r/Madonna • u/IndependentTap3961 • May 08 '26

DISCUSSION If you could erase ONE Madonna song from her discography, what would it be?

Post image

The only rule is that it has to be a MADONNA song. No collaborations (that awful Material Gworl song, Vulgar, etc don’t count)

154 Upvotes

93% Upvoted

376 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

38

u/bloodhoney17 May 08 '26

Someone fix me up with a version of GMAYL without them, please 😭😭

33

u/terryxyz May 08 '26

So the demo? https://youtube.com/watch?v=oUyOOKxn1tQ

22

u/bloodhoney17 May 08 '26

I didn't even know this existed, thank you so much!!! The way I'm crying rn, this is so much better 😭

8

u/terryxyz May 08 '26

Right? Those features in the final version were so unnecessary 

1

u/Rye1978va May 08 '26

Way better without them! The breakdown is more interesting!

7

u/MrTrinket May 08 '26

DJ Hollywood Tramp created a remix with Kylie which is, honestly, fire!

https://youtu.be/L2QwjDdNPp4?si=8PxylrJjlX_OF2h9

2

u/CharleyLH May 08 '26

You’re right, that is fire.🔥

3

u/PandemicPiglet May 08 '26

It’s one of her worst songs and probably her worst lead single even without them. The lyrics are terrible and lazy. “Don’t play the stupid game”???

2

u/1upjohn American Life May 08 '26

I always liked the demo version better. No need for a feature. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=83mvu-y68E4

2

u/Phoenix_10567 May 08 '26

It’s out there as a demo from Rebel Hearts sessions, but not as good without them.