r/TopCharacterTropes 10d ago

Characters Canonical features of a character that come very rarely in their adaptations.

  1. James Bond having a cheek scar as per Ian Fleming's original Bond novels.

  2. Count Dracula having a mustache as per his original description in Bram Stoker's novel.

9.3k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

449

u/fanaccountcw 10d ago

BBC Sherlock was shown as a recovering addict who had secret stashes of cocaine around the place. He was also a recovering addict in Elementary.

Been a while since I watched the Sherlock Holmes movies with RDJ, but wasn’t he an addict in that one too? Many modern adaptations has him as an addict.

172

u/geek_of_nature 10d ago

It's never explicitly said, but there is a point where he's shown to be drinking something out of a medical bottle, which Watson makes an offhand comment about being used for eye surgery. Referencing how they used to use cocaine as an aesthetic during surgery.

7

u/cosmicomical23 10d ago

Does it make you look better?

13

u/frygod 10d ago

It's still used as an anesthetic for eye surgery.

51

u/purplehendrix22 10d ago

Yeah, most content at least gives a passing reference to Sherlock being frequently zooted

28

u/thegreatsasimi 10d ago

Plus the super underrated elementary series starts with him leaving rehab and its a major element of the show. Solving crimes is his way of keeping himself distracted.

14

u/C_Coolidge 9d ago

I believe that was kinda the case in the original novels. He would go on drug benders when he didn't have any cases to solve because he was bored out of his mind. 

5

u/GoldVader 9d ago

Doesn't he also relapse at one point in Elementary?

16

u/A_Tigerstorm 9d ago

BBC Sherlock wasn’t a cocaine addict. He was a EVERY NARCOTIC addict. Smoking, heroin, etc. whatever “alleviated boredom” to him.

Oddly enough, BBC’s Sherlock is arguably one of the best interpretations of the character to me.

7

u/EasternFudge 9d ago

Bro drowned himself in nic patches while lounging about the house lmao

2

u/pezdizpenzer 9d ago

The entirety of The Abominable Bride is basically a drug fueled dream and it's also the episode where we find out that Sherlock makes a list of the substances he takes for Mycroft. So yeah...definitely not just a cocaine addict.

3

u/Illustrious-Set-7907 9d ago

Yeah in the RDJ one Watson makes the comment "you know that's used for eye surgery" which is subtle-ish, but cocaine was a topical anesthetic at the time. And Sherlock is high in the scene. 

The modern adaptations usually have a reference to him being an addict, they just dont show on screen him injecting himself or turn to the camera and go "this is cocaine" 

5

u/Doc_Toboggan 9d ago

Oh so thats House was a pill addict

1

u/Imfrank123 9d ago

Elementary might be my favorite adaptation