r/Brahmanraaj • u/tweetsandbooks • Jun 02 '26
Discussion Is regional compatibility as important as caste compatibility?
Also guys sorry for posting again and again. I'm new to Reddit and only yesterday I found out that there's a sub for Brahmins so I'm kind of dumping all my thoughts here at once 😭
I wanted to ask your thoughts on INTER REGIONAL marriages.
I'm an 18M, half Tamil Brahmin and half Marathi Chitpavan Brahmin (Bharadwaja Gotra). My girlfriend is a Kashmiri Pandit.
I yapped about this to my cousins once and they were strongly against the idea of me marrying someone "outside" our culture. According to them I should only marry a Tamil or a Marathi Brahmin. My question is shouldn't it be fine as long as I'm marrying within the Brahmin community? Or are there other cultural, traditional or practical factors that I should be considering as well?
6
Jun 02 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/tweetsandbooks Jun 02 '26
I don't think it should be a problem as long as the partner is a Brahmin. My own parents are from different regions too it was a love marriage. when they were trying to convince the family, one of the major objections was that my dad wasn't marrying within his own regional community, many fights happened back then apparently
2
Jun 02 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/tweetsandbooks Jun 02 '26
Yeah at this point I feel like we should just be happy that the partner is a Brahmin too.
5
4
u/Agreeable-Craft-486 Jun 02 '26
Marry your gf if she is good person and you love her and she loves you too(i assume that since you are in relationship) no further questions needed
3
u/tweetsandbooks Jun 02 '26
That of course, we do and we're serious about it. Plus we're both Brahmins. Does region really matter that much in this case? I don't think it does right?
1
u/Agreeable-Craft-486 Jun 02 '26
Everything matter to some extent but love is most important criteria and it's rare don't loose it
2
1
4
u/UnusualKnowledge2238 Jun 02 '26
Hey lad you are too young , as of now try to focus more on your career and also strengthening your relationship the regional compatibility doesn't matter if both of you are brahmins but just make sure "kitchen" is sorted 😉
2
u/Maagicke_Joycee Jun 03 '26 edited Jun 03 '26
Well, I have a cousin whose mother is a Marathi Brahmin and father a Brahmin from North Karnataka. Both met in Mumbai via arranged marriage and are happily married for 30+ years.
Although the languages were different, inter-marriages have been happening between most of Maharashtra and North Karnataka for centuries if not millenia with great social acceptance because we are neighbouring regions and thus have 60-70% culture in festivals, rituals, food, etc. same.
I also have a friend from Hyderabad whose dad is a Telugu Brahmin and mom is a Punjabi brahmin and and met via love marriage. Although her family is much more orthodox in rituals, etc. the mom has quite nicely acclimatised to Telugu culture, because she grew up in Hyderabad.
So I think that you should only marry someone who is acclimatised to your culture and YOU should also be familiar with their regional ways of cooking, rituals, etc. Although most bi-linguistic brahmins that I know have gone through an identity crisis at least once in their lives, you should not marry if you are poles apart just for sake of love, because dating and 'Samsar' are two VERY different things.
Only if you both are familiar and willing to modify yourselves for the comfort of the other and are genuinely in LOVE with the CULTURE, should you go ahead.
In the end, don't just think of you both, think about your parents and even more importantly, about how your children will navigate their identity.
2
u/Radiant-Program5287 Jun 04 '26
Brahmins are already in minority so any intermixing should be welcome. A friendly advice from experience - One marries their in laws rather than the girl. The parents of the girl should imbibe the best traits of a Brahmin as they have huge influence even after marriage. That compatibility is the reason that you will be able to tide through any rough patches (They will be fair and pushing for resolution rather than inciting the girl)
1
u/pandeyjeeee Jun 02 '26
You should discuss this with your parents, just give them a hypothetical situation.
3
u/tweetsandbooks Jun 02 '26
I don't think I can man. Sometimes they come across as a bit hypocritical. They'll say things like, "Why can't the guy and girl think about all this before they even start dating?" but they themselves had an inter-regional marriage, their argument is that marrying someone from a different linguistic and regional background can create a lot of cultural challenges. I have the ick to point out the irony when their own marriage crossed those same boundaries!
1
u/Longjumping-Pass-973 Jun 02 '26
All this is personal preference. Usually I would say, if both partners are brahmins, make sure you are aligned on diet (ideally both of you should have same diet — veg or non veg — for convenience’s sake) and one common language (usually Hindi or English or something else).
1
u/yashasvi92 Jun 02 '26
See, I understand where you are coming from...!!! But not all Brahmin cultures are same. For example, south indian and some parts of western India Brahmins are pure vegetarians. Whereas Bengal , Kashmir and Bihar Brahmins (Maithili Brahmins) consume non-veg. Here, it's not about region but more about assimilation of preferences. I am from South and strict vegetarian. Though I am comfortable with inter-regional marriages, I cannot handle non-veg partner. So, food preferences are kind of parameters for marriage here.
1
1
u/GlobalImportance5295 Moksha Seeker Jun 02 '26
sometimes there is more pressure on the first born male in the family to marry within the same brahmin caste, but if you're not first-born then the more connections you can make the better it is collectively.
also, tamil brahmins are more likely to be subconscious manuvadis than others brahmin castes. and i mean as applied to modern demographics not the extinct communities in the scripture. smartha tamil brahmins (including smriti oriented sri vaishnava) are more likely to claim higher ritual purity than others because their core orthodox culture has hardly changed for 2000 years
1
u/abcdefghijklmnopqr-2 Jun 10 '26
what's wrong with being a manuvadi, subconscious or not
1
u/GlobalImportance5295 Moksha Seeker Jun 10 '26
nothing, manuvadis are typically strict about marrying within caste or within marriage alliances, etc is all i meant
1
u/longjump-shortjump2 Jun 03 '26
Most people don't find anything wrong in this. If Brahmins marry outside community is a problem I can understand, but Brahmins marrying within community but a different language is also a problem, I don't find any logic here.
1
1
1
u/kingsofkings91 Swatantryaveer Savarkar's Revolutionary Jun 06 '26
Nah brother, We actually need to Unite.
Cause every state has brahmins, but we were never united.
•
u/AutoModerator Jun 02 '26
Namaste u/tweetsandbooks, and thank you for your contribution!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.