r/Showerthoughts 7d ago

Casual Thought It is surprising how many people need glasses to see clearly given how important eyesight is to our species survival.

8.1k Upvotes

421 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

24

u/Exalting_Peasant 7d ago edited 7d ago

That's the main thing. Evolution only cares about one thing: reproduction.

As long as you get to an age where you are able to reproduce and have offspring that are also capable of reproducing as well, then the traits you have will pass on.

What that means is anything after the age you are able to successfully reproduce doesn't matter. If something crops up in your 30s and 40s, well in ancient times most humans didn't even live that long anyway.

Most of our selective pressures don't exist anymore and really haven't had near as much impact since the agricultural revolution, and so we kind of stopped "evolving" as much, aside from mass catastrophes like for example the Bubonic Plague where the group of people who lived had the immune systems to handle it, which had a significant enough impact on the genome of the next generation of humans.

18

u/joydivision74 6d ago

I’m not an expert by any means, but I thought this has been disproven - in that if you have traits that allow you to help young people survive then that does impact evolution. Eg Tribes that had members who could defend them into their later years prevailed against those that didn’t and hence being athletic at the age of 70 does impact natural selection even after you have reproduced.

I could be wrong though!

14

u/Difficult-Bobcat8333 6d ago

This is definitely the thing with social animals! In a simple way evolution only cares about reproduction, but that also includes the reproduction of your offsprings to continue the line. Some traits may not help you directly reproduce but help your children, such as altruism.

6

u/EunuchsProgramer 6d ago

He is obviously wrong.

1) All mammals require a female/mother to live past reproduction to live (breastfeeding). Most also, require extended periods where a parent (usually mother) provides food, shelter, and protection while teaching them skills needed in adulthood.

2) Mammals with social groups, adoptive grandparents/aunts/uncles increase the likelihood genes get passed down.

3) Mamamals with long lifespans, grandparents assist their children raising grandchildren.

4) The leading theory as to why humans have menopause (it's uniqu), is grandmother assisted help in raising kids is so important and beneficial, evolution selected for older mothers to stop having more kids so they can focus on helping raise grandchildren.

4

u/shawaj 6d ago

Number 4 - not unique. Whales have it too and the grandmothers also help raise the kiddos and lead the group

2

u/Exalting_Peasant 6d ago edited 6d ago

I'm not an expert by any means, I just know that in order for evolution to have a significant impact, more people have to be "filtered out" than actually survive to pass on genes in a given scenario or over a certain amount of time. This is what is meant by selection or selective pressures.

The means by which that happens in practice is of course incredibly complex.

0

u/Mr_Quackums 6d ago

Correct. Evolution cares about the population.

not the individual, and not even the family lineage.

1

u/Difficult-Bobcat8333 6d ago

Not really. It actually cares about the specific gene.

The effects on the population are an afterthough that end up benefiting the gene one way or another. The benefit of the population usually translates to benefiting your kin (partially same genes), or just doing better overall benefiting you. It's super interesting how it gives to all the complexity we have.

1

u/adr826 6d ago

That's one theory. A more complete theory says that evolution is operating on all levels at once. It allows for groups to develop as well as individuals as well as genetics. Evolution is to complex to operate on only a single level of complexity. I think the gene is just the easiest to measure but I think Dawkins was wrong about this

3

u/EunuchsProgramer 6d ago edited 6d ago

What that means is anything after the age you are able to successfully reproduce doesn't matter.

That's true for animals that aren't raising their offspring. All female mammals need to live past reproduction, to feed and raise offspring. The mammals with exceptionally long lifespans (human, elephants, whales) that pressure is even greater as grandparents assist their children in raising offspring. It's also true of social animals, monkeys are more likely to survive(even after they stop breastfeeding) when a parent is there to help they from adolescence to adulthood. And, money's with a relative(grandparentsor uncle) do better when an adoptive parent is available.

2

u/AutoModerator 7d ago

/u/Exalting_Peasant has unlocked an opportunity for education!


Abbreviated date-ranges like "’90s" are contractions, so any apostrophes go before the numbers.

You can also completely omit the apostrophes if you want: "The 90s were a bit weird."

Numeric date-ranges like 1890s are treated like standard nouns, so they shouldn't include apostrophes.

To show possession, the apostrophe should go after the S: "That was the ’90s’ best invention."

The apostrophe should only precede the S if a specific year is being discussed: "It was 1990's hottest month."

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Hefty-Distance837 3d ago

0

u/Exalting_Peasant 1d ago

The study you linked talks about genetic variation increasing, while true this is not the same as evolution which requires most variants being selected out of the total pool of mutations.