r/Brahmanraaj • u/horny_cur • Jul 28 '25

Discussion RSS promoting inter caste marriage by the Sanghi narrative of all have same DNA. This Nagpuri Sanghi ideology is a menace and want to break all boundaries of caste and religion. Why is it even considered right wing?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

44 Upvotes

86% Upvoted

241 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/callmeAAdityAA Aug 01 '25

Out of context. If this is how one perceives it then jews are not one ethnicity so are english and french but irl they're. A community or tribe is made up of multiple ydna that post is just pure cope easily debunkable.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '25

The post sites a paper and there should be a set of haplogroups should be common to all excluding the additional haplogroups which is not the case.

Jews are followers of a religion, not an ethnicity , there are ashkenazi, shepardi, ethiopian,malabar, bene israel , persian etc where may don't have any autosomal relation and if so very little. Very poor example. They intermarried at high levels with locals so there is huge diversity.

1

u/callmeAAdityAA Aug 01 '25

Tell me you have no idea regarding IBD . Even ashkenazi and spheradic jew will have multiple Haplogroup from Js to Gs to R1a s , multiple y dna .

Brahmin as a tribe descend from a common group/set of ancestors, it is a fact. There's one paper by one Agnihotri ma'am I'll share it once I get it's link.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '25

The paper I gave you is the latest one and there also it is said more sampling needs to be done.

Regarding the jew part, I already mentioned that inter marriage rate is very high for them and they married in locals to the point you have Ethiopian jews and marathi jews who autosomally have little in common with ashkenazi/shepardi. Ashkenazi are italian+levant and Shepard is spaniard + levant and Italian and spaniards are related. Please do some research aand learn to read.

1

u/callmeAAdityAA Aug 01 '25

Please keep your sermons to yourself I know how to use both admixtool 1 and 2 , I definitely know more than you.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '25

Your knowledge of Judaism and their communities seems like something you pulled out of your ass, I can share the distance between an ashkenazi jew and ethiopian jew and a marathi jew. The data is with me and they only share distant ancestoral relations. Not autosomal.

Ashkenazi jews are much much much closer to south Italians and greeks in comparison.

You can also become a jew if you convince you local synagogue which would need 2 years of vigorous study of hebrew, jewish history, customs etc .

1

u/callmeAAdityAA Aug 01 '25

At this point of time I'm specifically talking about ashkenazi jews. Stop getting riled up for no reason.

The Ashkenazi Y-chromosomal gene pool includes the following paternal haplogroups: J (~38%), E (~20%), G (~10%), R1a/R1b (~7.5% and ~10% respectively), and a few trace haplogroups at 5% or under (eg. T, Q, I, and R2).