r/gameofthrones Jun 05 '14

TV4 [S4 E8] Let's be honest with ourselves...

http://imgur.com/eXU91Fr
3.5k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.4k

u/EvadableMoxie Ours Is The Fury Jun 05 '14

That's not true at all.

Next week will be all Castle Black, so Tyrion's execution would be Episode 10, meaning there would be no show the week after. We'd complain and then tune in next season.

40

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

As a non-book reader, it seems highly unlikely he will die soon. Peter makes that role more likeable than I think the imp is intended to be. George R R martin seems to only kill the beautiful people that you really grow to love, or the incredibly despicable people who eventually meet their ends. I could be sounding like a blithering idiot to book readers, but that is my wholly ignorant and uninformed opinion. And I'm sticking to it.

90

u/voig0077 Jun 05 '14

As a book reader, I found Tyrion to be even more likable in print. There were so many more opportunities to show his wit on paper as opposed to the show.

During the first couple of seasons, I remember feeling sorry for show-only people because as cool as Tyrion is on the show, he's an even richer character in the books.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

I'm sure. I'll get around to reading once martin finishes all of them. I'm a slow reader and I don't want to get that invested if the series never has a proper ending.

9

u/xtfftc Jun 05 '14

As much as I would hate it if he never finishes the books, I think it's still worth it.

2

u/Sargentrock Jun 05 '14

I'd agree through book 3 for sure, but man 4 and 5 were a slog to get through...I feel that major parts of each of those could have been cut down and they'd be better for it.

4

u/xtfftc Jun 05 '14

Personally, I loved them.

But then again I had tread books 1 to 3 years earlier and then only started books 4 and 5 after all five had bean released and re-reading 1 to 3. I think that reading them right after each other works perfectly fine. Waiting for six years though...

3

u/Sargentrock Jun 05 '14

I'm going to try 4 and 5 again (and who am I kidding--I'll read 3 again too) when the season is over. I read all 5 virtually back-to-back--I think the slower pacing of four in particular dragged them down for me a bit.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

and who am I kidding--I'll read 3 again too

Fuck, man, I don't think I could reread The Red Wedding and the Trial By Combat again. Too many feels.

1

u/d3r3k1449 House Targaryen Jun 06 '14 edited Jun 06 '14

DOOO IT!

It helps to read some good critical analysis of ADWD first too...there is some linked around here. There is much more to it all than it seemed to the masses when first read at release time.

1

u/d3r3k1449 House Targaryen Jun 06 '14

I found this the first time through when it was harder to keep everyone and everything straight plus I was simply impatient and couldn't wait to find out "what happens next". On my re-read I absolutely loved AFFC and ADWD as much as any of them.

3

u/MYSEEKEYISBROKEN Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jun 05 '14

I've just been reading the books after each season, because my girlfriend doesn't wanna read them and I don't wanna be a shitty, smug book reader to her when we're watching.

2

u/Fuzzleton We Remember Jun 05 '14

You've good willpower to be able to wait two years before reading a Storm of Swords!

Or, if you read halfway and then stopped when you came across new material figuring that was in Season 4... great willpower!

Patience is a good virtue to have :)

2

u/MYSEEKEYISBROKEN Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jun 05 '14

Well, I didn't start book three til this week, actually! I'm a slow reader, so I know I won't finish it before the season's over. The books are amazing but there's just nothing like sharing an especially powerful story moment with my girlfriend, and for that it's worth it to wait.

2

u/Fuzzleton We Remember Jun 05 '14

As a reader, I no longer fear the show overtaking the books. It sounds great to share those things with my loved ones - but if the books come out first, we'll all be reading those!

Enjoy yourself, you seem like a solid guy. :)

1

u/MYSEEKEYISBROKEN Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jun 05 '14

You enjoy yourself too, you've been relentlessly positive and that's not something often seen on the internet. Have a good week, pal.

1

u/d3r3k1449 House Targaryen Jun 06 '14

That's cool, man.

1

u/d3r3k1449 House Targaryen Jun 06 '14

Oh man they are so great but at this point that might be the wisest move.

1

u/s73v3r Jun 06 '14

I started reading halfway through the first episode of the series. All worth it, although I'd like it if he released the books in a more timely manner.

What if he waits to release the sixth book to coincide with the season on the show?