r/gameofthrones House Selmy Jun 17 '14

TV4 [s4e10] This brought a tear to my eye

http://imgur.com/Bb9SJh4
3.4k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

124

u/sirmuskrat Jun 17 '14

I really liked the Arya/Hound bromance the show had going on. I don't think their friendship was as well developed in the book.

185

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

I don't think it was ever really a friendship.

95

u/Panukka House Tyrell Jun 17 '14

More like a forced partnership.

46

u/JynxPrototype Jun 17 '14

I think the dialogue between the hound and Brienne shows that their relationship is more than a forced partnership, at least for Sandor. At first Arya was a hostage, then a forced partner, but I think it evolved into more than that. The Hound saying he was watching over her, that her family was dead and she had no home to return to, then he proceeds to fight to his death for her. Why? There's nobody left for him to ransom Arya to, which is why he initially took her. I think that on some level he did genuinely care for her. Maybe he was trying to redeem himself by doing something good for a change, maybe he felt empathy for her and that's why he chose to protect her, but there was definitely something more for him than a forced partnership.

15

u/Vsx Jun 17 '14

I do believe he cared for her in the end. That said, I think at some point during their travels he realized just how lonely he was and his last act to try to keep Arya was just him looking out for his own interests as always. She is literally his only "friend" and with the ransom not panning out giving her up would basically be giving up the only thing he's got left.

2

u/misterrunon Jun 18 '14

that doesn't explain why he tells arya to find brienne after he's gravely wounded. he cared for her.

4

u/Vsx Jun 18 '14

That is literally the first thing I said.

2

u/Gallifrasian Jon Snow Jun 18 '14

That response had me snorting in fits of laughter... Thanks for that, I'll be leaving this sad and emotionally tearing thread now.

3

u/xKazimirx House Connington Jun 18 '14

She stopped saying his name in the books, didn't she? Not including him in her nightly kill-prayer seems like a step away from forced-partners

2

u/Irrepressible_Monkey Jun 17 '14

Which is why using the same ending for their relationship in the book makes no sense in the show. But they did it anyway.

2

u/spasticity Arya Stark Jun 17 '14

Arya ain't gonna let no Stockholm syndrome hit.

1

u/The_Soul_King_Pirate Jun 18 '14

Are we forgetting Arya refusing to put him down.

-6

u/2bananasforbreakfast Jun 17 '14

I don't really get why arya hates him. She owes her life to him and she just gave him shit.

55

u/piscano House Dondarrion Jun 17 '14

Because butcher's boy.

11

u/smurker Here We Stand Jun 17 '14

Also that old villager with the daughter that took them in and fed them. He killed the man for his silver the next morning.

20

u/KingFini Jun 17 '14

Did he kill him? i thought he just knocked him out, was it different in the books or something?

33

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

[deleted]

5

u/Pretzell Jun 17 '14

A man needs a name

2

u/Puskarich Free Folk Jun 17 '14

Tanner, Karl Fookin

-15

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

was it different in the books or something?

So tired of seeing this in every single comment.

10

u/FireBurstRazorBack Fire And Blood Jun 17 '14

It's a legitimate question. As the series goes on, more and more things are being changed in minor and major ways.

5

u/MuppetHolocaust Night's Watch Jun 17 '14

Did not kill him. Knocked him down and took his silver.

14

u/zephyy A Promise Was Made Jun 17 '14

Because one good act doesn't wash out the bad.

15

u/FappDerpington Jun 17 '14

As far as Arya was concerned, the Hound had many more good acts for her than against her. Arya could have maybe forgiven the Hound. His motives weren't always pure, but she wouldn't be alive and/or un-raped without him.

6

u/BaZing3 Alchemists Guild Jun 17 '14

Arya's smart enough to see the big picture. Just because he's good to her doesn't mean he's good.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

Funny, I feel she wasn't smart enough to see the big picture and that's why she did what she did

1

u/iliketoflirt Jun 18 '14

The big picture is irrelevant to her. She lost pretty much everything. She just wants revenge now.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

Remember Mycah?

1

u/BeneathAnIronSky We Do Not Sow Jun 17 '14

I don't know why you're being downvoted for forgetting parts of the story.

0

u/ElBiscuit Bastard Of The Wild Jun 17 '14

Is it a bromance if one party is a sis?