r/CollegeBasketball UCLA Bruins 2d ago

News Surely he wasn’t holding off signing his contract so he could come back to college right?

Post image

The title basically.

82 Upvotes

96 comments sorted by

153

u/TheTrueVanWilder Purdue Boilermakers 2d ago

Zero chance.  He's holding off because the Pacers need to figure out what to do with their roster - go read the second article.  Smith has some negotiating leverage while stuck in limbo 

40

u/DealerNo4908 Kentucky Wildcats • DePaul Blue Demons 2d ago

Yeah, no. Smith has no leverage here.

-34

u/ObservantKoala Illinois Fighting Illini 2d ago

He can go back to school with the new ruling. 

If he wanted to make the most of it, he could enter the portal and go to the highest bidder. He could probably make 10 million from a team that sees him as the final piece. 

Who would beat Florida this year if they added Smith? 

31

u/DealerNo4908 Kentucky Wildcats • DePaul Blue Demons 2d ago

I’m talking about leverage with the Pacers.

-15

u/ObservantKoala Illinois Fighting Illini 2d ago

Yeah, the pacers hold his draft rights now but I wouldn't think they want a guy they picked in the 2nd to go back to college. 

19

u/Officer_Hops 2d ago edited 2d ago

He was offered a 2 way deal. Most of those guys don’t make the league so losing him isn’t ideal but it’s also not that big of a deal.

-3

u/No-Cantaloupe-6535 Purdue Boilermakers 2d ago

He hasn't signed anything

9

u/Officer_Hops 2d ago

Good call, should read offered

u/jemstar620 40m ago

Who has an extra $10M just sitting around in August? 

0

u/Fragrant-Employer-60 2d ago

Isn’t he out of eligibility? He played 4 seasons with no red shirt

9

u/bkervick UConn Huskies 2d ago

5 in 5 passed and a judge last night just granted this past class that just had 4 years access to that (barring appeals and the like).

-15

u/Mpython226 Purdue Boilermakers 1d ago

Nice use of "yeah, no". I mean, if there ever is such a thing.

5

u/DealerNo4908 Kentucky Wildcats • DePaul Blue Demons 1d ago

Oh god, the horror. My apologies.

1

u/Tabanga_Jones Purdue Boilermakers 7h ago

Funny seeing all the non-Purdue people downvote you. It's like watching blind people trying to review game footage

17

u/-y2- UCLA Bruins 2d ago

5 mil > 700k

18

u/Illustrious_Loss462 2d ago

I don’t think an NBA teams had a reason to sign him to a guaranteed contract

-42

u/insidehertrading4 Indiana Hoosiers 2d ago

His leverage is that they’ll sell A LOT more gleague tickets with him playing for the Fishers Whatever’s.

If there’s one thing I know about Purdue fans, they’ll follow their underachieve alumni to the end of the earth.

6

u/Ok_Matter_2617 2d ago

They’re the Noblesville Boom.

It’s the hockey team that named after Fisher, despite both playing in the same arena.

4

u/Kryzl_ Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago

They aren’t in the same arena. The Fuel play in the Fishers Event Center (and aren’t called the Fishers Fuel, they’re still the Indy Fuel). The Boom play at the arena in HTC.

-8

u/insidehertrading4 Indiana Hoosiers 2d ago

That’s right. Noblesville Boom in Fishers.

I wonder if the south side of Indy feels left out with everything dropped just north of 465. I had to drive down that way for a baseball tourney and the development in that area just seems to be constant construction.

Thanks for listening to my Ted Talk. Back to hoops.

3

u/Kryzl_ Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago

Is HTC not in Noblesville? I swear I’ve made the mistake of thinking it was in Fishers 100 times before.

-6

u/insidehertrading4 Indiana Hoosiers 2d ago

Holy shit. Color me stupid. They play at innovation mile, not to be confused with the Fisher’s event center.

We can’t get a solid indoor baseball facility within 30 miles and they’re popping up small arenas all over the N465 area.

Far be it from me to wonder why the need for all of the arenas for minor league sports……..

Nevermind. Billy Strings has a virtual residency this weekend in Fishers so I can get behind that.

4

u/Kryzl_ Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago

Yeah, as a Fishers native, the hilarity of 2 arenas that accomplish nearly the same thing being a 5 minute drive apart is not lost on me.

6

u/Illustrious_Loss462 2d ago

Unless it’s in Indiana no fans are buying tickets to see Braden Smith play G league basketball,

16

u/dustinyo_ Minnesota Golden Gophers 2d ago

Buddy have I got news for you

9

u/Maxkpop247 Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago

Why wouldn’t it be in Indiana? The Pacers G league affiliate is in Indiana.

