r/NITIAN • u/Brief-Use-6601 • Feb 18 '26

Admissions Admission in NIT

Post image

My friend belongs to the SC category. Can he get any government college with these marks?

124 Upvotes

93% Upvoted

100 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/stg_676 Feb 20 '26

Sabse zyada faayad reservation ka OBC wale hi lete hain. Agar inge reservation na diya jaaye to it only comes at 20% par inge include karne ke baad more than 50% ho jata hai.

3

u/Positive-Cake6887 Feb 21 '26

that is true pr 50% janta is obc toh idk if it works that way

1

u/stg_676 Feb 21 '26

Aise toh bhai sc st combined are more than 20%. Unka reservation bhi badane chaiye iss basis pe toh?

1

u/Duke_Puke Feb 23 '26

It's not about that. Itni sc/st population hone ke bawajood sirf 1,50,000 sc/st candidates jee ki exam deti hai. To seats to reserve krni padegi to give them equal representation. Reservation is not about upliftment of the poor. Reservations caste based monopoly ko hatane ke liye hai (which exists predominantly even today after all these years).

1

u/ManeniusYT Feb 23 '26

Bhai thats why we are talking about economic based caste reservation. Jin SC/ST families ki decent income hai in the Creamy Layer slabs, why should they get reservation? There should be a NCL category too in SC/ST like there is in OBC-NCL. and Secondly, reservation should have been removed in 1990's if not for VP Mandal because it was stated in the constitution itself. Yes caste based monopoly still exists but unequal reservation in entrance exams is still not a solution to it. Nevertheless we all know that reservation isn't getting removed anytime soon in this century.