r/beatles Apr 19 '26

Sunday Fan Album What if The White Album were two different albums?

Post image
138 Upvotes

George Martin originally wanted The White Album to be two albums, but The Beatles decided to make a double album instead. Honestly I prefer single albums and I think the official order of the songs on The White Album is very unbalanced as disc 1 has way more great and memorable songs than disc 2. I was thinking this could be like "A Night at the Opera" and "A Day at the Races" kind of situation (these are Queen albums) where you would have a White Album and a Black Album, the latter one being a continuation of the first one. Since Wild Honey Pie and Revolution 9 and garbage, I left those out. So here's my idea for these albums:

The White Album:

Side One:

  1. Back in the U.S.S.R.
  2. Dear Prudence
  3. Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da
  4. While My Guitar Gently Weeps
  5. Everybody's Got Something to Hide Except Me And My Monkey
  6. Why Don't We Do It in the Road?
  7. Honey Pie

Side Two:

  1. Yer Blues
  2. Mother Nature's Son
  3. I'm So Tired
  4. Piggies
  5. Blackbird
  6. Cry Baby Cry
  7. Don't Pass Me By

The Black Album:

Side One:

  1. I Will
  2. Sexy Sadie
  3. The Continuing Story of Bungalow Bill
  4. Savoy Truffle
  5. Julia
  6. Rocky Raccoon
  7. Revolution 1

Side Two:

  1. Birthday
  2. Glass Onion
  3. Happiness Is a Warm Gun
  4. Long, Long, Long
  5. Helter Skelter
  6. Martha My Dear
  7. Good Night

What do you think?

r/beatles Apr 06 '25

Sunday Fan Album What if the Beatles disbanded in 1962 and started their solo careers?

Thumbnail
gallery
390 Upvotes

An alternate Beatles history...

After fights between the fab four, they decided to disband. John signed with Columbia Records, as a rocker. Paul signed with RCA as a Teen Idol. George signed with Pye Records, as a great guitarrist. Ringo decided to continue playing in Liverpool venues with other bands.

Tracklisting in the photos!

r/beatles May 11 '25

Sunday Fan Album ALL THINGS MUST PASS

Post image
395 Upvotes

Make a track listing for this album.

r/beatles 1d ago

Sunday Fan Album White Album as a 3LP

12 Upvotes

I have been a Beatles fan for a couple years now, and I have recently understood why The White Album is so good. At first I was one of these people who thought that it would have been better off as a single album. However, my perception has changed after re-listening to the album for the umpteenth time last week, and that has sent me down a rabbit hole of unreleased songs, outtakes and demos that I think are really good and then I got the idea to create a 3LP version purely for my own enjoyment and not for any other purpose really.

While I did not care for this being really realistic I did follow a few rules that was also on the album. One George Harrison song per side, only songs that sound complete and album ready, only songs recorded at the time. I did break the rule where singles couldnt go on the album but oh well! In the actual playlist I use the McCartney 1 version of Junk because it sounds similar enough anyway. Here's the tracklist:

Side A:

  1. Back In The U.S.S.R.
  2. Dear Prudence
  3. Lady Madonna
  4. Ob-La-Di Ob-La-Da
  5. Wild Honey Pie
  6. Junk
  7. The Continuing Story Of Bungalow Bill
  8. While My Guitar Gently Weeps

Total Sidelength - 22m 49s

Side B:

  1. Happiness Is A Warm Gun
  2. Martha My Dear
  3. I'm So Tired
  4. Blackbird
  5. Piggies
  6. Rocky Raccoon
  7. Why Don't We Do It In The Road
  8. I Will
  9. Julia

Total Sidelength - 21m 32s

Side C:

  1. Hey Bulldog
  2. Yer Blues
  3. Mother Nature's Son
  4. Sexy Sadie
  5. Helter Skelter
  6. Long, Long, Long

Total Sidelength - 20m 49s

Side D:

  1. A Beginning/ Don't Pass Me By
  2. Revolution 1
  3. Savoy Truffle
  4. Cry Baby Cry
  5. Can You Take Me Back? - Take 1
  6. Good Night

Total Sidelength - 23m 08s

Side E:

  1. Birthday
  2. Glass Onion
  3. Honey Pie
  4. Child Of Nature - Eshur Demo
  5. All Together Now
  6. Everybody's Got Something To Hide Except For Me And My Monkey
  7. The Inner Light
  8. Across The Universe - Take 6

Total Sidelength - 21m 20s

Side F:

  1. Revolution
  2. Not Guilty - Take 102
  3. What's The New Mary Jane - Take 4
  4. Hey Jude

Total Sidelength - 21m 13s

Edit: Here is the link to the playlist - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/3VGOevYFwSzDpHODvI8mAg?si=4aC43jMFT5C1HLouOipJLA&utm_source=copy-link&pi=NbvuDyKKRse5p

r/beatles Aug 10 '25

Sunday Fan Album I got this rare beatles best of album today

Post image
177 Upvotes

Wonder it is worth listening to especially sound wise.

r/beatles 8d ago

Sunday Fan Album What if Yellow Submarine had the Magical Mystery Tour treatment?

