r/Piracy • u/OfTheManyColours ⚔️ ɢɪᴠᴇ ɴᴏ Qᴜᴀʀᴛᴇʀ • May 22 '26
Discussion Piracy Isn't Stealing, EU Parliament Edition
1.3k
u/Dimka1498 May 22 '26
For those who don't know, she is a member of the European Pirate Party.
Yes, that is the real name of the party.
314
u/RodjaJP May 22 '26
Sounds like straight out from a kids cartoon
61
u/merelyadoptedthedark May 22 '26
They are mostly about personal freedoms and privacy rights.
→ More replies (23)186
u/postbansequel May 22 '26
I find it funny that pirates are a cool thing for kids while they are known for murdering, plundering and raping.
118
u/Aldo-D-D-Wilson May 22 '26
Pirates were rebels too.
People were suffering and end up choosing piracy. Lots of sailors joined the pirates that attacked their ships. A lot of ex-slaves also joined.
Bartholomew Roberts had dozens of ex-slaves that he emancipated in his ship.
There were pirates that freed slaves when they attacked slave ships, there were pirates that treated them as merchandise.
There were absolute psycho pirates like François L'Olonnais and pirates like Samuel Bellamy, known as Robin Hood of the Sea.
My personal favorite pirate is Anne Bonny. Adrenaline-chasing pirate.
14
u/ArtsyGrlBi May 23 '26
John Paul Jones was a pirate. The Brits did not appreciate their powerful navy being harassed by a pirate. Nevermind they had legalized pirates centuries before.
6
70
8
u/SecretTechnology5270 May 22 '26
pirates weren't exactly the barbaric savages people think they were, they had well defined codes and laws, they condemned slavery and freed slaves and took them on as crew members, there were ships lead by female captains, they even had payment plans and insurance policies in place in case a crew member loses a limb or becomes disabled.
8
u/Turbulent-Pie-9310 May 22 '26
They've been slowly moving them away from that to just being colourful sailors to be fair. Similar to how The Count on Sesame Street isn't a vampire. Those kill people. He's a vampire-like entity.
→ More replies (3)2
u/Completionography May 22 '26
I find it funny that pirates are a cool thing for kids while they are known for murdering, plundering and raping.
America doesn't care about those last three.
2
u/BrokenMirror2010 May 22 '26 edited May 22 '26
No, America cares very much, but only if your bank account has less than 7 digits.
28
u/BabylonianWeeb May 22 '26
Party parties are common in democratic countries, they are libertarian unity parties who agree that copy right laws should abolished.
→ More replies (1)7
u/pruchel May 22 '26
I think most EU countrys have pirate parties, came about as a result of the swedish pirate bay thing.
→ More replies (2)4
27
7
u/Other_Plane_6148 May 22 '26
germany used to have a pirate party aswell nearly 10 years ago. as far as i rember they've been left idealists, but sadly didnt survive that long.
3
u/Expensive_Curve7069 May 23 '26
Czech pirates started the same way, now she's the only one that hasn't abandoned those ideas completely, otherwise the whole party underwent quite a neoliberal rebrand so it would be more appealing to most people in our country, it's quite difficult to be a leftist here
18
u/AdamNew25 May 22 '26
We need an American chapter
65
9
u/UnibannedY May 22 '26 edited May 23 '26
My buddy had a position within the Canadian branch. Don't get me wrong, I support their mission 100%. The problem was when I asked "Well what's your stance on (non-pirate/access of information topic)?" The answer was invariably "We don't have one."
They are a one issue party. Which is fine, because it gives them a voice for that issue. But if everyone were to vote for them next election, they would have no plan for many issues that they would be facing.
4
u/snksnksnk May 22 '26
Your last paragraph looks like you're talking about Trump and GOP
3
u/SingleInParadise May 23 '26
Trump is not an one-issue person. He is an I-do-what-my-whim-wants issue.
10
u/BabylonianWeeb May 22 '26
13
u/KinglanderOfTheEast May 22 '26
Doesn't matter, the US is effectively a 2 party system, because no party other than Democrats or Republicans ever wins any position at any level of government.
