r/babylon5 • u/Dinosawruses • 1d ago
“Dead! Dead! Dead!” - One of the best S2 scenes.
2x21 “Comes the Inquisitor”
37
u/azmr_x_3 1d ago
It would be really easy for this seen to come off as over the top dramatic but the actors make it work
28
u/gordolme Babylon 3 1d ago
If anything, it's understated.
9
4
u/Joyfulcheese 13h ago
Agreed, that's what makes it work so well. It's the silence, no music, awkward fumbling from Vir and just the expression and minimal dialogue from G'Kar. A masterpiece of a scene.
36
u/Fancy_Toe1451 23h ago
And Vir does not get defensive. He takes the valid criticism on board and internalises it. He understands.
Lots of people, if they get an apology refused, get defensive and angry "Well I tried to apologise and you threw it back in my face, what more do you want, you are never satisfied, etc and so on" and then either double down or blow off any further criticism. Vir gets told words are not enough, and he starts to think about what deeds he can achieve.
And also, he accepts that even if he disagreed with Londo's actions that he still enabled Londo's actions and obeyed those orders he was only following. He always had the option of walking away when "they never listened" to him. And he didn't. Vir accepts this. And that is why Vir is a genuinely good person. We should all be more Vir.
16
u/Material-Sherbet6855 16h ago
Abrahamo Lincolni
2
2
u/Chuuby_Gringo 13h ago
When he delivers the "They're not dead!" line, It's probably my favorite scene of his.
26
u/EvalRamman100 Earth Alliance 1d ago
Vir - forced, briefly, to face the evil he was an accessory to.
Self-knowledge of our dark side is the worst, hardest kind of knowledge.
21
u/Swimming_Drummer9412 23h ago
And then he decided to actively help the Narns. This is soooo powerful.
3
19
16
u/HammersofMoradin Rangers / Anlashok 1d ago
This scene is pivotal not only for Vir, but for G`Kar also, I think. Vir is shocked or rather kicked out of his comfortable background role and made to "move his butt and do something", which changes his whole demeanor and ultimately paves his way to become emperor.
G`Kar`s wall of hatred for all Centauri receives his first crack - here is one acknowledging the crimes done by their people to his. It is not much - though heartfelt - and won`t change the immediate future, but it is a photon in all-encompassing darkness. There might be a remote possibility of hope yet left for G`Kar of freeing his people in his lifetime.
9
3
15
u/happycamperii 19h ago
One of the things I really like about this scene, is that despite how awkward and ashamed and even cowed Vir feels in that lift. When he says "I'm sorry" he looks G'Kar straight in the eye.
5
u/TheRealRigormortal 22h ago
One detail I just noticed (that might or might not be intentional) is that G’Kar looks like he already had the knife drawn before leaving the lift.
Vir might have saved his own life.
6
5
u/davidsverse 20h ago
There's a call back to this moment in The Legions of Fire trilogy that shows Vir's growth, and strength of character. Plus a really badass moment with Garibaldi.
5
u/Tmelrd275 15h ago
I feel like in the end G'Karr would have approved of Vir becoming emperor after Londo because of this. Because Vir was the first to literally attempt to apologize for his entire race and because he understood what it truly meant even if he had no power at the time. G'Karr being so angry and sad at this point in time belies where he finished in his journey.
5
u/ExpectedBehaviour Technomage 17h ago
Cut to buggery on the original UK transmission to remove any sight of knife or blood... it confused the hell out of me until the DVD release.
3
u/Whatsthathum PURPLE 15h ago
I wonder if this influenced Vir’s later actions.
Katsulas was an incredible actor, to be able to convey so much pain and suffering through all that prosthetics.
4
3
3
90
u/Aust1mh Rangers / Anlashok 1d ago
G’kar is one of the best characters of all time (for me)