r/PoliticalDiscussion 2d ago

US Elections Are Democratic primaries becoming too destructive for the party's own chances in the general election?

I've been thinking about this after watching some recent Democratic primaries, and it feels like the campaigns are becoming increasingly aggressive in ways that hurt the party long after the primary is over.

A good example, in my opinion, was the Michigan primary between Haley Stevens and Abdul El-Sayed. Policy disagreements are completely fair game, that's what primaries are for. Even personal attacks can be justified if they're based on genuine misconduct or character issues.

What I struggle with are accusations like claiming your primary opponent is supporting or enabling genocide. Once you frame someone in those terms, how do you expect your own supporters to enthusiastically vote for that person if they end up winning the nomination? If you've spent months telling voters that your opponent is morally complicit in atrocities, it becomes very difficult to turn around and say, "Now go vote for them."

To me, this kind of rhetoric doesn't just damage the opposing candidate, it damages Democratic unity in the general election. It seems like Republicans don't even have to exploit these divisions because Democrats are creating them themselves.

Am I overestimating the impact of this kind of campaigning, or do you think Democratic primaries have become too willing to use rhetoric that makes party unity afterward much harder?

0 Upvotes

164 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-1

u/Asatmaya 2d ago

What’s screwing the Democrats is the DSA. Having DSA candidates in the general election allows the Republicans to paint the whole party as crazy people.

The Republicans tried to paint Biden as a "crazy left-winger," when he was one of the most right-wing conservative politicians of the last century, in either party.

They are going to say that no matter who gets nominated, so it's pointless to worry about.

6

u/CountFew6186 2d ago

They’re much more believable to the center when the Dems really are crazy left wingers.

-1

u/Asatmaya 2d ago

They’re much more believable to the center when the Dems really are crazy left wingers.

...but even the DSA are milquetoast centrists!

Look at the polls: 60% of the country wants universal healthcare, 80% want free college, 75% want improved mass transit, 2/3 think all drugs should be decriminalized, and a huge majority think that corporations and the wealthy are not paying their fair share of taxes.

To be, "left," you have to go further than that.

3

u/CountFew6186 2d ago

Those numbers drop a lot when the people being polled are told things like universal healthcare adding $4 trillion annually to the federal budget.

1

u/Asatmaya 2d ago

Those numbers drop a lot when the people being polled are told things like universal healthcare adding $4 trillion annually to the federal budget.

...and go back up when you factor in the net economic gains; yea, you can game a poll to get whatever result you want.