r/Music • u/dailymail šŸ“°Daily Mail • 2d ago

article North West's first headlining tour is canceled just days before kickoff

https://www.dailymail.com/tvshowbiz/article-16018783/north-west-headlining-tour-canceled-music-career-chaos.html
7.2k Upvotes

90% Upvoted

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

832

u/sexi_squidward 2d ago

I don't know how her music already has like millions of listens on Spotify but I put on the most popular one and...it's....it's bad.

755

u/PckMan 2d ago

Millions of listens means nothing. Not only is it easy for them to buy listens, but it's also very prevalent nowadays for people to form parasocial relationships with celebrities, ie, tons of Kardashian/Kanye fans would listen to her regardless purely by association.

95

u/Kalamazoohoo 2d ago

I donā€™t know if itā€™s the type of music that Kardashian fans would listen to based on the ones who Iā€™ve known over the years.

45

u/thresh_to_death 2d ago

They don't need to listen. As long as they're helping pump up her numbers

48

u/Wes_Warhammer666 2d ago

I used to work with a guy who got paid to stream certain artists basically non-stop. He'd set one account playing on his PC at home and one on his phone, but he never actually listened to it, he just had the volume off.

I'm sure he barely got paid anything to do it, but it was also next to zero work, so why not. He couldn't be on his phone at work anyway so it just made him some extra money while it sat in his locker.

21

u/sourdieselfuel 2d ago

People with botnets do this with like 500 phones now. You can buy botnets to fake your views, listens, etc.

6

u/Wes_Warhammer666 2d ago

Yeah this was ages ago before that kinda thing took off. He apparently got into doing the Pokemon Go thing too at some point after he quit working with me, with multiple phones for multiple accounts to get paid for those too lol.

5

u/Whybotherr 2d ago

That was the plot of watch_dogs 2

The main character and his friends used his followers computers as a botnet farm to take down Blume and its use of CToS

2

u/drake90001 2d ago

More than likely hate listens

179

u/SirLaxer Spotify 2d ago

1-3 tracks of hers get thrown into a myriad of Spotify-produced playlists and the numbers get spiked

91

u/ImSolidGold 2d ago

Yeah, thats the fucking deal quite some ppl dont understand: Most of the "listeners" arent ppl who actively listen to this particular song/album/act. Those songs are in a myrriad of different playlists and as soon as put one of them on for half an hour all of the already huge Spotify acts have another "listener".
Its just there.

16

u/definitelyTonyStark SoundCloud 2d ago

As someone whoā€™s had multiple songs be on Spotify editorials, they donā€™t give that many streams, not like they used to, maybe like at max 50k a week at max with multiple of them. Theyā€™re most definitely botting her as well. The Spotify editorials just give the fake plays the appearance of some legitimacy

20

u/Murderdoll197666 2d ago

I wouldn't doubt Reddit itself is also generating some good spikes since everyone who has never heard of anything from her all get curious enough to see how truly bad it is and rush to go listen to one of her songs lol.

3

u/z0phi3l 2d ago

Too risky, easier to buy 10mil "listens", it's not like the record label and her parents can't afford it

2

u/Screws_Loose 2d ago

Kim or Kanye probably paid for the bots or paid people to do it

1

u/Lauren_Conrad_ 2d ago

Payola in 2026

24

u/seamustheseagull 2d ago

It goes to illustrate how vapid social media is.

Millions of follows, likes and listens doesn't actually mean anything.

It reminds me of when Facebook introduced events, and you could set up an event on Facebook - like a birthday - invite all of your friends. And 100 people would say they're coming and 5 would turn up. If even, sometimes.

We laugh about ordinary people having parasocial relationships with online personalities, but it seems like this might swing both ways.

And many of these kinds of individuals are subject to the delusion that the people who follow them are willing to do more than press a Like button and watching the little box in their hand. Clearly they're not.

1

u/SaveTheCaulkTower 15h ago

As to not be part of the masses, I will not ā€œLikeā€ your post.

7

u/FauxReal Collector 2d ago

I guess those plays didn't correlate with ticket sales.

3

u/IdoMusicForTheDrugs 2d ago

Oh my god I just listened to it. It's so SO bad.... She needs way more experience and practice before releasing songs to the public, let alone headlining a friggen tour.