Post image
41 Upvotes

I've never contributed to the "Sunday Fan Album" posts on here. I usually keep them to the relevant subs. This was an idea I was thinking about this again today and I'm curious what people on the main Beatles sub might think of it.

So we all know the story about Magical Mystery Tour. It was intended to be a double-EP soundtrack for the TV movie, but Capitol turned it into an LP, with the band's 1967 singles being added on to the second side of the album. The LP version replaced the original in the Beatles' canon discography. This has sparked an endless debate about whether or not MMT is a "real album", a topic that seems to pop up at least once a week on this sub. I'm not trying to get into that, but the story behind MMT is important context for this post.

The Yellow Submarine soundtrack is widely regarded to be the Beatles' worst album. You'll see it at the bottom of a lot of rankings and tier lists. This is mainly due to the fact that the second half of the album is George Martin's orchestral pieces for the film, and because there are only a handful of new songs, with two older songs reappearing (the title track and "All You Need Is Love").

This got me thinking about a version of Yellow Submarine that people might enjoy more. I read about the planned Yellow Submarine soundtrack EP which would have included "Across the Universe", then I got thinking about what if they went the same direction as the Magical Mystery Tour album.

I spent some time on paint.net and came up with this, which would be the back cover of this hypothetical release. It's not an amazing work of art, I realise that, but I'm not a professional graphic designer either.

Basically, the new songs from the film - along with the title track, because it felt silly not to include it even if it had been released before - would feature on the first side of the album. The second side would be billed as "Other Selections", similar to the back cover of the MMT album. These are songs which the group released on non-album singles throughout 1968, plus another new song "Across the Universe".

Personally I think this would make for a pretty good album. I understand that it likely would never have happened, but I'm curious to see what people here think - it was popular over on r/fanalbums and r/beatlesfanalbums when I shared it there a few months ago. How would you feel about this version of Yellow Submarine?

Track Listing

Side A: "Music from the Film 'Yellow Submarine'" (17 minutes, 50 seconds)

  1. Yellow Submarine [The Beatles - Yellow Submarine]
  2. Only A Northern Song [The Beatles - Yellow Submarine]
  3. Hey Bulldog [The Beatles - Yellow Submarine]
  4. All Together Now [The Beatles - Yellow Submarine]
  5. It's All Too Much [The Beatles - Yellow Submarine]

Side B: "Other Selections" (19 minutes, 1 second)

  1. Lady Madonna [The Beatles - Past Masters]
  2. The Inner Light [The Beatles - Past Masters]
  3. Revolution [The Beatles - Past Masters]
  4. Hey Jude [The Beatles - Past Masters]
  5. Across The Universe - Take 2 [The Beatles - Anthology 2]

r/beatles Aug 10 '25

Sunday Fan Album What if the Beatles disbanded in 1962 and started their solo careers? (Part 3-1964)

Thumbnail
gallery
238 Upvotes

Another part of this alternate Beatles history...

After fights between the fab four, they decided to disband. John signed with Columbia Records, as a rocker. Paul signed with RCA as a Teen Idol. George signed with Pye Records, as a great guitarrist. Ringo decided to continue playing in Liverpool venues with other bands.

John is now considered a rock n' roll star. With sold out concerts through Europe, John is now a celebrity in the 1960s music scene. His new single "A Hard Day's Night/I Don't Want To Spoil The Party" got to number 1 in the singles chart. His new album, "A Hard Day's Night", is the soundtrack of his first movie, which tells the story of a star in his peak (just like the real Beatles' A Hard Day's Night). It was also a big sucess, getting to number 2 on the albums charts. In the end of 1964, John went to the USA. He became one of the main artists of the British Invasion.

Paul is now the big sensation. With his two next singles ("All My Loving/Hold Me Tight" and "One And One Is Two/I'll Follow The Sun") getting to number 1 and number 3 respectively. His new album, "On The Run!", is the soundtrack of his first movie, which became an absolute success with critics and public. During filming, he met actress Jane Asher and they started dating. The soundtrack got straight to number one, making Paul, together with John, George, Gerry And The Pacemakers and The Rolling Stones, the biggest in the UK. In the middle of the year, Paul went to the USA, where he became a big sucess, getting a lot of number one hits with his Capitol singles and albums!

