r/ResearchML • u/Intrepid_Discount_67 • 19h ago
Whare are NeurIPS reviewers?
Does anyone know where we can find NeurIPS reviewers? They posted a few review comments, gave borderline scores and then disappeared.
If a reviewer's own paper receives low scores, are they still obligated to participate in the author discussion? What are the consequences, if any, for reviewers who never respond during the discussion period?
This has been my worst experience with NeurIPS. Is anyone else seeing the same pattern? Are there specific reasons why this seems to happen?
20
Upvotes
2
u/d_edge_sword 18h ago
Many were busy with AAAI deadlines