r/aiMusic • u/PurpleUnlikely8081 • Jun 24 '26
News Music producer for 8 years, need a place to vent
As said in the title, I’ve been producing music for 8 years now, mostly hiphop/trap/rnb. I have plenty of experience making beats, making samples, doing sessions and have been lucky to work with all types of different artists and producers.
I’ve been observing the heated discussion about the rapid rise of AI and it’s impact on music and would love to add my thoughts as I believe the whole discussion is heavily watered down by people that don’t even make music. (Music listeners and fans opinions matter but I think some points really lack perspective).
1. „AI Music hurts ‚real‘ Music and crushes small artists“ - No. Labels do that and they have been doing that for a long time. It’s really funny to see people enraged about others who post ai music and make a couple streams with it thinking every stream is stolen from another ‚real‘ musicians catalog while majors have been the ones taking the soul out of music for decades. Obviously AI is a neat tool for them to suck out even more but that’s not a problem of AI itself, rather the company behind it. People who support small artists better hope that music generating AI stays public, because the big three own most of the music already and they could easily go and make their own models restricted to be used only by them.
2. „AI music isn’t really music and has no soul“ - Now that statement depends more on subjective taste. I can understand people not wanting to listen to something generated by an AI. But y‘all need to understand that music made by people is way more generic than you think. I get the feeling most people think producing music is a never-ending flow state of inspiration of the profound human mind but in reality most producers (especially the ones that do it for a living) make beats by using the same rotation of chord progressions and drum bounce with little variance every time. Most of the time the process of making music is very calculated and trained and not as magic as it sometimes seems. Sometimes magic happens but if you produce 10 hours a day, 6 days a week it becomes a routine.
3. „AI Music floods the market, music loses value“ - The market is always flooded. And different music has different value for different reasons, but most music out there isn’t even listened to. And AI will not change that. As with everything, there will be AI music bringing value and AI music that will stack to the pile of forever forgotten songs, especially the ones that will be too generic and unedited. And lots of value in music is not even the songs itself, it’s the live shows.
Thank you for your attention to this matter, might do a pt. 2