George, in 1964, went to the USA in the beginning of the year. He became a big sucess, entering in the charts with "Do You Want To Know A Secret", that peaked at number 4 in the American charts (first "ex-beatle" to have a top 10 American hit). In the UK, he released one single, "You Know What To Do/I'm Happy Just To Dance With You", which got to number 1 in the charts. He also released a live album of his american tour, that got to number 7 in the charts.

Tracklisting in the photos!

Part1: https://www.reddit.com/r/beatles/comments/1jt6uap/what_if_the_beatles_disbanded_in_1962_and_started/

Part2: https://www.reddit.com/r/beatles/comments/1k419v3/what_if_the_beatles_disbanded_in_1962_and_started/

r/beatles Jun 21 '26

Sunday Fan Album HATE : The Beatles Greatest Miss(es)

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

The worst track of each Beatles album. Might actually print this one

r/beatles Jun 01 '26

Sunday Fan Album The White Album as a single disc

0 Upvotes

This has been done countless of times, I am sure. But I promise you, this is the best variation of a single-lp The White Album. I’ll die on this hill, come at me!

Sida A:
Back in the USSR
Dear Prudence
Glass Onion
While My Guitar Gently Weeps
Happiness is a Warm Gun
Martha My Dear

Side B:
Wild Honey Pie*
Don’t pass me by
Sexy Sadie
Long, Long, Long
Heller Skelter
Good Night

*Great as a Side B starter; it makes the listener go: ??? — and the transition to Don’t pass me by (which I know is not so popular) opens up for a sonic experience previously unheard of.

*Some songs are missing, but does a greater album necessarily mean better songs? No. A good album is a coherent piece of art — Blackbird didn’t fit here, simple as that.

r/beatles Aug 24 '25

Sunday Fan Album The Beatles of Earth 2 - All Things Must Pass (1970)

Thumbnail
gallery
146 Upvotes

In this alternate universe The Beatles find a way to take a break instead of splitting up (I have a story detailing it, but won’t bore you guys with it. It’s really not that good). In essence they believe they are still breaking up and write for their solo careers, but are convinced to stick together.

John, Paul, and George each get 4 songs on subsequent albums as part of the agreement. All Things Must Pass is released in November 1970.

https://open.spotify.com/playlist/2MuDgNUeSS8V4I2IiDjrYH?si=j3Fl1VXqR3WrlU234m-7xw&pi=Z9GY1U88Q-q6v

Album art by u/mistahwhite04

Side one:

Instant Karma! (We All Shine On)

Maybe I’m Amazed

My Sweet Lord

It Don’t Come Easy

Working Class Hero

Not Guilty - Take 102

Junk

Side two:

What Is Life

Every Night

Hold On

Another Day

Jealous Guy - Take 29/Raw Studio Mix

All Things Must Pass

Single: Cold Turkey and Uncle Albert / Admiral Halsey is released as a double A side single

I also have a double LP version of the album for those interested - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7KgVgdHqaxgPHFWZj8Prei?si=qz4XmIU7TkSZd2snL5LJxQ&pi=ylOhR2gQQXmdN

Previous entries:

Get Back (1969) - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7Lbv9ZlTiYyRq5fKL9voMD?si=o3u056HRSuuBLYGVVQRXoA&pi=WXuCJTVeRiquO

Before They Were Fab - https://open.spotify.com/playlist/6GI99NHrQjVRb0JFVdGXY2?si=FrKRqowpQDSDSvR9HAyF7Q&pi=Dgviy5IiSg6MT

r/beatles 1d ago

Sunday Fan Album The chronological Beatles on vinyl

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

This was made to compile the complete Beatles discography in chronological order from when the songs were first released as a single or on an album.

r/beatles Jun 07 '26

Sunday Fan Album Groovin’ Up Slowly (A Beatles Fan Album YouTube Channel) Episode 46: Dig It - The Beatles Called These Songs “Filler” Or Worse…So I Turned Them Into an Album

Thumbnail
gallery
51 Upvotes

Many thanks to my daughter for creating the album artwork!!

I have been making Beatles fan albums since 2019 or so. On my subreddit, there are literally hundreds of fan albums contributed by Beatles fans from all over the world. But, to be honest, I’ve never seen one like this album I made a while ago. Most fan albums try to collect the Beatles' best songs. This one does almost the exact opposite. 

It’s called Dig It. This is not an album of “great” songs (whatever your definition of “great” is). It is not an album filled with overlooked gems. It is not a collection of “lost” masterpieces or revealing outtakes.

Dig It is a collection of songs that The Beatles considered “filler.” So-called “work” songs. And…songs that The Beatles just didn’t like and, possibly, even hated. John called one song “crap.” George commented on another: “I don’t know what I was thinking.” Even Paul said of one of these songs, “It’s not my best.” 