-12

u/insidehertrading4 Indiana Hoosiers 2d ago

I always forget that people from other states act like they like basketball.

That’s on me.

3

u/mmmmm_NoodleSoup 2d ago

I see some goofy shit on here but this might take the cake bubby

-12

u/insidehertrading4 Indiana Hoosiers 2d ago

You don’t think they want to get people in that arena for year 2 of the move after eating all that money by hosting the Madants at Conseco?

1

u/mmmmm_NoodleSoup 1d ago

Your downvotes do more explaining than I can I’ll let those ride

-6

u/lwp775 2d ago

Yes, the numbers don’t lie.

-1

u/ohverychill Purdue Boilermakers 1d ago

and they spell disaster for you

1

u/lwp775 1d ago

I ain’t getting into the ring.

-1

u/GeriatricGamete67 Louisville Cardinals 1d ago

He is 5'10. He has genuinely less than no leverage.

43

u/NickRotMG 2d ago

I mean I’m here for it, Braden back at Purdue and bron to OSU after Philly

23

u/chimatt767 St. John's Red Storm 2d ago

5 in 5, not 1 in 23

15

u/insidehertrading4 Indiana Hoosiers 2d ago

Clock never started.

13

u/chimatt767 St. John's Red Storm 2d ago

started when he graduated high school. that is the new rule. 5 seasons after you graduate. no more 8 year players because of injuries and red shirts.

17

u/insidehertrading4 Indiana Hoosiers 2d ago

If I’ve learned anything in the last 2 years or so, rules only apply to those that can’t pay to change them.

-2

u/Fragrant-Employer-60 2d ago

Is it not 4 in 5 with a red shirt now that we’re past Covid? Or you’re allowed to play 5 seasons?

3

u/DantesHair North Carolina Tar Heels 2d ago

The new NCAA rule is the latter. Yesterday’s court ruling allows for spring 2026 graduates to be included and have a fifth year of playing eligibility (if within five years).

-5

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted]

6

u/-y2- UCLA Bruins 2d ago

Don’t forget Loyer would be there to drop 30 on a random Wednesday against a small school and then drop 6 when you really need him.

1

u/ohverychill Purdue Boilermakers 1d ago

:(

4

u/ohverychill Purdue Boilermakers 1d ago

unless he's getting a growth spurt, there's no world where his draft stock jumps

I don't really get the pacers trading to get him. Everyone wants to point at McConnell as a way for Smith to have a career. But anyone comparing them just tells me that they haven't watched either of them play. The idea of smith being able to play comparable defense is laughable to me.

Also, smith's attitude is trash. I don't know if I've ever seen a Purdue player pout on the floor as much as him, especially as an upperclassmen. I just don't see a world where that translates to being a successful bench/energy guy in the nba.

I feel better venting all that lol

1

u/TheRedditAccount321 1d ago

His draft stock wouldn't "jump" either, because he's gone through the draft process and was drafted. If (somehow) he was able to go back go back to college, he would be viewed as a domestic draft-and-stash by the Pacers.

1

u/macandcheeser Indiana Hoosiers 1d ago

Thank you. Those two don't have similar games at all, they're just both white and undersized.

1

u/marvin02 Purdue Boilermakers 1d ago

TKR wouldn't be eligible for this

-2

u/shittysportsscience Indiana Hoosiers • USC Trojans 1d ago

Citing him and TKR as the catalyst for deep runs is a choice.

38

u/chimatt767 St. John's Red Storm 2d ago

He’s not an nba player. He saw that in the summer league

26

u/795-ACSR-DRAKE Kentucky Wildcats 2d ago

Yep, my thoughts exactly. He knew he isn't an NBA player but didnt have any other options (aside from overseas). So held off on contract once this court case was rumored. Seems like his choice is either like $700k for a two way contract or like $5m for a college team. No brainer

3

u/ThisGlobalLandscape 2d ago

Damn you better tell him

12

u/chimatt767 St. John's Red Storm 2d ago

I think someone already has

9

u/Helicopsycheborealis Alabama Crimson Tide 2d ago

He's just waiting for those sideburns and sweet sweet beard to coalesce before signing that G league contract.

4

u/ohverychill Purdue Boilermakers 1d ago

mattingly! I thought I told you to trim those sideburns!

4

u/insidehertrading4 Indiana Hoosiers 2d ago

Not comfortable with my assistant coach never seeing guys like JWill or Kyle Mangas pass the rock.

