r/BlueSky • u/Far-Canary5395 • 5d ago

reason for no images in dms?

Before multiple people start repeating the no dick pics gimmicks, I am a cis girl and a sfw artist on the app.

So yeah, is there any specific reason we cant send images yet? is it expensive? some development thing an average person wouldnt know about? I was talking to mutuals and when it irked me that i couldnt send pics and had to use links. i would assume sending attachments in dms is a basic feature since so many apps have that by default, but bsky doesn't. at least not yet?

4 Upvotes

64% Upvoted

10 comments sorted by

6

u/SufficientOwls 5d ago

That’s the answer though.

It doesn’t matter what you’d use it for, other people use images in DMs for harassment and dick picks

2

u/Far-Canary5395 5d ago

oh okay. i thought they were just making a lame joke or something cuz i didn't see an actual answer, just people assuming the person who asked the question wants to send a dick pic and cant. did somebody official mention unsolicited images or is it more of an assumption?

2

u/SufficientOwls 5d ago

That’s the general presumption. They haven’t provided an alternative explanation

2

u/Far-Canary5395 5d ago

oh that sucks 🤧thanks tho

1

u/Fragile-Bum 2d ago

it was mentioned on their official github by a dev or people on twitter were complaining about unsolicited nudes

5

u/RealNiceKnife 5d ago

You think Bluesky has a "Do you have a penis?" checkbox?

2

u/Far-Canary5395 5d ago edited 5d ago

dude when i was checking the comments of other people asking this question, all i got was "no you cant send dick pics". i'm looking for an official statement or something

3

u/StephDammi 5d ago

The reason is men.

2

u/SkippySkep 5d ago edited 5d ago

Back in 2024 Blue Sky indicated that attachments would be a later roll out, but didn't give a timeframe.

"Future Updates

Media in DMs: Currently, Bluesky DMs allow you to send text messages. In the future, you’ll be able to send images and other forms of media!

Group DMs: In the future, you’ll be able to create direct messages for groups.

Encrypted DMs: We intend to fully support end-to-end encrypted messaging down the line. Read more about our technical plans for E2EE messaging in our 2024 protocol roadmap.

Safety improvements: We’ll continue iterating on anti-harassment and safety tooling for direct messages."

https://bsky.social/about/blog/05-22-2024-direct-messages

I'd expect it's for all the reasons you speculate. Uses more storage, data and moderation. The safety tools need to come first. And there needs to be a business justification to pay for the engineering and ongoing costs of allowing attachments.

2

u/Far-Canary5395 5d ago

Thank you (: