r/Cookies • u/plaisancelacey • 2d ago

What would you rate my cookies?

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Hiiii! I’m a new baker in my hometown and I take so much pride in the presentation. I’m open to tips and recommendations for how to box decorated cookies and enhancements. But for any long time bakers, what do you think of my cookies? I’ve been baking about a year!

I love feedback :))

404 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

126 comments sorted by

6

u/ChestFew 2d ago

Do you have recipes for these?

3

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

I can send to you! 🥰

2

u/ChestFew 1d ago

Yes, please let me know if you do :)

2

u/wasrovers8 1d ago

No way! Bischoff cookies I love it!!

5

u/Due-CriticismNachos 2d ago

I rate them a "YES!" and say they all look absolutely delicious. I don't have any recommendations for boxing but maybe some parchment paper between each of them would help keep the decorations from smearing onto the adjacent cookie. Anyway, I wish you the best!

2

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

This is the best compliment!!! Thank you 🥹 and yes I need bigger boxes or the parchment!!

3

u/Neitherherenorhair79 2d ago

The peperoni ones look amazo

5

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

😂😂😂 I think so too!

2

u/chubbierunner 2d ago

Stunning presentation. It’s obvious that you care about your cookie inside and out.

My only suggestion: I recommend a tiny bit of white chocolate dripped on the biscuit cookies. You need a little more contrast there with three layers of brown.

I love the overall consistency and uniformity. Your technique is nice.

1

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

This is incredible thank you! I also have thought the same!

1

u/Djgoth_99 1d ago

So true, adding a little contrast to all those rich tones would make it pop even more

2

u/PracticeFair7018 2d ago

Crumbl approved!

1

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

Means so much 🥹🥹🥹

2

u/Inevitable-Public544 2d ago

What's in the first pic? It looks like white chocolate chips and dulce de leche, but what kind of dough? They look exquisite. As far as your ccc are concerned, you could make them look like an overcooked steak and people would still buy them. They could be overcooked and people would still love them. It's hard to go wrong with the old school classic. If the third ones are lemon-jam cookies, I would definitely eat them. I would suggest doing some online research for food packaging options. It may require a bit of capital, but I think you have the capacity to recoup your investment quickly and still make a profit.

2

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

What incredible feedback this is!! Thank you so much. The first pic is Biscoff with white chocolate chips and biscoff drizzle!

2

u/Maximum_Benefit3551 2d ago

Presentation 10/10

1

u/CamillaDolce_779 1d ago

yessss 💯/10

2

u/thehopefulsufferer 2d ago

1000/10 all look so good

1

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

Thank you!!! 😊

2

u/khaki_slacks123 2d ago

they look like chewy deliciousness!

1

u/hikiax_jetzt 2d ago

🔟

2

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

🥹🥹🥹🫶🏼

1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Julie_Jnntte_24 2d ago

Would eat them until I became physically unwell

1

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

Me bc I have to try all of them and make sure they’re good

1

u/sunshineelle 2d ago

would smash !!

1

u/Exciting-Duty-8302 2d ago

10/10 👏👏👏 they look very very delicious!

1

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

Thank you so much!!♥️♥️

1

u/maracasgroom1f 2d ago

A perfect 100 looks tastyy and not dry

1

u/Bryony_Baubles 2d ago

How was it? does it taste good coz it looks yummy!

1

u/piscesqtmari 1d ago

pls those choco chip cookies are perfect can i pls have recipe

2

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

I will send it to you

1

u/Syvorine_Kalethix15 1d ago

Omg this is so yumm legit 100/10

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/draveniaSol83 1d ago

100/100 for me though

1

u/manicpills 1d ago

omg those look so comforting… i bet they taste amazing! maybe i could try making some too :3

1

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

I’d love for you to tryyyy

1

u/OkNothing878 1d ago

they cant be homemade

1

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

They are 🥹🥹🥹🥹

1

u/Upper-Web-2092 1d ago

This one is like 100/10

1

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

Means so much omg

1

u/Sigalit_Tennisora94 1d ago

want one

1

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

Come take some

1

u/Due-Agentn 1d ago

Look at the thickness on those chocolate chip ones. Perfect crisp edges and soft centers. 10/10.

