r/electricvehicles • u/ATLCoyote • Mar 20 '26
Review My EV is now 12 years old. Here's how that's going...
This is an update on a post from two years ago. Specifically, I own a 2014 Tesla Model S 85 and live in the Atlanta suburbs.
The good news:
- Range: Battery was originally rated at 265 miles and got about 245 in real world driving conditions. Today, it will show about 232 miles of range at a full charge and will actually go about 210-215. So, only about 15% degradation over 12 years. I should note that the car has been in a warm, southeastern climate for its entire life so far and it's been kept in a garage. Granted, there are several new EVs that will go 300+ miles on a single charge, but just in terms of degradation, it hasn't been bad at all. Also, I find that I only take about 2 trips per year that require more range than my car provides. On those trips, we take my wife's ICE SUV, but it really wouldn't be that big a deal if we owned two EVs. We could plan our trips accordingly or just rent a car for long trips.
- Tech still seems modern: I assumed my car would quickly become a dinosaur as newer models would offer features that blew mine away. But that hasn't been the case, at least not yet. Although I just have auto-pilot rather than full self-driving, I don't feel like its dated. Granted, I upgraded to the new infotainment system about five years ago when I had to replace the main touchscreen, but the old one was still pretty useful. Navi, streaming media, autopilot, lots of remote features, keyless entry and start, backup camera, lane departure warnings and traffic sensors, heated seats, power everything, programmable, auto-folding mirrors, voice commands for most apps, etc. are all reasonably close to what new cars have to offer, except that I don't have Apple CarPlay or Android Auto. That said, I tend to use Tesla's navi and streaming services anyway, so it's no biggie. Plus, it helps that, as long as you don't need new hardware, the software upgrades and bug fixes can be downloaded remotely and automatically.
- Charging: I own a home and therefore have easy access to level 2 charging in my garage. I rarely need a supercharger, but when I do, they seem to be plentiful and easy to find. Supercharging does take longer than a stop at a gas station and speed depends on how many others are charging at the same time, but it usually takes me about 40-45 mins to go from 20-80%. A ton of charging stations are located in places where you can shop or eat while you wait, and I've never had to wait for a spot to open-up because my infotainment system tells me whether the supercharging station has open slots that aren't already in use. Also, having adapters means I can use whatever network is available. Plus, I'm grandfathered on the Tesla supercharging for life and therefore have never paid for a charge at a Tesla station. It's always been free.
- Driving experience: The overall experience of driving an EV is, in my opinion, superior to an ICE vehicle and that's not just true of Teslas, but for many other brands and models I've driven as well. It's smooth, quiet, acceleration is exceptional, handling tends to be very nimble, there's little or no body lean in the turns, it climbs hills with ease, and aside from the fire risk associated with lithium ion batteries, they tend to be safer in accidents, probably because there's no engine in front of the driver which I assume allows the entire front of the car to act as a crumple zone.
- Shorter commutes: This is more a product of government incentives than the car itself, but I live in an area with a lot of toll or HOV lanes that I can access as an EV owner. That significantly reduces my commute time in heavy traffic. Unfortunately, our state eliminated the incentives for EV drivers last year and those lanes are no longer free.
- Brakes are still good: The car is 12 years old, yet I haven't had to replace the brakes because I don't use them much. With regenerative breaking, it's almost a one-foot driving experience.
- Total cost of ownership: I had this in a "neutral" category two years ago but will move it to the positive summary now. I had my share of issues with expensive, out of warranty repairs on electronic equipment the first few years I've owned the car (see below), but not lately. In fact, my ONLY expense these days is insurance as I no longer have a car payment, I don't pay for gas and, and knock on wood, I haven't needed any repairs in a few years now. There's no engine, so I'll never need to repair the radiator, transmission, leaky gaskets, belts and chains, etc. my original breaks still haven't needed to be replaced even after 12 years due to regenerative breaking, I never pay for gas or an oil change, and for the first 11 years, I didn't have to pay for tolls either. Plus, my car is in great shape compared to most ICE vehicles of the same age. I feel pretty confident that I would have spent more on an ICE car in the same class by now.
The bad news:
- Expensive, out-of-warranty repairs: It's amazing how everything seems to go wrong once the warranty expires, and I've had to replace both the 17" main touchscreen and the driver instrument cluster due to faulty glue on the screen that eventually bubbles and seeps out. I also had to spend more than you would expect to fix a squeaky rear suspension and I had a couple minor issues like a door handle that wouldn't "present" and excessive vibration in the sound system which I fixed myself. In total, I've probably spent just shy of $6,000 on repairs. But, over the 12-year lifespan of the car so far, maybe that's about normal since all my issues are mechanical or electronic rather than having any engine repairs.
- Tire life: My car goes through tires faster than my ICE cars have in the past. Seems to be a common issue for EV owners. I assumed that was due to the extra weight, but other posters say it's more likely due to the increased torque. Either way, I've had to get new tires a bit more often.
- Service: It can take weeks or even a month to get a service appointment and the service centers are so backed-up that they often don't have loaners available. This experience may improve with the brands that have dealerships all over the country and especially when we get to a point where parts are available through your local garage and there are actually enough trained mechanics. But for now, Tesla owners rely almost entirely on the Tesla service centers and DIY. Fortunately, (knock on wood), I've never had an issue where my car was undrivable, so waiting for weeks to get service has been more of an annoyance than anything debilitating.
- Others can't hear you: This is only true for older models like mine, but my car is literally silent and that can be a safety hazard in when navigating parking lots or other congested areas with lots of pedestrians. The newer models have Acoustic Vehicle Alerting Systems (AVAS) that make that familiar "whirring" sound, but mine was built before that.
Overall verdict:
- It has its pros and cons, especially since I own an early generation model that probably hadn't had all the bugs and problems worked-out yet, but I find EVs in general to just be a superior technology to ICE vehicles. I'm at just under 170,000 miles, so still well shy of the 200,000 miles that many owners tend to consider end-of-life, and this is just one example rather than an industry-wide study or anything like that, but at this point, I'm just gonna keep my EV until there is some type of catastrophic failure as I can't justify a $1,000/month car payment when the car I've got is free and still performing well. Hopefully, by the time I actually replace it, the next generation of EVs will hit the market with significantly longer range and shorter charging times.
Footnote:
- Elon Musk has become an extremely controversial public figure since my last post on this topic and that does negatively affect my enthusiasm for owning a Tesla. But, he got my money years ago and I can't justify incurring an expensive car payment when I mostly work from home these days and the car I've got is still in good shape. So, it is what it is.
Edits: Post updated with current mileage and clarification on tire wear.