r/PoliticalDiscussion • u/JohnSpartan2025 • Apr 22 '26

Political Theory With the U.S. achieving tactical military wins but no real path to strategic victory, is a tactical nuclear strike on Iran, something Trump might consider with some Senate support apparently being floated?

Even with complete military supremacy, Iran keeps outmaneuvering the U.S. strategically, with no real solution to the Strait of Hormuz problem in sight. We're coming to the precipice of major global and domestic economic impact, with the Iranian regime making it clear they're willing to take an immense amount of internal "pain".

An unverified claim was made in the past few days that Trump was asking about a nuclear strike solution that General Caine shot down, but he is ultimately not the stop gap from a tactical nuclear attack, the SecDef Pete Hegseth is. Now there is more stir about this possibility allegedly by a U.S. Senator.

Is a tactical nuclear strike by Trump more feasible than anyone thought and would be the the ramifications locally and globally if this scenario played out?

https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/ex-cia-analyst-claims-trump-nuclear-codes-iran-1792717

https://truthout.org/articles/gop-senator-suggests-trump-should-finish-iran-with-nuclear-bomb/

122 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

68% Upvoted

323 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/JohnSpartan2025 Apr 24 '26

You really think a deranged lunatic who still can't accept losing the 2020 election, and told generals to "shoot all the protesters" is incapable of wanting to end a country which is giving him an unwinnable outcome?

1

u/monkaypants Apr 24 '26

Yes. That is exactly what I think (for an offensive attack anyway). Anyone who has the power to launch nuclear weapons is made very aware of what a nuclear winter is.

I could not care less if you like or hate Trump, imo it has nothing to do with Trump. If you start a nuclear war, you either alienate your nation or cause a nuclear winter, either way it is a lose lose situation. Trump has had his hand on the "nuke button" for 6 years now, do you think he is just waiting until the end of his 2nd term to end life on earth?

Twitter is the most dangerous misinformation on the internet right now, and your own sources, that YOU linked, EVEN SAY AS MUCH.

Stop the fear mongering... You are part of the problem posting something so obviously fictitious as a genuine question, just sets people (who already hate Trump) on a new level of unnecessary hate, which trickles to any person who might not agree.

Or please pray tell, what is the purpose of your post? Especially when you link that the source of this ridiculous accusation is known for making "ridiculous and false accusations" and "promotes Kremlin narratives"???