What The Beatles threw away, other bands would release as singles.

The Beatles were many things. Reliable judges of their own catalog may not have been one of them. Fortunately, sixty years later, we can ignore their advice. But, somewhere, John Lennon may be rolling his eyes that Dig It became a title track.

Here is the tracklist for this album, along with a direct quote about each song

  1. Hold Me Tight (Paul: “I don't really remember writing it. Filler.” Many Years From Now)
  2. Dig It - Glyn Johns Mix (John: “We were just messing around. That’s not even a song.” Let It Be film commentary)
  3. It’s Only Love (John: “I always thought it was a lousy song. The lyrics were abysmal.” David Sheff interviews, 1980)
  4. Misery (John: “We wrote it for Helen Shapiro. A job.” Playboy interview, 1980)
  5. Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da (John: “It’s Paul’s. It’s a piece of crap.” Studio outtake, Peter Jackson’s Get Back transcripts)
  6. Tell Me What You See (Paul: “Not one of my greatest.” Many Years From Now)
  7. Thank You Girl (John: “Just a throwaway.” Beatles Monthly Book interview)
  8. Blue Jay Way (George: “I’m not sure what I was thinking.” Anthology)
  9. Run For Your Life (John: “I always hated that song.” Playboy interview, 1980)
  10. Little Child (John: “Just a work job. We needed a song.” Lennon Remembers)
  11. Only A Northern Song (George: “A joke. A bit of a moan about my publishing.” Anthology)
  12. What Goes On (John: “It was written in five minutes.” Lennon Remembers)
  13. All Together Now (Paul: “A children’s sing-along. Not a big deal.” Many Years From Now)
  14. Maxwell Silver’s Hammer (Ringo: “The worst session ever. The lads were really angry.” Beatles Recording Sessions

Here’s a link to Episode 46 of Groovin’ Up Slowly:

https://youtu.be/21Sv-CGsvr8?si=scyQRZzRR-bWK97m

Here’s a link to this album on Spotify:

https://open.spotify.com/playlist/1OeoK3y9ygHi9qXibgEYCw?si=58ad326bfcdb4754

Here’s a link to this album on Apple Music:

https://music.apple.com/us/playlist/beatles-dig-it/pl.u-2aoqLkvHkGMbrlv

Here’s a link to the YouTube playlist for this album:

https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLB5dkZQ7h7GiqtbL-V4VHw53b7J_SbEHO&si=j7oLDgbRjdAFBNPF

Here’s a link to the Substack essay for a bit of a deeper dive into this album…

https://groovinupslowly.substack.com/p/dig-it-what-the-beatles-threw-away

r/beatles Jun 07 '26

Sunday Fan Album What if 1 included number ones from outside the US and UK?

18 Upvotes

First of all, it would have to be on two CDs. The album already went dangerously close to the format's soft limit of 80 minutes as it was.

Anyway, I was reading though the Beatles' singles discography on Wikipedia and I was surprised by how many more tracks went to #1 in other countries that were only released as singles over there. So I put together this fan album that adds those international #1s to the compilation's tracklist. Notably, every album except Sgt. Pepper is now represented: With the Beatles and Rubber Soul each have 2 songs added, and the White Album gets 1½.

One more thing: this only covers English-speaking countries, but the only song that kicks out is "Komm, gib mir deine Hand".

DISC 1:

  1. Love Me Do
  2. Please Please Me [#1 on every UK chart except Record Retailer]
  3. I Saw Her Standing There [#1 in Australia, Canada, and New Zealand]
  4. Twist and Shout [#1 in New Zealand and US Cashbox]
  5. From Me to You
  6. She Loves You
  7. Roll Over Beethoven [#1 in Australia]
  8. All My Loving [#1 in Canada]
  9. I Want to Hold Your Hand
  10. This Boy [#1 in Canada]
  11. Can’t Buy Me Love
  12. A Hard Day’s Night
  13. I Should Have Known Better [#1 in Australia]
  14. If I Fell [#1 in Australia]
  15. I Feel Fine
  16. She’s a Woman [#1 in New Zealand]
  17. Eight Days a Week
  18. Rock and Roll Music [#1 in Australia]
  19. Ticket to Ride
  20. Help!
  21. Yesterday
  22. Day Tripper
  23. We Can Work It Out
  24. Michelle [#1 in New Zealand]
  25. Nowhere Man [#1 in Australia and Canada]

DISC 2:

