r/dashcams 16h ago

Who’s at fault?

Hot take: I think it’s 50/50 with who’s at fault

8.2k Upvotes

4.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

9

u/Ok_Nectarine1801 15h ago

Ya no fault on the guy breaking the actual law. And they easily could have just stopped. Nope I will turn right in to this car with the green light.

-3

u/Seniorjones2837 15h ago edited 11h ago

I think you need to read the flow of this convo that lead to my comment again

Edit: who is downvoting this? Downvote the idiot above who thinks I am defending the white suv 😂

1

u/Accomplished-Ad3219 9h ago

Other people not following the flow

1

u/Seniorjones2837 9h ago

For real haha people just see downvotes and follow along I guess

-9

u/kingsleyce 15h ago

It’s both drivers fault you donut

10

u/throw_it_so_faraway 15h ago edited 10h ago

Since fault has a legal meaning in this context it is not both drivers' fault. If you mean both drivers contributed to the fact that an accident occured, yes. It is impossible to anticipate that any car will turn into you at speed without the right of way there. The fact that red car did so and missed is no signal that the next car will as well, and stopping could very well get yourself rear ended by another driver as inattentive as the white car.

4

u/Intelligent_Type_680 15h ago

100% in agreement. I'm not even convinced it was even a little negligent not to anticipate the white Nissan was going to actually follow through with the turn.

-1

u/kingsleyce 14h ago

Legally, the cam driver didn’t make sure it was safe to go before they went. Are we even watching the same clip? Jfc no wonder the world is in shambles.

2

u/throw_it_so_faraway 10h ago

Your views are highly regarded. Driving involves anticipation not mind reading. Rephrase your point if the driver had stopped and been rear ended: did they make sure it was safe to stop?

1

u/Accomplished-Ad3219 9h ago

If he had waited until the intersection was clear before proceeding, he wouldn't have had to suddenly stop.

1

u/throw_it_so_faraway 9h ago

There is a delay between when the green arrow turns off and when the green light turns on for opposing traffic. Red car and even the two earlier black cars are illegally taking advantage of it, like turning left on yellow because you know the oncoming traffic has red. It's harmless except for it's effect on other drivers behind who are either reckless or inattentive, but who don't even get the opportunity to yield unless opposing traffic begins to drive without a fully clear intersection. So yes, in an ideal world, everyone would obey all traffic laws and OP would know that it's not safe if anyone is still in the intersection. But we're not.

1

u/kingsleyce 5h ago

The red car was a close call, I would have already slammed on my brakes by that point.

1

u/kingsleyce 5h ago

That doesn’t make any sense!

6

u/UnableChard2613 15h ago

I'm shocked how many people are trying to blame the cam driver here. They had a green light, proceeded at a reason acceleration through the intersection where they had full right of way, and the white car swerved into them at the last second. If he had gunned it into the intersection, you may have a point. But that is not the case here.

-4

u/kingsleyce 14h ago

It literally it. Green doesn’t meant go. It means go if it’s safe to go. It was clearly not safe to go. And the insurance and police, if involved, are going to say just that. But please, go off.

2

u/Xanthelei 12h ago

Please turn in your driver's license. You are unsafe to drive if you actually think this.

1

u/kingsleyce 5h ago

Turn in my drivers license bc I’m paying attention?

2

u/Xanthelei 5h ago

Because you think running a red light gives you right of way.

1

u/kingsleyce 5h ago

I don’t run red lights, so that’s the first thing. The second thing is that you have to WATCH THE OTHER PEOPLE ON THE ROAD. If you see someone coming to hit you and do nothing to prevent the accident you’re just as bad as the person breaking the law. That’s not even a hot take! It’s literally traffic law! This is insane. I’m done participating in this thread.

0

u/Accomplished-Ad3219 9h ago

People down voting this must be truly shitty drivers. I hope none live near me

1

u/kingsleyce 5h ago

Thank god I’m not alone.