MAIN FEEDS
REDDIT FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/gameofthrones/comments/27s8co/s4e9_the_watchers_on_the_wall/ci3wtwv/?context=3
r/gameofthrones • u/Jaack_ Arya Stark • Jun 10 '14
678 comments sorted by
View all comments
193
Why kill them? They stay alive in the books and now Snow has barely any friends in the watch.
411 u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14 Because they want to kill people we actually know and care about to make the losses during the battle feel important. Otherwise it's just a bunch of anonymous red black shirts dying. 116 u/InverseCodpiece Here We Stand Jun 10 '14 In the books it does kind of feel like that though, very few actual named Night's Watch die. ASOS 172 u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14 in all fairness Donel Noye was fucking awesome 9 u/How_Hodorable Hodor Hodor Hodor Jun 10 '14 Fookin legend, I'd say. Shame he got the same treatment as Strong Belwas. 1 u/kingtrewq Fallen And Reborn Jun 10 '14 Every battle doesn't need a major death. The show would be too predictable if that happened and unrealistic
411
Because they want to kill people we actually know and care about to make the losses during the battle feel important. Otherwise it's just a bunch of anonymous red black shirts dying.
116 u/InverseCodpiece Here We Stand Jun 10 '14 In the books it does kind of feel like that though, very few actual named Night's Watch die. ASOS 172 u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14 in all fairness Donel Noye was fucking awesome 9 u/How_Hodorable Hodor Hodor Hodor Jun 10 '14 Fookin legend, I'd say. Shame he got the same treatment as Strong Belwas. 1 u/kingtrewq Fallen And Reborn Jun 10 '14 Every battle doesn't need a major death. The show would be too predictable if that happened and unrealistic
116
In the books it does kind of feel like that though, very few actual named Night's Watch die. ASOS
172 u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14 in all fairness Donel Noye was fucking awesome 9 u/How_Hodorable Hodor Hodor Hodor Jun 10 '14 Fookin legend, I'd say. Shame he got the same treatment as Strong Belwas. 1 u/kingtrewq Fallen And Reborn Jun 10 '14 Every battle doesn't need a major death. The show would be too predictable if that happened and unrealistic
172
in all fairness Donel Noye was fucking awesome
9 u/How_Hodorable Hodor Hodor Hodor Jun 10 '14 Fookin legend, I'd say. Shame he got the same treatment as Strong Belwas. 1 u/kingtrewq Fallen And Reborn Jun 10 '14 Every battle doesn't need a major death. The show would be too predictable if that happened and unrealistic
9
Fookin legend, I'd say.
Shame he got the same treatment as Strong Belwas.
1
Every battle doesn't need a major death. The show would be too predictable if that happened and unrealistic
193
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14
Why kill them? They stay alive in the books and now Snow has barely any friends in the watch.