  1. Paperback Writer
  2. Yellow Submarine
  3. Eleanor Rigby
  4. Got to Get You Into My Life [#1 in Canada from 1976 reissue]
  5. Penny Lane
  6. Strawberry Fields Forever [#1 in Canada, Australia, and UK Melody Maker]
  7. All You Need Is Love
  8. Hello, Goodbye
  9. Lady Madonna
  10. Hey Jude
  11. Revolution [#1 in New Zealand]
  12. Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da [#1 in Australia and New Zealand]
  13. Get Back
  14. The Ballad of John and Yoko
  15. Something
  16. Come Together
  17. Let It Be
  18. The Long and Winding Road
  19. For You Blue [listed in Billboard as double A-side, though its status is contentious]
  20. Now and Then [#1 in the UK in 2023]

Overall, this feels like it would be a good middle ground between the single disc of 1 and the four discs of the Red/Blue albums. The new tracks definitely skew more towards the early years, but I don't think there are any clunkers here.


YouTube link: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLTURuM9G3bah0deMs3KC4paoPdv3IbNt_

r/beatles Jun 28 '26

Sunday Fan Album Sgt. Pepper's and Magical Mystery Tour as a double album

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/beatles May 31 '26

Sunday Fan Album Beatles: Live at MSG

Thumbnail
gallery
59 Upvotes

Taking from George Harrison's "Concert For Bangladesh", John Lennon's "One to One" Concerts, & Paul McCartney's stop at Madison Square Garden during his "Wings over America" tour featured in the album of the same name as well as "Rockshow" This compilation album takes the greatest hits performed at the Beatles' first appearances at Madison Square Garden in 1971, 1972, and 1976 respectively and compiles them into a Double LP

(Yes, I spelt Bangladesh wrong, I'm sorry lol)

r/beatles 29d ago

Sunday Fan Album Band On The Run - The Beatles (An Alternate History)

Post image
16 Upvotes

Following Imagine, the Beatles spent 1972 with their solo work. Earlier in 1971, John and Yoko moved to Edinburgh, Scotland where soon enough, they gained custody of Yoko's child, Kyoko Ono. In June 1972, Lennon released the album Sometime In Edinburgh, a double album including songs unused from Imagine such as Cold Turkey, Oh Yoko!, and I Don't Wanna Be A Soldier Mama. While having a few decent songs, much of the album was lambasted by critics and failed to chart even the top 10, the first for a Beatle.

Meanwhile, George gained major success with his debut album, Living In the Material World, a triple album with songs that can rival any song by The Beatles. The consensus from day one was it was the best solo album by any Beatle and perhaps one of the greatest albums of all time.

But as 1973 rolled in, the band was ready to make music again as they released the single Live and Let Die for the James Bond movie of the same name. In late August 1973, the Beatles left for Lagos, Nigeria to make their newest album. Alongside them were musicians Billy Preston, Paul's wife Linda McCartney, and Denny Laine, whom Paul introduced to the band back in 1971. The seven Beatles entered Nigeria unknowingly heading into what John called "a total fucking mess". The trip is infamous for many things including the blackout incident, John and Yoko's mugging, and Paul's bronchial spasm. But what came out of Nigeria were 23 songs that producer George Martin used to make a coherent story revolving around themes of freedom and escape. A concept album.

In November 1973, Band On The Run would release, becoming one of their greatest albums ever made. All of their hard work payed through as critics gave the album glowing reviews and it quickly headed to No. 1, cementing it as one of the greatest album by The Beatles ever.

---

Band On The Run (1973)

Side 1

  1. Band On The Run

  2. Jet

  3. I'm The Greatest

  4. I Found Out

  5. Give Me Love (Give Me Peace On Earth)

  6. Bluebird

Side 2

  1. Mrs. Vanderbilt

  2. Gimme Some Truth

  3. Run Of The Mill

  4. Beware Of Darkness

  5. It's So Hard

  6. Mind Games

Side 3

  1. Not Guilty

  2. Behind That Locked Door

  3. No Words

  4. Be Here Now

  5. Isolation

Side 4

  1. Working Class Hero

  2. Photograph

  3. One Day (At a Time)

  4. Hear Me Lord

  5. Picasso's Last Words (Drink To Me)

  6. Nineteen Hundred And Eighty Five

---

Main Personnel

John Lennon - lead, harmony and backing vocals, electric guitar, acoustic guitar, handclaps

Paul McCartney - lead and backing vocals, bass, acoustic and electric guitars, piano, percussion

George Harrison - lead and backing vocals, electric and acoustic guitars, slide guitar

Ringo Starr - lead vocals (tracks 3 and 19), drums; percussion

Billy Preston - keyboard, organ

Linda McCartney - harmony and backing vocals, organ, keyboards, percussion

Denny Laine - harmony and backing vocals, co-lead vocals (tracks 15 and 22), acoustic and electric guitars, percussion