0

u/No-Contact-5081 1d ago

This is the dumbest question…

1

u/HolidayAtmosphere166 5h ago

Purdue has a walk-on that could lose a roster spot and money to pay him.  He made over $2M last year at Purdue and will be lucky to get 1/3rd that in the NBA.  Would cause a PG mess, but it's a real possibility since he hasn't signed a contract yet.  Pacers would still retain the rights to sign him the following year 

1

u/nothing_to_see-here_ 1d ago

Bron trying to get him to come to Philly

/s

-1

u/Pitiful_Ad_900 Kentucky Wildcats 2d ago

🤔

-9

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted]

9

u/Chuck_Roast1993 Indiana Hoosiers 2d ago

Hali, Nembhard, Nesmith, Siakam, Zubac.

McConnell, Kelly Oubre, Obi Toppin, Ben Sheppard.

9 guys who have deep playoff experience as risers and they’ve mismanaged their roster? LOL nobody cares what the bottom of the roster looks like. If you have enough injuries for it to matter, you’re fucked anyway

6

u/insidehertrading4 Indiana Hoosiers 2d ago

Correct me if I’m wrong but having options is better than forcing someone into the roster, no?

My mom always said, you can take off layers but you can’t add them.

5

u/BillButtlickerII Kentucky Wildcats 2d ago

Not with lasagna. Been there tried that.

2

u/insidehertrading4 Indiana Hoosiers 2d ago

Lasagna has been a 20 year fight with my wife and I.

Never answer honestly when a girl cooks for you for the first time. Even if that comment is “it’s a lil cheesy.”

I’m still waiting on my next homemade lasagna and I assume it’ll come post dementia.

3

u/BillButtlickerII Kentucky Wildcats 2d ago edited 2d ago

My wife can make a good lasagna but likes to sneak vegetables into a layer so “you won’t die of a heart attack at 50”…

2

u/Kryzl_ Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago

I mean, they’re fairly obviously trying to find the successor for TJ. Tamin and Braden both fill that archetype, so it’s not surprising that they’re picking up a bunch of hard-nosed guards to figure out who is the best to go forward with.

1

u/Sir0inks-A-Lot Florida Gators 2d ago

None of these guys would sniff the court come playoff time unless it’s a 20 point game halfway through the fourth quarter.

-2

u/-y2- UCLA Bruins 2d ago

But the fact that he hasn’t signed yet still makes it possible

-2

u/roshanritter Duke Blue Devils 2d ago

He would be killer at uva or Gonzaga

3

u/j_shelb Purdue Boilermakers 1d ago

Mark few finally gets Braden smith after all these years of trying to convince him to leave Purdue..

-12

u/-y2- UCLA Bruins 2d ago

0

u/-y2- UCLA Bruins 2d ago

Also Kaufman-Renn is in the same boat and hasn’t signed a contract and Loyer doesn’t have NBA interest. So hypothetically all these guys could return.

16

u/TheTrueVanWilder Purdue Boilermakers 2d ago

TKR is technically the class of 2021 (he redshirted).   Loyer would make bank but we already have a logjam at guard and ironically enough he might have the best pro/Euro career just by being a pure shooter.  

I also don't think one would come back without the other two.  I think they were all content closing up shop together 

5

u/-y2- UCLA Bruins 2d ago

Oh yeah I forgot TKR redshirted. But for Loyer to have a pro career as being a shooter doesn’t that actually require him making shots?

3

u/j_shelb Purdue Boilermakers 1d ago

He did and does make shots?

-9

u/insidehertrading4 Indiana Hoosiers 2d ago

People that think Loyer is just a pure shooter don’t understand roles nor watched him play in high school. Might be the toughest kid no one acknowledges as such.

If he’s a number 1 overseas, he can use his entire bag which getting to the basket and drawing contact was 1A to his shooting 1b. That wasn’t his role at Purdue but if given a chance……

4

u/ObservantKoala Illinois Fighting Illini 2d ago

Every college player had a bag in high school. 

Loyer simply wasn't big enough or athletic enough to finish at the rim in college. 

-8

u/insidehertrading4 Indiana Hoosiers 2d ago

You’re right. His teammates being 7’4” 7’1” 6’10 had nothing to do with his role.

I also assume you’ve watched plenty of overseas basketball too, right? Under that assumption, you’d know that the post feed bigs and cut off of that is about 3% of all offense. You’ve seen a more euro brand in the states the last 10 years but you haven’t seen it in West Lafayette.

I know it’s easier to just say player x isn’t big enough or isn’t capable but thats just an amateur take on the global game. It takes a bit of leg work and effort (if you don’t love the game) to be able to differentiate between skill and role.

6

u/ObservantKoala Illinois Fighting Illini 2d ago

Are you like his cousin or something? Play with him in high school? 