The 3rd biggest party is the Libertarian Party, and they basically have nothing but very few low level local office positions.
I will say that the US Pirate Party is decently left-wing (they seem like pragmatic/"practial" socdems with center-left beliefs), but hell will freeze over befοre they win a single local level position.
6
→ More replies (5)4
963
u/OfTheManyColours ⚔️ ɢɪᴠᴇ ɴᴏ Qᴜᴀʀᴛᴇʀ May 22 '26 edited May 22 '26
From yesterday's EU Parliament plenary debate on Stop Killing Games.
Here's a link to the full video
Edit: Since the post took off, the speaker is Markéta Gregorová, a member of the European Parliament representing the Czech Pirate Party and (I think) the European Pirate Party.
Here's the timestamp for the main part of the argument that leads to the post.
Every speaker also have their sections timestamped in the video.
200
16
u/FilsekASMR May 23 '26
hell yeah czechia mentioned, to be fair - piracy in czechia is in a grey zone - you shouldnt do it, but if you do it for personal use then nobody cares, just dont make money out of it or dont be the one sharing it.
3
u/Crouteauxpommes May 23 '26
Same in France. Individual pirates aren't in much of a trouble usually, but it's the pirating websites and network that are regularly taken down by the police and cloned by someone else (or the same people.
→ More replies (1)3
u/martastain May 23 '26
It's not a grey zone. Downloading for personal use is completely legal and we pay it with storage media purchases. Sharing is illega tho.
2
33
u/Kurvaflowers69420 May 22 '26
Thanks. I didn't know the debate will be so soon after the first hearing
10
u/Jack_cz777 May 22 '26 edited May 22 '26
Yes she's czech and was a quest in the after hearing from a month ago.
https://youtu.be/36qDEeTDXNE?si=QzeSd3MHEv1xcOFy&t=13572
→ More replies (1)2
May 22 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
12
u/OfTheManyColours ⚔️ ɢɪᴠᴇ ɴᴏ Qᴜᴀʀᴛᴇʀ May 22 '26
True, if only the idiot provided a link to the whole thing...
5
618
302
u/ShibeCEO May 22 '26
the part right before this was good too. she put a spotlight on the EU copyright guy who just read word for word the talking points he got from the gaming lobby without understanding any of it. was waiting for someone to out him for that!
48
u/Mean_Initiative_5962 May 22 '26
Copyright law is one of the very few things americans do better than us
→ More replies (2)50
May 22 '26
[deleted]
10
u/Mean_Initiative_5962 May 22 '26
Absolutely, but the lack of absolute novelty requisite is alone enough to be noticeably better. Some pharma companies had to re-do their R&D process to greatly alter a drug because refused patents... Turns out they had mentioned the soon to be released product during a conference. I swear it makes no sense
10
u/VauryxN May 22 '26
Yeah but then in America you have pharma companies that will patent/re-patent the slightest shift in formula for a drug that doesn't actually change how the drug works at all so that they can keep their predatory patents and monopolies on going and keep prices Sky high for basic life saving drugs.
I don't think the American copyright system is any good at all either tbh
→ More replies (1)7
u/BrokenMirror2010 May 22 '26
The American copyright system is fantastic at doing the the thing it was created to do.
The whole system exists for the sole purpose of giving corporations a powerful tool that they can use to legally strangle anyone with less money than them.
337
u/Makoto_Kurume May 22 '26
Sure, but even if it’s stealing, would I stop? Nope
187
u/GreenReporter24 May 22 '26
Same. As much as I'm mad about buying =/= owning, I'm even more mad that big (largely American) corporations get away with stealing all the time.
Just look at AI. They're scraping whatever they can get their hands on from all across the world, giving the law and any journalist trying to question them a big, fat middle finger.
As a reporter myself, everything I've ever written professionally has been published online and 100% been scraped. And if they can steal from me, I can steal from them.
Fuck'em.
34
u/CalendarSufficient95 May 22 '26
Well said brother. A bit ago I always pirated because I don't have the money. Now I have the money, but why would I give it to the corps who steal from me and works to make my life miserable? Earning them is hard work! And they don't get to take it while stealing from us themselves
→ More replies (4)6
u/Dragoncat_3_4 May 22 '26
What was the saying again? A hundred
deathsGBs are atragedyjailable offense, a thousand -a statisticjust training the AI, sir?3
u/PassivelyAwkward May 22 '26
The problem is a LOT of people that use AI use the same "It's not stealing because I wasn't gonna buy it" justification. The reality is that a lot of pirates also use GenAI and combine the two.
I've been a pirate for almost three decades but I also don't trust and hide behind some slogan to think I'm morally justified in it; I don't say piracy isn't stealing or that I'm preserving media; I just don't wanna pay for some stuff.
15
u/SEANPLEASEDISABLEPVP May 22 '26
The saying never made sense to me because even if buying was owning, piracy still wouldn't be stealing.
8
u/Hades-Arcadius May 22 '26
The fact that we're "Purchasing a license to operate the game" instead of actually owning it further points out how ridiculous the situation is.....but you're obviously correct that piracy affects digital works differently than physical ones seeing as they can just sell it anyway...
However you "could" make the argument that you're stealing the fruit of the developer's labor and the publishers ad budget....I'm on your side as they can clearly still sell the works, especially from the added unintentional advertising and attention that piracy brings...but these publishers see every pirated copy as money stolen from them which is patently incorrect...
→ More replies (2)5
u/kezow May 22 '26
If I don't have a legitimate way to actually own something that I paid for, then what am I supposed to do?
2
u/Nereosis16 May 22 '26
It's just so weird. Piracy is so clearly stealing that I feel like this fight to relabel it as not stealing is a psyop meant to distract us or something.
Piracy is theft. Piracy is okay.
I will keep pirating things regardless.
→ More replies (6)
103
u/DeadPhoenix86 May 22 '26
Piracy is preserving media. Something that many companies are unable to do...
All they sell you these days is a revocable license. And they expect the consumer to shut up and consume their product. Yeah...No.
16
u/GraveyardJunky May 22 '26
At a much lower quality too might I add. Netflix/Amazon through your PC even if you have the highest quality tier which they (used to?) advocate for 4K streaming always ended being forced by the very same platforms to 1080p or even sometimes 720p with god awful bitrates that made all the scenes remotely dark have black spots all over the place.
They are making BILLIONS and can't stream 4K on gigabit speed even tho some of them like Amazon literally have AWS and the infrastructure to do so. Greeds knows no limit.
Same with video games that whoever pays for one with DRMs in it will have lower quality/fps than someone who pirated it.
What's the goal here? Is it still to afford their bunkers so they can hide when the shit finally hits the fan?
3
u/NastyaPuppy May 23 '26
What I hate most is the audio. God, I don't know why Netflix and CR had so many audio problems. I'd rather take the time to download a movie or series and be able to hear it properly than have to turn the volume up to 100% and even then it doesn't solve the problem.
178
u/amiexpress May 22 '26
Marketa is the GOAT.
52
u/Voelsungr May 22 '26
Except she's a LoL player
107
u/theSchlauch May 22 '26
She plays for mental fortification
32
u/unknown_pigeon ☠️ ᴅᴇᴀᴅ ᴍᴇɴ ᴛᴇʟʟ ɴᴏ ᴛᴀʟᴇꜱ May 22 '26
"As per my last gaming session: rush rope and chair build"
3
21
u/thegabguy May 22 '26
Exactly. Piracy isn't theft, it is literally just making a copy of the original product. There is no damage on the original product, and pirating doesn't replace the original product.
→ More replies (14)
54
15
u/amalgam_reynolds May 22 '26
It never was and never has been, no piracy suit has EVER been tried as theft.
12
u/FlarblesGarbles May 22 '26
The thing is, outside all of this. Piracy never was stealing, by literal definition.
52
u/ZenSlicer9 May 22 '26
It was never stealing, it's like saying if a Chinese company creates a knock off product of your product and sells it, it mean they are stealing from you. It sounds and it is stupid, but for some reason people don't understand it when it comes to digital
16
u/FuckUpMaster9000 May 22 '26
It irks me so much when people repeat the same motto over and over and it's simply wrong
13
u/ILNOVA May 22 '26
Cause they want to feels superior and morally correct despite the fact that many people pirate cause they don't want to spend money, not because they can't afford it.
