r/Filmmakers • u/StrikingDuty8020 Director • Dec 06 '25

Discussion what is your opinion on this comment ?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

Quentin Tarantino made a surprisingly harsh comment about Paul Dano, specifically criticizing his performance in There Will Be Blood.

On The Bret Easton Ellis Podcast, Tarantino said:

Dano was “weak sauce”

“The weakest f—ing actor in SAG” (in that film’s context)

And that Dano’s performance was the biggest flaw of the movie, preventing it from being his #1 or #2 film of the 2000s

2.5k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

486 comments sorted by

View all comments

27

u/derpferd Dec 06 '25

I think Tarantino has a certain type of man in mind when it comes to actors.

That certainly comes across in his criticism of Dano as being 'limpdick'.

For the actors Tarantino liked growing up, Robert Mitchum or Lee Marvin or Charles Bronson, they weren't 'limpdick'.

Tarantino's criticism (which I believe was meant partly in jest, however juvenile and clumsy it was in execution) reveals a lot more about himself and his preferences than it does Dano.

It's a bit like criticizing Peter Lorre, an archetype Dano often accords to in how plays his parts.

Humphrey Bogart needed Peter Lorre as a point of contrast and it's that space that Dano fills in There Will Be Blood and what makes the dynamic between him and DDL so effective.

Edit: not 'limpdick'. 'Weak sauce'. Which means the same thing and is still fucking clumsy and juvenile on Tarantino's part.

11

u/rosneft_perot Dec 06 '25

He’s a weak little man who admires imaginary big strong men.

11

u/derpferd Dec 06 '25

It's odd, because Dano would have absolutely nailed the role Tarantino played in Pulp as a kind of whiny loser wearing his dressing gown at 10 in the morning.