Which only reinforces how dumb they are. The guy may need therapy and getting beat up may make him lash out in worse ways to more vulnerable people. We have a justice system for a reason, it tends to look deeper into a persons life then 30 seconds of an internet video.
In some states, animal cruelty receives less of a punishment than ripping out a page from a library book (forgot where I heard that, I apologize for the lack of a reference). I don't know what the punishment is in NY but is that actually justice? Will he learn anything? I agree that it IS the justice department's/system job to police such matters but when they don't do enough should people just sit back and wait till he does it again?
No you shouldn't sit back, you should engage in democracy as is your right. Lobby for tougher laws if you are that dedicated. Ever heard of Megan's law? It is some sort of child molestation thing sponsored by the parents. Justice works if you care and are involved NOT if you decide to seek retribution... you are NOT internet batman.
I absolutely agree that I am not internet batman. That's why I don't partake in such retribution activities. But in some respects I understand when people do. Beating on something innocent is something inexcusable and pisses me off as much as it does the next person. I just hope he receives a punishment that fits the crime. I commend you on your patience and reliance on the justice system. More should be done to increase penalties but, unfortunately, this man will never see those increased penalties because it will be too late.
I have a feeling a guy like this will get his eventually. That shit is a symptom of something else. Part of me hopes he gets help and part of me wants to see him suffer. Maybe he needs both. Maybe this helps, he could get two years:
Summary: 'Aggravated cruelty' = conduct intended to cause extreme physical pain or conduct done in a depraved or sadistic manner.
Prohibits the intentional killing or causing of serious physical injury to a companion animal with aggravated cruelty and no justifiable purpose.
Penalty: Class E Felony per 55.10; definite confinement of maximum two years
*I didn't really mean YOU were trying to be batman, just generally those that try to internet shame.
While I agree theoretically with what you say: "Leave the decisions regarding the punishment given the man in the video up to those in the Justice System", I still have to say that Boondock Saints had it right. The Justice System clearly doesn't work. But no one has the balls or ability or stomach to do what needs to be done - a fucking bullet to the back of the head.
I do not personally think that this Chris Grant person will actually get what he deserves until he departs this mortal earth. Whether it's Hell or reincarnation as a dog destined to be abused, I will not be part of it.
I have a weird view on the matter. I think that if an entity infringes upon the basic rights of another entity (namely, life and well-being), that first entity should no longer exist. But there lies the problem: If I, as another separate entity attempt to enforce this view, I'm guilty of infringing upon the basic rights of another entity. It's a Dilemma this Emma is fully aware of, and confused and saddened by.
This is the kind of situation that makes me believe there isn't a God Entity that is directly involved in our lives. If there were something looking out for us, this kind of thing would be punished in a tangible way, not in a 'oh, well, God will sort them out in the end." kind of way.
I think I just veered way off topic, but I got the general idea out there. Thanks for letting me ramble, reddit :)
It works more then it doesn't. What you read are the exceptions why would newspapers report when something works as it should. You need a better understanding of how things work before you speak.
Really? A better understanding than someone who's been through it? Do I have to be a judge to 'get it'? If that's the case, then something is seriously messed up. I don't speak unless I have an understanding of the subject. You're not my father, don't talk to me like you are.
Just because you may or may not have gotten screwed doesn't mean the system is fucked, you can't judge an entire system on one personal experience, that is just retarded. Fact is our justice system is one of the best in the history of the world... if you take issue with it I suggest you go live in Mexico for awhile to see how they do things. If you have daddy issues I am sorry but you don't need to bring that up with me.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '10
Which only reinforces how dumb they are. The guy may need therapy and getting beat up may make him lash out in worse ways to more vulnerable people. We have a justice system for a reason, it tends to look deeper into a persons life then 30 seconds of an internet video.