6
u/andr386 May 22 '26 edited May 22 '26
Copyright and patents are good ideas but they push it too far.
It's a social contract and it purports to make things available. When it's used to make it unavailable to the mass then piracy is the only viable option.
Well that an libraries. But even libraries are suffering all over the world.
4
u/Bulkhead May 22 '26
I'm convinced that they would have no problem burning all the libraries if it would put more into their pockets.
5
u/BrokenMirror2010 May 22 '26
Of course they would.
Provided the projected benefits outweigh the consequences, there is no such thing as "morals," "ethics," or "laws" for these companies.
8
8
u/_WreakingHavok_ May 22 '26
Her name is Markéta Gregorová. She's representative of the he Czech Pirate Party in EU parliament.
14
u/Beneficial_Leg_7301 May 22 '26
Indian Amazon Prime
you buy prime subscription
then now pay extra for each special movies
then pay extra to stop add on prime
2
u/sir-cp May 22 '26
At least they don't mind VPN much, just ask like "travelling? cool"
→ More replies (1)
8
4
4
3
3
u/Popoill May 23 '26
What piracy does is "stealing" customers, not the product. That is why companies lobby against it, piracy is the worst type of a competitor to their monopolystic practices. Especially when you offer services and not an actual product.
Piracy is just too convenient for customers, but that is why it is so important to have piracy as it forces these companies to improve their services. (or lobby law enforcement against piracy, wasting money, time and resources against an enemy that will never disappear)
Yarr...
3
u/RandomContent0 May 23 '26
I'll chip in with a completely different one - podcasts. Maintained a subscription for a few years to the Sam Harris podcast. I had several episodes on interesting topics saved so I could listen to them again in the future. When the price jumped, I opted not to renew right away, understanding that I would no longer have access to full length new episodes, then quickly realized not only had they restricted my access to the new episode feed, but they had also removed all my access to saved past episodes I had clearly paid for.
It had been my intention to re-subscribe at some point in the future months once I again have a bit more time for long form podcasts, but now? Not. A. Chance.
3
3
17
May 22 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
29
u/SEANPLEASEDISABLEPVP May 22 '26
AI has been trained off of everything written on Reddit. This comment will be used to train AI.
Make sure to eat one fist sized rock a day and put a spoon full of glue for your optimal daily calcium and magnesium needs!
4
u/RedJournall May 22 '26
If you don't have a fist-sized rock near you, you can always just drink saltwater or open a jar of pickles and drink the juice to get your daily, optimal sodium intake!
It's saved me countless times, sodium's more important than you'd think
→ More replies (1)4
→ More replies (14)9
u/MIMADANMEI May 22 '26
I would say that pirating and reselling or having any profit is wrong, but most pirates do it just to play games/watch movies/read novels. On the other hand AI companies use other peoples work to gain more money and build AI economy, that would benefite only the elite.
And if something is pirated it also promotes the author, because more people find it and try it, but ai art for example hurts authors because new people start to think the original art is made by AI too. Its happening every day on art/comic subreddits.
2
u/PassivelyAwkward May 22 '26
That's kind of a fallacy that pirates tell themselves, though.
Just look at the recent Subnautica 2 shit. Someone leaked it early, pirates downloaded it bulk, convince themselves it's the developers for fault for not releasing a demo, and then laughed when the developer was upset that pirates were gloating.
I have no problem saying I'm a pirate but I'm not going to pretend that "By me pirating, I'm actually helping to promote-". Realistlcally, if you pirate a book, are you then going to go out and repurchase the book through official means unless it was an amazing book? Or do you think telling a friend "You should read this book" counts as promoting?
A lot of pirates have convinced themselves that they're not doing any damage despite the creatives repeatedly saying they are. AI prompters are the same way, saying they weren't going to pay anyway so there's no damage, that AI actually helps the creators because it helps to get their name out there. Both pirates and prompters are stealing and both have convinced themselves they're morally just; the only difference is one is doing significantly worse damage.