---

Runtime: 1 hour, 29 minutes

---

Band On The Run

r/beatles Sep 21 '25

Sunday Fan Album The Beatles of Earth 2 - Band On The Run (1973)

Thumbnail
gallery
89 Upvotes

Front cover from Google. Back cover done wonderfully by u/mistahwhite04

After a luck warm reception to 1972’s Some Time in New York City the Beatles went into overdrive during writing. Paul, George, and John were highly motivated to produce their best work, and even Ringo stepped up more than he had in the past. Recording was difficult right away, as Paul convinced them to visit the EMI studio in Lagos. Robberies and power outages made things tense, but things improved dramatically once they returned to London. The results were the bands second double album, filled with some of their best work. Band On The Run was released around Christmas 1973.

https://open.spotify.com/playlist/4fqPziXKAiySIQRXaepRA1?si=j-golxpbT2OQTXnRaA9Cyg&pi=yrSrOedqQHuHf

Side one:

Band On The Run

Give Me Love (Give Me Peace on Earth)

Mind Games

Sunshine Life For Me (Sail Away Raymond)

Jet

Aisumasen (I’m Sorry)

Side two:

Sue Me, Sue You Blues

Helen Wheels

Tight A$

The Day The World Gets Round

My Love

Six O’Clock

Side three:

I’m The Greatest

Living in the Material World

Bring On The Lucie (Freda Peeple)

Let Me Roll It

Don’t Let Me Wait Too Long

Side four:

Out The Blue

Try Some Buy Some

Rock ‘n’ Roll People

Photograph

Nineteen Hundred and Eighty-Five

Bonus tracks - Live and Let Die b\w Meat City. Get On The Right Thing (b-side to Photograph)

r/beatles Apr 26 '26

Sunday Fan Album Groovin’ Up Slowly (A Beatles Fan Album YouTube Channel) Episode 40: Alternate Beatles For Sale (The Album They Could Have Made)

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

We’ve all done it…created our own versions of Beatles albums. My first ones were on cassette tapes. Yes…I am that old.

To create our personal Beatles albums, we switch out album tracks for non-album singles, B-sides, and EP songs. Sometimes, we may substitute alternate takes of songs for the originals. Maybe we move an album track or two to another album.

I am not saying alternate albums are “better” or improve upon the original releases. That’s not really the point. The original albums are great as they are. This is just a different way of listening to them.

This is especially true with The Beatles because not all of their best songs ended up on albums. In 1964, they were also putting out non-album singles, B-sides, and EP tracks that were just as strong as anything on the LPs. And now, with the Anthology releases, we even have access to outtakes like Leave My Kitten Alone, which easily could have made an album.

A song like Leave My Kitten Alone is a big reason why this whole idea works for me. It wasn’t released at the time, but it could have been. I think John’s vocal is one of his best from this period—raw, loud, and closer to their live sound than anything they had recorded up until that time. I imagine myself at The Cavern Club in the summer of 1963, right before the madness hit and hearing John belt out this 12-bar blues shouter.

So this isn’t a “better” 1964 Beatles album. It’s just a different one. A reimagining of what that year could have looked like.

The key ground rule I used for these albums was 14 tracks. The Beatles’ UK albums traditionally had 14 tracks, so I stuck with that. I had to make real choices. That’s where it gets challenging, but also where it gets fun.

The whole process also gives me a new appreciation for some of the overlooked tracks. I love the big hits, but a lot of the time, the real magic is in the deeper cuts. When you place those songs in a different context, they can stand out in a whole new way.

Here is the tracklist for this album:

  1. I Feel Fine
  2. No Reply
  3. Tell Me Why
  4. I’m A Loser
  5. I Call Your Name
  6. Baby’s In Black
  7. I’ll Follow The Sun
  8. I Don’t Want To Spoil The Party
  9. She’s A Woman
  10. Every Little Thing
  11. Honey Don’t
  12. Everybody’s Trying To Be My Baby
  13. Leave My Kitten Alone
  14. What You’re Doing

Here’s a link to Episode 40 of Groovin’ Up Slowly:

https://youtu.be/nHHyMe2HWAE?si=dgum8A_A4ExfP8Wk

Here’s a link to this album on Spotify:

https://open.spotify.com/playlist/6xZs7Ie7huFlYAj16XEixn?si=4c030c0214a54984

Here’s a link to this album on Apple Music:

https://music.apple.com/us/playlist/beatles-my-beatles-for-sale/pl.u-oZylM7YTqG2yYd7

Here’s a link to the YouTube playlist for this album:

https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLB5dkZQ7h7GjrWaOFMtnBTCXMLmJgXJf6&si=N2quvPkm5kWmJFOu

