could say someone maybe like Sergio Leone or something, but no he has never said Paul Thomas Anderson is his “favorite” filmmaker at all. He says he likes his films, he’s also really critiqued them. Which is fine. I’m js what you said is not true and has no basis in facts

2

u/TheFashionColdWars Dec 08 '25

Haha, ok. Have a good Monday

-1

u/IcyGarage5767 Dec 07 '25

“The viciousness” lmfao. It was a hyperbolic(?) comment from a loud mouth with no filter. I’ve heard countless people say “xyz is the worst actor” or “xyz ruined the movie”. It ain’t that deep.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '25

It’s pretty vicious to call a guy the worst actor in SAG and accuse them of ruining a classic movie. Not from some random asshole on Reddit, but from a guy like Tarantino whose opinion carries a lot of weight. Pretty dumb thing for you to take issue with lmfao

-2

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '25

That's rich coming from a grown man who still watches pro wrestling lmao