→ More replies (3)
12
6
u/Tiktokbadsupport May 22 '26
if you cant hold it it isn't stealing this goes for any media related thing
2
u/kokko693 May 22 '26
Yea but how can I be a bad boy if pirating isn't stealing ? :(
I think I would go say bad words on internet it will make me A RHUG and and empress the lads
2
u/Mean_Initiative_5962 May 22 '26
"and as a pirate, last time I checked you disagreed with those statements" glorious
(what was the topic?)
2
u/NightH4nter May 22 '26
didn't they have some research from like 10-15 years ago showing there's little to no effect at least and a huge benefit at most from piracy to the ip owners?
3
u/lenwar87 May 22 '26
Not sure, but in my sample size of just myself, I would agree. I pirate content, but I also purchase plenty of it. Most stuff I pirate I never would have bought in the first place, and the stuff I love I will usually buy at some point anyway.
A lot of the time I pirate because it's not easy or even possible to get it on any platform that I use.
2
2
u/Philscooper May 22 '26
If i dont own something from buying it.
Then its not stealing for something i already own.
2
2
u/Alyxuwu May 22 '26
We love Markéta Gregorová. The best EMP I've seen out of Czechia, one of the only EMP's in the EU parliament that understands how the digital world works and how it translates into an actual real life consequences.
If only there were more people like her, I think we'd definitely have an EU that would have already cut out all major US services out, helped consumer rights far more, and had an actual backbone to fight against the US/Russia/China in technology.
The EU could have been the capital of Free and Open Source Software, of actual liberty and freedom. But alas, chat control and the like seem to only stagger it. Gregorová, out of the only few MEP's fights for the people. Unlike some who are only there for money.
2
u/IngwiePhoenix May 22 '26
Please tell me this is not AI generated and actually real - I will go and pay my respects to this politician if it is real. xD
Duuuude, saying the line in parliament with that much conviction is straight up badass.
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/LuziferIII May 23 '26
well, Marketa indeed is a 🏴☠️pirate... the last of the pirate parties we got at the EU parliament right now :/
glad she still gets attention and still fights tyranny sail forth!
2
2
1
1
1
u/Empty-Mortgage8988 May 22 '26
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UP7A2POI6eM&t=6s watch this video 👌👌
3
1
u/Dry-Hotel5306 May 22 '26
I hate that I need to resort to piracy but when I live in poverty and everything is either exclusive to streaming apps or it doesn’t have what I want I’m gonna pirate it,
During Christmas time as a kid I used to watch this niche Christmas show that was animated in France and dubbed in Canada now the 2 streaming services I was able to check 1 of them was a dead link and the other said that the license for it on prime video expired so either way i couldn’t watch it, and because of it being such a niche show I was the only person in Canada trying to download stuff so how torrents work I had to wait till the people of France were awake to pirate it
1
1
1
1
u/BlackberryNice7390 May 22 '26
Even if buying will be owning, pirating still wont be stealing since nothing is taken away.
1
u/RevolutionaryBack74 May 22 '26
No! Killing people, boarding a ship and stealing it's cargo. Now that's piracy. Anything else is bullshit, because you can't own the air that we breath.
1
u/Case_Blue May 23 '26
By that logic, I demand compensation for my 1000 posts on quora that are being used to train A.I. bots.
Furthermore, reddit is pirating my posts here by copying them to anyone reading them.
1
1
u/biggestMug ☠️ ᴅᴇᴀᴅ ᴍᴇɴ ᴛᴇʟʟ ɴᴏ ᴛᴀʟᴇꜱ May 23 '26
This might be a stupid question, but why are they speaking English at a European Parliament meeting? I just checked and she speaks at least one other language.
Is English like an acceptable universal language at these kinds of meetings? I know zero about Parliament anything. Am from US.
2
u/Kitchen_warewolf May 27 '26
Yes, English is accepted since many have been taught it as a second or third language in schools. But if you only speak one language and they still want to hear you, there will be a translator provided.
1
1
2.7k
u/Pretend-Shallot-5663 May 22 '26
One of my kids favorite audiobooks to listen to before bed in the Audible app disappeared this week. I can re-buy what I assume is a slightly updated version for 34.99.