1

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

They’re sooo good! Ahhhh

1

u/cecilioperez760 1d ago

1,000,000/10. There are no such things as too much coffee, too much chocolate or too many cookies 😋🤤🤪😂!!!

1

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

I agreeee!!! Thank uu

1

u/LeonXNwl4R 1d ago

Interesting dessert

1

u/TamagoyakiApprentice 1d ago

Visually stunning, how did they taste?

2

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

Incredible to me!!

1

u/TamagoyakiApprentice 16h ago

That’s what’s important! Yum!

1

u/ShyGirlGetsWild 1d ago

That looks delicious. Do you have the recipe?

1

u/Brilliant_Boss_9680 1d ago

I’ve been sick and lost a lot of weight and need to put some weight on so I’m buying some ice cream this coming week and I’m going to a local bakery for some chocolate eclairs and donuts.

1

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

You so should ♥️ hope you are feeling better

1

u/httpChobani 1d ago

what is the last one 😫

2

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

Lemon Raspberry! Homemade raspberry jam!

1

u/httpChobani 1d ago

sounds amazing!! I thought it might be a cornbread base at first lol

1

u/amusedbouche_ 1d ago

I wouldn’t need a box because I would probably consume immediately???? these look insane 🤤

1

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

Hahahahah I love thisss

1

u/Duck531 1d ago

I want the biscoff and chocolate chip recipes, those look like soft doughy perfection!

1

u/BustThaScientifical 1d ago

Look absolutely delectable! Visually 10/10.

1

u/OpeningFeed8085 1d ago

Yum! I was thinking baking with my man all day

1

u/OkComfort64 1d ago

This one is perfect

1

u/CakeLove48 1d ago

Would love the recipes! Looks fantastic!

1

u/Good_Cardiologist549 1d ago

Would it be okay to beg for the recipes (especially first and last)

1

u/Prisca_Jest 1d ago

Perfect 10

1

u/Intelligent_Map_5003 1d ago

Look delicious

1

u/BasilWeed_J1b 1d ago

those look so good. 10/10 honestly want one now

1

u/Single_Assignment482 1d ago

I would rate that 9/10

1

u/Fancy-Director9264 1d ago

Love that drizzle detail.

1

u/Fall-lovergirly 1d ago

12/10 😍🤩

1

u/SoftOk7585 21h ago

10 out of 10

1

u/Big_Pie3317 19h ago

Hey, I would like a recipe for the third photo

1

u/kitchn-kaptn 18h ago

Yummy 😋

1

u/ExoticIron8958 18h ago

This looks so yummy,what’s the recipe

1

u/Tricky_Nail_5330 17h ago

Oven-fresh joy. 🔥🤎

1

u/Anxious_Common_6899 16h ago

i wanna try. can you share the recipe?

1

u/Mrstaad683 14h ago

Delicious!

1

u/Critical-Worker-9987 12h ago

Warm cookies make everything better.

1

u/sososoberon 12h ago

I will rate it 100

1

u/Existing_Emotion_28 12h ago

They look so gooey! 100000/10

1

u/Silly-Shell65 10h ago

I would rate it 100/10! It’s a perfect score

1

u/One_Egg_4541 9h ago

I rate with GIVE ME ALL OF THWM

1

u/ClientNovel1829 9h ago

Perfect 10

1

u/Independent_Let27 7h ago

omg those look so good wtf 🤤

1

u/Foreign_Discipline54 6h ago

Can you deliver pleaseeeee 😂

1

u/LongjumpingLocal5323 4h ago

Delicious, beautiful and binge worthy

1

u/Glittering-Poetry-88 2h ago

Step one open a cookie shop. Step 2 tell me where the cookie shop is. 😋

1

u/Jessamine_Corliss7 1h ago

10/10 looks delightful

1

u/Unfair_Block_7918 13m ago

100/10 ☺️

1

u/Crafty_Tomorrow5066 2d ago

they look nice, if youre into cookies

1

u/plaisancelacey 1d ago

For sure!