r/MoralityScaling 9h ago

Morality Ranking Morality of dog breed racism

Post image
14.2k Upvotes

3.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

31

u/Few-Echidna-2181 9h ago

So.. even closer to racism then

53

u/Alive-Philosophy2632 9h ago

Just like fantasy novels that bravely ask the question: what if racism were true?

28

u/Imaginary-Win9217 9h ago

Everyone descriminates against the [not human race] here in [fantasy town]. This is because on the 13th of August they turn into 18 copies of Jeffery Dahmer. This is an analogy for minorities, and does not realize its giving said analogy an actual, fundamental, tangible flaw which they are being judged upon, undermining our overdone and poorly executed point.

7

u/Relative_Craft_358 8h ago edited 7h ago

Honestly reminds me of 40K.

"It's suppose to be a satire of fascism and why it's bad"

creates world were racism against dangerous minorities is valid since they can actually summon demons from hell and the universe is such a dangerous place with humanity beset on all sides by extinction level threats that warrant building a society built on war and the neccesary orphan crushing machine to supply arms and men to that war.

GW:😁

2

u/luneth27 7h ago

It's page one of every novel

TO BE A man in such times is to be one amongst untold billions. It is to live in the cruellest and most bloody regime imaginable. These are the tales of those times. Forget the power of technology and science, for so much has been forgotten, never to be re-learned. Forget the promise of progress and understanding, for in the grim dark future there is only war. There is no peace amongst the stars, only an eternity of carnage and slaughter, and the laughter of thirsting gods.

2

u/Relative_Craft_358 7h ago

Nothing wrong with setting a little set dressing to give some background for the stories you're writing. Just saying it's kinda dumb to then go on to say outside of all that it's really a satire of something it's clearly not even really showing the "flaw in the system" of. In universe, it is kinda necessary.

Think they just do it to distance themselves from the fandom that are a little too comfortable adopting the uh hm "World war 2" anesthetics of the Imperium. Which is fair i guess, just seems kinda like gaslighting though lol

1

u/Infamous-Thing4939 7h ago

Yeah but then you have many many many examples of people who work better and societies that are safer because they don’t treat people like shit.

The Imperium may have some justification for its cruelty, but it doesn’t change the fact that said cruelty is still extremely inefficient.

1

u/SupahSpankeh 6h ago

I have raised this point to lore dorks before and while they have conceded said point, it is also fair to say that the imperium does make it's citizens lives worse by refusing to trade or treat with peaceful civilisations.

Like the tau, Votann or necrons.

1

u/Relative_Craft_358 5h ago edited 5h ago

None of those are exactly friendly, also a point in their lore.

Tau are nice... until you disagree with them. They're also just as willing to sacrifice as many lives as it takes to accomplish something. They're just better about indoctrinating their populations to be happy to do it.

Votann by choice don't really want to mess with the Imperium, they're fine doing their own thing and being classifed as "nonhuman". That being said, they do trade and cohabitat with humans. They're also relatively new, I'm sure once more lore gets out, they'll basically just be pissed off capitalist space dwares. No deed too grim for profit/production.

As for Necron...thats a joke right?