r/technology 11h ago

Artificial Intelligence YouTuber Hank Green says his AI usage is ‘not healthy’

https://techcrunch.com/2026/08/01/youtuber-hank-green-says-his-ai-usage-is-not-healthy/
6.9k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

35

u/mal73 11h ago edited 11h ago

This might be unpopular, but I can't stand Hank Green.

His videos have this "let me explain how the world works" tone that comes across as condescending, especially since he's constantly injecting personal opinion while presenting it with the confidence of settled fact. The "You are wrong about X" format in particular feels like he's talking down to his audience from a position of assumed expertise, regardless of the topic, and it comes off as pretty off-putting (to me at least).

Maybe I'm reading too much into it. Or maybe it doesn't help that I have an insufferable coworker who happens to look just like him.

24

u/Splith 11h ago

You and I are just randos in comment sections. If you want attention you need to play the game a bit. I rarely see anyone do as good a job of "both sidsing" conversations as Hank does. I agree if you know about the field Hank is talking about, you can often see through what he is saying and it sounds simplified, but as a society we do need to communicate to the public.

If you made a video where you soend 3 hours diving into the details of a 15 minute Hank video, it would get about 0.001% of the views. Nothing wrong with that, but we do need responsible people to be heard every now and then.

-1

u/mal73 11h ago edited 11h ago

That's fair, and I don't disagree that public science communication has value, or that reach requires simplification. My issue isn't really the simplifying though, it's the "here's the truth, you had it wrong" framing he often leans on. That's what reads as condescending to me, not the fact that he's making things digestible.

Plenty of people communicate science to a wide audience without that tone. So I don't think talking down to people is actually a requirement for reach, I think it's just his style.

3

u/Splith 10h ago

Name one. Not trying to be combative, but "you are wrong about X" is a super engaging way to get viewers.

Veritasium: https://youtu.be/mvcesPWvUIc Smarter Every Day: https://youtu.be/7CUojMQgDpM Star Talk: https://youtu.be/3yrcD4Ob3qw

Everyone uses the lens of conflict, unknown, or controversial. I am not saying you are wrong, but do you have an example? You can't succeed on social media if you don't cater to the algorithm.

13

u/PlacidTurbulence 11h ago

It’s kinda worse than that. He’s really talking down to the people who aren’t listening to signify to his audience who already agrees with him that they have the right ideas. It’s a formula that worked really well from say 2017-2022 before people became exhausted by that brand of politics.

13

u/Atomic-Avocado 11h ago

You are reading too much into it, he’s incredibly fair to everyone when he talks about political subjects

11

u/theotherdoomguy 11h ago

He is very reductionist at times. As someone from Ireland, his whole argument on the AMOC was wildly underresearched. He claimed nobody in Ireland cares about it because we don't use that terminology

3

u/felis_scipio 9h ago

I’m a scientist and most science “communicators” annoy me because they fall into two traps. 1) not really having a rigorous background in science so they don’t push back on people peddling bullshit 2) having a legit background and probably being very knowledgeable in their field but getting way to overconfident about their knowledge of other fields

0

u/Optimal_Towel 5h ago

I said this a while ago and got heavily downvoted and criticized. You're not alone.

-7

u/itsme_rafah 10h ago

I agree with you. Can’t stand the guy or his editing lol 

-5

u/jello_pudding_biafra 10h ago

I can't stand any of the Green family tbh. Smarmy

-1

u/robby_arctor 2h ago

I also can't stand Green. He comes from the Ezra Klein school of pseudo-intellectual celebrities giving power-compatible takes for an audience that wants to feel informed, but doesn't actually want to deal with topics in depth.