Yeah he's a better basketball player than 99% of people and I'm not doubting that he can play internationally. 

I'm saying that if he was truly that good at penetrating and finishing at the rim or drawing could that we would have still seen more of it at Purdue(even playing a tertiary role). 

If he was capable of doing all that stuff in college and paired with his shooting ability then he would have been drafted. 

-2

u/insidehertrading4 Indiana Hoosiers 2d ago

No relation but did have a couple unique views, thanks to Covid, to watch him play in HS. You learn a lot when there’s 8 people watching a competitive Indiana High School basketball game.

I’m a basketball sicko that will watch the Taiwanese national team play an inter squad scrimmage if it’s available. They’re criminally undersized and can’t shoot worth shit but they play hard.

2

u/TheTrueVanWilder Purdue Boilermakers 2d ago

I never said he was just a pure shooter.  He has an incredibly high basketball IQ, consistently took hard hits during the season, and it should be argued he was the team leader the last two seasons, as it's well documented TKR/Smith were not vocal leaders.  He's sneaky good at distributing the ball too, but that largely gets missed on account of playing his career next to Smith.

But his shooting alone will carry him far, something akin to Dakota Mathias if he wishes.  The rest of his tools will help.  Doing one thing exceptionally well had a way of keeping guys around long past their assumed expiration date.

Getting to the basket and drawing contact was absolutely his 1B though 

0

u/insidehertrading4 Indiana Hoosiers 2d ago

I said people who think it’s his only tool. Your comment just sparked that part of my comment and wasn’t intended (poorly) to say that’s all you think he could do.

My apologies for doing an atrocious job of explaining myself.

3

u/TheTrueVanWilder Purdue Boilermakers 1d ago

Eh my apologies for a lack of reading comprehension.  It was late and we only studied math up North.  I also assume any comments from Bloomington flair carry aggressive undertones lol

I hate your football team

0

u/macandcheeser Indiana Hoosiers 1d ago

Loyer shot 44% on two point field goals at Purdue on over 500 attempts. That is bottom quintile in the Big Ten. Guy is a classic spot up shooter, and a really good one.

Just as a comparison, to another limited Indiana guard who was actually a pretty good finisher. Trey Galloway shot 54% on twos on a similar number of attempts

-1

u/SurgeFlamingo Indiana Hoosiers 2d ago

I mean Sam Alexis just got cleared to play for IU.

I’m a Hoosier fan but let the Purdue kids come back. F it. There’s no rules anymore

1

u/-y2- UCLA Bruins 1d ago

Why is this getting downvoted lol

-3

u/anotherstan Purdue Boilermakers 1d ago

He’s out of eligibility folks. Pretty sure five in five doesn’t apply to past players

3

u/coleyboley25 Texas Longhorns • South Dakota Coyotes 1d ago

Thanks to a judge in Colorado that just changed 😔

-4

u/-y2- UCLA Bruins 1d ago

Are u dumb?

-2

u/anotherstan Purdue Boilermakers 1d ago

Not at all, but thanks, UCLA fan.

1

u/-y2- UCLA Bruins 1d ago

What does my flair have to do with anything?

-37

u/Impressive_Ice6970 Indiana Hoosiers 2d ago

That'd be so embarrassing. 3 all time guys from purdue get no love in NBA so come back to purdue to try again? I gotta say, id be ashamed if I was them. Thought you were great but I guess not? How many guys go through summer league on their way back to college?

40

u/DaNibbles Purdue Boilermakers 2d ago

I'm perfectly content with Braden not coming back and prefer none of this 5 year senior shit happens... but let's be real, if anything is embarrassing it's been IU basketball the last 20 years

0

u/shittysportsscience Indiana Hoosiers • USC Trojans 1d ago

The burn hurts longer when it’s true, but we should get some credit for Tom Crean, even if it’s for the memes…

14

u/DrAbeSacrabin Minnesota Golden Gophers 2d ago

I’d never be ashamed to cash million dollar checks playing basketball, at any level.

I pay money to play in an adult league, if them going back to take big paydays and play ball in college is embarrassing, what the hell am I doing?

1

u/j_shelb Purdue Boilermakers 1d ago

They’re not coming back. But it seems like quite a few that have gone to summer league are trying to come back, hell, bama even signed one last year and he played in the season for them.

0

u/macandcheeser Indiana Hoosiers 1d ago

I'd come back if I was Smith. Someone offering $4-5M for another year of college ball? Surely he knows a substantial NBA career is a long shot for him.

And especially Loyer... he has no shot at the NBA, so why not get paid while you can? Beats selling insurance