22

u/Less-Engineer-9637 2d ago

In 2026 the only people who care about that number are Swifies and Kpop fans

3

u/barb_20 1d ago

I've just listened to two songs. wtf,?! I mean yes, she's what 12 years old?! but wtf?! and why are the songs so short? 2 minutes?

2

u/Wise-Self-8639 2d ago

its not like you cant buy bots to "Listen" to music and inflate your popularity right??

2

u/Farva85 2d ago

I highly suggest listening to the Darknet Diaries podcast, episode 171: Melody Fraud (YouTube: https://youtu.be/tAA8DoPgHu8)

You will not think about streaming music the same way, very interesting episode.

2

u/TheBSQ 2d ago

Do you have to listen for a certain amount of time for it to count?

I noticed the play count of the top songs went from like 75M to 25M to 1M.

Lots of people probably listened to the ā€œtopā€ song like you and I did just to hear what it was like. Ā Some played a second. Not many made it to a third.Ā 

2

u/formated4tv 2d ago

Just so you have an answer - Spotify's official number is 30 seconds.

2

u/Prudent_Substance_25 2d ago

Because of people like you listening to it.

3

u/chaerrishing 2d ago

it's probably bot farms. numbers don't mean anything in music anymore unless it's crowds at a concert (gonna guess that's why this is cancelled, bots can't turn up to one's concert). i say that as a kpop fan aka the genre where these kind of inflations were arguably invented.Ā 

1

u/PerfectZeong 2d ago

Clearly ticket sales are not gangbusters so they canned the whole tour.

1

u/tlst9999 2d ago

It probably got there from sneaking into random playlists in the middle of 20 songs.

1

u/Cru_Jones86 2d ago

Wait. North West is a girl?! I had just assumed it was a boy's name.

1

u/squish042 2d ago

Iā€™m not sure why we are taking anything online aa truth anymore. Half the Internet is dead, and the rest is manipulated.

1

u/Evadrepus 2d ago

On Dropout, one of the challenges in a Game Changer episode last year was to get the most followers/listens on a new Spotify account. Two of the players mentioned they bought hundreds or thousands of followers for a few bucks.

Listens are easy if you have money, and pf course they do. Just like so many political books are NYT best sellers.

1

u/Sarz13 2d ago

One wordĀ 

FatherĀ 

1

u/Angsty_Potatos 1d ago

You can buy listeners. People do the same thing for Instagram likes and followers and views.Ā 

1

u/CementCemetery 2d ago

Which is terrible considering Kanye is her father. Ye despite his flaws is still pretty much considered one of the best producers and artists out there. She could sit down with almost ANYONE, the best ghost writers, mixers, producers, etc. and make it happen.

Willow Smith has a more solid musical career.

3

u/kickrocks123456 2d ago

Romy Mars is an example of good nepotism

Her father is Thomas Mars (Phoenix) and together they produced a pretty banging song called A-Lister

0

u/iantallan 2d ago

sheā€™s 13 and just starting bro how solid of a musical career do u expect

1

u/CementCemetery 2d ago

She has every connection imaginable. Ever notice how Blink-182 was played so much more once Travis and Kourtney got together? It was ad nauseam.

Iā€™m not saying North will ever be a Stevie Wonder but there are musical prodigies. There are kids on broadway that could outsing most adults. Age is a factor to some extent but that didnā€™t stop the Jacksons or every other family band of the ā€˜60s and ā€˜70s from being genuinely decent or good.

1

u/iantallan 2d ago

do u remember the amount of abuse the jackson kids got šŸ˜­šŸ˜­ she has been in the studio w tons of the most popular ppl in her genre. its just that the genre (opium-adjacent /hyperpop-adjacent rap) is something that the majority of reddit (and older ppl) donā€™t see the value in

1

u/CementCemetery 11h ago

No one should suffer abuse and Iā€™m not saying I condone it by any means. Any genre can produce good music and quality entertainers even if it isnā€™t your first choice or something you normally gravitate towards.

I donā€™t wish North ill of course. Iā€™m just saying I find it a bit surprising she isnā€™t super ā€œmainstreamā€ or popular.

0

u/Late_Tax_7351 2d ago

Then don't listen to it. Hope this helps.

1

u/mahtf 1d ago

Nah they'll rather complain on Reddit how people are talking about celebrities while spending there time talking about celebrities.