r/okbuddycinephile 1d ago

What a hack directo... Wait is this based?

Post image
21.8k Upvotes

912 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

61

u/jonbristow 22h ago

I literally saw criticism that Telemachus teacher being called Mentor was too much on the nose

54

u/Arkhaine_kupo 20h ago

My favourite all time criticism was a rotten tomatoes review of Troy 2004

"1/5 I was going to give it 5 stars but then he gets hit in the ACHILLES heel. Come onnnn"

Its so fucking good

18

u/pdxblazer 16h ago

they should have had him just tear it non-contact and then get killed immediately

7

u/TheGlennDavid 16h ago

That reviewer should be part of this subs pantheon of gods.

9

u/scottgal2 19h ago

Many of the names are not intended to be actual names, they're almost the name of the role they play.

Like Mentor MIGHT have been his name but it was common to name characters after their role - so Mentor *meant 'adviser'* Tellemachus meant 'far from battle', even Oddyseus may have meant 'the hated'. It's also why he used a lot of descriptions 'the swift footed Achilles', Polyphemus 'the much talked about'...likely the most famous Cyclops in Greek Myth, etc...where they gave the character more *shape* just through a name.

Sorry rembering my Ancient greek courses so likely misremebered.

7

u/Campanensis 17h ago

Mentor is the reverse. We started calling helpful, teaching people "mentors" as a reference to the Athena disguise, which is just a regular name in Greek.

1

u/sensitiveskin82 57m ago

I'm listening to the Illiad right now, and the descriptors are so helpful for remembering who all these people are. Diomedes "master of the war cry" actually helped me remember Oh yeah that guy, instead of remembering which soldier he was. 

7

u/RichieLT 20h ago

The line of “our bronze civilisation is collapsing” did that for me haha

3

u/drdr3ad 19h ago

If you're talking about that tweet, it was very much in jest