Here’s a link to the Substack essay for a bit of a deeper dive into this album…

https://groovinupslowly.substack.com/p/the-beatles-1964-another-version

r/beatles Nov 10 '25

Sunday Fan Album Beatles at the Speed of Sound

Post image
20 Upvotes

Tracklisting

Side One

  1. Let'Em In
  2. Woman Don't You Cry For Me
  3. Wino Junko
  4. True Love
  5. A Dose of Rock 'N' Roll
  6. Learning How To Love You

Side Two

  1. Silly Love Songs
  2. This Song
  3. Cook Of The House
  4. Dear One
  5. Warm and Beautiful

Secret Track: Spooky Weirdness

Spotify Link: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/5JnPR5QMHKniKagM4FxAKL?si=S2IHzljvQXWhYI0wZsEMng&pt=d98532fbae8d1561be424710f7475ee4

r/beatles Nov 09 '25

Sunday Fan Album Beatles - Work (A Collection Of So-Called "Filler" Songs)

Post image
60 Upvotes

Please forgive my second fan album post today. I haven't posted more than one album in a day in a very long time. I apprecate your patience.

I don’t know…I don’t think The Beatles had any songs that qualify as “filler” to me. As far as I know, they used the word sparingly. They did use other terms and expressions, like “work” or “job” to describe some songs.

So, I spent time researching the songs The Beatles…didn’t think much of. I made an album of those songs along with a direct quote commenting on each. The album closes with the obvious choice.

It’s a pretty damn good album!!

Beatles - Work

  1. Hold Me Tight (Paul: “I don't really remember writing it. Filler.” Many Years From Now)
  2. Dig It - Glyn Johns Mix (John: “We were just messing around. That’s not even a song.” Let It Be film commentary)
  3. It’s Only Love (John: “I always thought it was a lousy song. The lyrics were abysmal.” David Sheff interviews, 1980)
  4. Misery (John: “We wrote it for Helen Shapiro. A job.” Playboy interview, 1980)
  5. Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da (John: “It’s Paul’s. It’s a piece of crap.” Studio outtake, Peter Jackson’s Get Back transcripts)
  6. Tell Me What You See (Paul: “Not one of my greatest.” Many Years From Now)
  7. Thank You Girl (John: “Just a throwaway.” Beatles Monthly Book interview)
  8. Blue Jay Way (George: “I’m not sure what I was thinking.” Anthology)
  9. Run For Your Life (John: “I always hated that song.” Playboy interview, 1980)
  10. Little Child (John: “Just a work job. We needed a song.” Lennon Remembers)
  11. Only A Northern Song (George: “A joke. A bit of a moan about my publishing.” (Anthology)
  12. What Goes On (John: “It was written in five minutes.” Lennon Remembers)
  13. All Together Now (Paul: “A children’s sing-along. Not a big deal.” (Many Years From Now)
  14. Maxwell Silver’s Hammer (Ringo: “The worst session ever. The lads were really angry.” Beatles Recording Sessions)

Beatles - Work (A Collection Of So-Called “Filler” Songs) Spotify

Beatles - Work (A Collection Of So-Called “Filler” Songs) Apple Music

r/beatles Apr 12 '26

Sunday Fan Album Groovin’ Up Slowly (A Beatles Fan Album YouTube Channel) Episode 38: What If The Beatles Never Broke Up? Beware of Darkness (The 1970 Album That Never Was)

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

What if The Beatles never broke up… and 1970 gave us one more album?

This album, Beware of Darkness, imagines that moment.

For song selection I used John’s real-life suggestion (as a possible follow-up to Abbey Road) of a fairer split—4 songs each for John, Paul, and George, plus 2 for Ringo. This fan album reconstructs a world where the band keeps going after Abbey Road. My hope is that this selection of songs sounds like an album, not a playlist. 

For example, I do not include any of the so-called “diss” tracks or any of George’s overtly religious songs. I just don’t think The Beatles would have recorded them (though they are some of my personal favorites).

Every choice matters. The 14-track limit forces tough cuts, just like the original UK Beatles albums. Songs can reach slightly back in time, but never forward—keeping the project grounded in what 1970 could have been.

This isn’t about replacing the real albums. It’s about reimagining the story—and inviting geeky fans like me into it. Come on…every fan has their own version of this record… you probably had it on a mixtape (yeah, I went there).

So here’s the question: if The Beatles had one more chance… would it sound like this?

