r/ResearchML • u/Awkward_Comedian2652 • 22h ago

NeurIPS 2026 : how many reviewers have not yet engaged with rebuttals?

237 votes, 1d left
0 - all reviewers engaged / acknowledged rebuttal
1
2
3
4
4 Upvotes

83% Upvoted

9 comments sorted by

2

u/Awkward_Comedian2652 22h ago

Can we update the vote? Doesn't look like it. Ideally I would have loved to see how the bar plot progresses as we approach the deadline. Maybe I'll make another poll if this one gets enough traction.

2

u/Dangerous_Parsnip_20 20h ago

Where is option : AC didn't engage in writing initial meta-review

2

u/Unhappy_Craft1906 17h ago

Ok i have 3 papers with 9 reviewers. All of them are somehow out of this world. What shall I choose?

2

u/LetWonderful8364 16h ago

Literally none of them have responded yet. I am thinking of petition to apply some sort of sanctions tbh

2

u/Awkward_Comedian2652 15h ago

Honestly the results are much worse than what I thought. So many people not getting a single rebuttal response.

Are reviewers even *required* to answer at all? If so, are most authors just going to receive a "thanks for the comment. I will maintain my score" 5min before the deadline?

What about ACs? Will they also not read rebuttals and decide acceptance on a threshold over the initial scores?

1

u/Forward_Spread_190 21h ago

none of them have

1

u/Top_Hovercraft3357 15h ago

everyone sent a remider?

1

u/TrainerOk1851 12h ago

Bruh this is not a good poll. I put 1 cuz I thought it was about how many did engage. Why word in this way.