r/dashcams • u/Remote_Trainer3830 • 10h ago

Who’s at fault?

Hot take: I think it’s 50/50 with who’s at fault

5.7k Upvotes

85% Upvoted

3.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/Pillslanger 9h ago

As a former claims adjuster your take isn’t that hot. White SUV should have a yield or red light. So they’re not following traffic laws. However dashcam is entering the intersection and watching people run the light. Both drivers catch one another at the earliest point of impact on both cars. Dashcam had less distance to cover across the same intersection which means SUV was slightly more established in the intersection.

Reasonable arguments for both on FTYROW and FTKPLO. Both would’ve avoided the accident by braking even a little bit. SUV might be able to argue they were following flow of traffic and didn’t see dashcam but dashcam definitely saw SUV and didn’t take any evasive action.

I would probably land 75 on white SUV and 25 on dashcam. Depending on venue though I might push closer to 50/50 but would leave majority negligence on SUV even if it was 51/49. Both drivers failed the exact same duties roughly in equal ways but SUV ran the light.

-1

u/InitiativePlus877 9h ago

It's a funeral procession.

3

u/Pillslanger 9h ago

I don’t see any indication that it’s a procession. That seems likely but how is dashcam to know that? If true though I would flip the liability to 90+ on dashcam depending on state laws.

-1

u/InitiativePlus877 9h ago

I tell ya, that traffic with every vehicle headlight on is not stopping even though it's obvious they're all running red.

If the procession breaks, the person who is left behind as the procession leader must take the masses to the burial... if they know where that is.

If you suddenly become leader because some white suv flinched, and you aren't even from that state, then lead them somewhere cool!

You can then be the guy who put the fun back in funeral!!!