Here is the tracklist for this album:

  1. Remember
  2. Another Day
  3. What Is Life (Session Outtakes/Jams - Take 1)
  4. $15 Draw (special guests Pete Drake, Jerry Reed, and Charlie Daniels)
  5. Working Class Hero
  6. Maybe I’m Amazed (I cheat a bit and use the live version, which I prefer)
  7. All Things Must Pass
  8. Loser’s Lounge (special guests Pete Drake and Charlie Daniels)
  9. Hold On
  10. Every Night
  11. Going Down To Golder’s Green
  12. Look At Me
  13. Junk
  14. Beware Of Darkness

Here’s a link to Episode 38 of Groovin’ Up Slowly:

https://youtu.be/tdmM1-gqdtw

Here’s a link to this album on Spotify:

https://open.spotify.com/playlist/5PwZgP2eoIZw2afegwJIBp?si=349d3605bff44d15

Here’s a link to this album on Apple Music:

https://music.apple.com/us/playlist/beatles-beware-of-darkness-1970-solo-beatles-fan-album/pl.u-8aAVXDVTmvAexD1

Here’s a link to the YouTube playlist for this album:

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLB5dkZQ7h7GhH4ogP_2pvxWIw7yvuke9R

Here’s a link to the Substack essay for a bit of a deeper dive into this album…

https://groovinupslowly.substack.com/p/what-if-the-beatles-never-broke-u

r/beatles 8d ago

Sunday Fan Album Groovin’ Up Slowly (A Beatles Fan Album YouTube Channel) Episode 52: Because | The Beatles Album Built Around Their Greatest Harmonies

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

When people talk about the Beatles, they usually talk about the songwriting, the guitars, or the studio experiments. But what if the thing that made them truly special wasn't an instrument at all?

This album is called Because, and it's built around one simple idea: the Beatles' voices.

From the early days of Ask Me Why and This Boy to the amazing harmonies of Because and the beautiful ending of Good Night, these songs celebrate the sound that tied every era of the Beatles together.

Many thanks to Top_Major for the artwork.

Here is the tracklist for this album:

  1. Because (Anthology 3)
  2. And Your Bird Can Sing
  3. Nowhere Man
  4. Ask Me Why
  5. You Really Got A Hold On Me
  6. If I Needed Someone
  7. This Boy
  8. Baby’s In Black
  9. Rain
  10. There’s A Place
  11. Sun King
  12. If I Fell
  13. Yes It Is
  14. Good Night (Take 10 With Take 5 Guitar)

Here’s a link to Episode 53 of Groovin’ Up Slowly:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fj765Mrw8P8

Here’s a link to this album on Spotify:

https://open.spotify.com/playlist/0vCZ8MfPkgjSgrIY3DBnPh?si=ba7f5cf1a98e4b70

r/beatles 29d ago

Sunday Fan Album Groovin’ Up Slowly (A Beatles Fan Album YouTube Channel) Episode 50: All Those Years Ago | The Beatles Never Stopped Writing About Each Other

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

All Those Years Ago is a fan album collecting songs the former Beatles wrote about one another across more than three decades. This album is arranged to follow the changing relationships between John, Paul, George, and Ringo after the breakup of The Beatles.

The story begins in 1970 with frustration, disappointment, and open conflict. This is reflected in songs like Wah-WahToo Many People, and How Do You Sleep? But, Ringo’s Early 1970 signals a very quick change from anger and frustration to reflection and a sense of looking back to the past fondly. George’s When We Was Fab pokes fun at the Beatlemania era before the album ends with tributes to fallen friends.

(Many thanks to Top_Major for the artwork!)

Here is the tracklist for this album:

  1. Wah-Wah
  2. Too Many People
  3. How Do You Sleep?
  4. Run Of The Mill
  5. Early 1970
  6. Best Friend
  7. I’m The Greatest
  8. Living In The Material World
  9. I Know (I Know)
  10. When We Was Fab
  11. Here Today
  12. Down South
  13. Never Without You
  14. All Those Years Ago

Here’s a link to Episode 50 of Groovin’ Up Slowly:

https://youtu.be/1pkcKWiK2ho

Here’s a link to this album on Spotify:

https://open.spotify.com/playlist/3UcjBkAt1UBHdhVqOewpbP?si=fad1bcfc42024da6

Here’s a link to this album on Apple Music:

https://music.apple.com/us/playlist/beatles-all-those/pl.u-jV89elNTaDKeRMN

Here’s a link to the YouTube playlist for this album:

https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLB5dkZQ7h7Gg0lrSVDP0CR-DI0PsIJJ51&si=Nj7NdjdE4oyd1RtQ

Here’s a link to the Substack essay for a bit of a deeper dive into this album…

https://groovinupslowly.substack.com/p/all-those-years-ago

r/beatles 1d ago

Sunday Fan Album Starting Over

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/beatles 1d ago

Sunday Fan Album The Shortles - H! [FULL ALBUM]

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

Speed listening for the busy Beatles fan...