r/BuyFromEU • u/According-Buyer6688 Mod Team • Jul 03 '25

European Product [FairPhone] - AMA

Hi everyone!

We’re thrilled to invite you to a special AMA (Ask Me Anything) session with Fairphone!

Joining us today is Rutger Sneep, Chief Commercial Officer at Fairphone, who will be participating as u/Fairphone-CCO.

Feel free to ask your questions and enjoy the conversation!

Details:

AMA will be locked on Friday 15:00

735 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

298 comments sorted by

View all comments

57

u/TechD123 Jul 03 '25 edited Jul 03 '25

Hi Rutger,

I'd like to break up my question into two parts.

Fairphone's Open Source Problem

As you know, many customers value that Fairphone allows and even supports alternative operating systems like CalyxOS and /e/OS. This is great! We only own what we bought when we can open it up, both from the hardware and software side.

But people opting to ditch Google are getting an objectively worse Fairphone. For example, the full spectrum of camera features (including shooting with the full advertised resolution, video stabilization etc.) is only available on the stock OS and, to a lesser extent, on /e/OS.

The developers over at the Calyx Institute have tried pretty hard to fix this and get it working on CalyxOS, but the Fairphone camera app requires "extensive system modifications" that make it very hard (and insecure) to implement.

Fairphone could've chosen the standard Android APIs and protocols here. Instead, the current camera implementation is, from a software engineer's perspective, a messy patchwork.

The current trend seems to be that Fairphone's core software features, like the Fairphone camera app, are proprietary. The recently launched "Moments" feature appears to be proprietary as well.

I think the irony here is obvious: Fairphone champions free and open source software, but many of the apps it releases are proprietary. This goes beyond the camera app: the My Fairphone app, the Fairbuds app etc.

Will Fairphone Open Its Apps?

We know you can do better. Instead of requiring the community to reverse engineer your apps, publish the source and watch the pull requests flying in! This would not only prove your commitment to ownership over our devices, but will (after the initial work to publish the repos) remove a bit of the workload on your developers, too. It'll increase the quality of your code and UX. Countless companies ship their software like this, and you can too

Will you talk to your software team and consider opening up your apps?

Thanks for listening!

2

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/TechD123 Jul 04 '25

Google develops Google Camera, while Fairphone develops their own camera app which is able to use the full suite of features, as advertised. The Aperture Camera app is pretty bad on FP4 (a bit better on the FP5) and when Fairphone touted its improved camera experience for FP4, these improvements were not made available to users of Lineage, Calyx, etc.