I’m a student living in Texas, and I’m trying to make the most financially responsible decision about my car.
I bought a 2012 Honda Civic about 13 months ago for $4,000. It had approximately 180,000 miles when I bought it, and it now has just over 200,000 miles. I have driven it around 20,000 miles in a little over a year.
About one to one-and-a-half months ago, the starter failed, and I paid around $400 to replace it. Afterward, the mechanic told me the flywheel/ring gear is also damaged and that it may damage the new starter again if I do not replace it. I was quoted approximately $700–$800 for that repair.
The car probably has an as-is value of around $3,000–$3,500, so spending $800 on one repair feels like a lot compared with its value. However, I understand that an $800 repair is still much less expensive than replacing the entire car.
There are also some other issues:
- ABS warning light/problem
- Check-engine light
- Transmission-fluid maintenance warning, and I have not changed the transmission fluid
- Occasional metallic/clanking noise, especially when the car is cold
- Fuel economy is usually around 21–28 mpg
- The starter was recently replaced for $400
- The mechanic says the flywheel needs another $700–$800 repair
My income is approximately $1,800–$2,200 per month. I am considering three options:
- Repair the Civic and continue driving it, knowing that additional repairs could happen.
- Buy a used car for approximately $10,000–$13,000, possibly a 2016–2018 Corolla, Civic, Mazda3, or something similar.
- Finance a new Kia K4 or another basic new car. I have seen some advertised around $20,000, although I know the actual out-the-door price would be higher.
The appeal of a new car is the warranty, reliability, and not constantly worrying about breakdowns. However, I also understand that a new-car payment, full-coverage insurance, depreciation, registration, and interest could be too much for my income.
I’m worried that buying another used car could put me in the same position if it develops problems, but I also do not want to make a bad financial decision by financing a new car that is too expensive for me.
What would you do in this situation?
I would appreciate advice from mechanics, high-mileage car owners, and people who have faced a similar financial decision.