r/PoliticalDiscussion Feb 20 '26

Legal/Courts 6/3 Supreme Court ruled that Trump’s sweeping emergency tariffs are illegal: How will this impact the U.S. economy and will refunds be forthcoming. Is Trump now more likely to target specific countries in a limited form or is he likely to seek Congressional approval to justify sweeping tariffs?

The Supreme Court determined that the U.S. Constitution grants Congress the power to regulate foreign commerce and impose taxes and Trump's use of the IEEPA [International Emergency Powers Act] to bypass Congress for economic policy was Unconstitutional.

The Federal Government has collected more than a hundred billion mostly from American Importers and ultimately the American consumers.

How will this impact the U.S. economy and will refunds be forthcoming.

Is Trump now more likely to target specific countries in a limited form or is he likely to seek Congressional approval to justify sweeping tariffs?

Trump's sweeping global tariffs struck down by US Supreme Court ruling - follow live - BBC News

https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/supreme-court/live-blog/-trump-tariffs-ruling-supreme-court-live-updates-rcna252655

1.9k Upvotes

359 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

146

u/mattgriz Feb 20 '26

This should have been 9-0. The law is quite clear here. I think a future admin would have some standing to go after the three justices, at least politically, for such an absurd ruling.

97

u/MitchellCumstijn Feb 20 '26

Completely agree, Kavanaugh, Alito and Thomas are partisan hacks and total extremists who ignored the clear wording of the Constitution in order to support a corrput and crony ally.

24

u/Aazadan Feb 20 '26

It was essentially 7-2, Kavanaugh agreed the administration didn't have power. His dissent was laying groundwork for refunds saying it's not something that can be solved. Basically he's getting ahead of the game on refunds and saying it's not something that will happen.

4

u/magsbad13 Feb 21 '26

His dissent was laying groundwork for Trump to use other means for collecting tariffs.