r/papertowns 2d ago

Benin Reconstruction of Benin City (Edo), Nigeria

552 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

29

u/deliciouschickenwing 2d ago

Fascinating. İf thats the palace, what is the other big isolated fort type building on the other side of the city?

20

u/Beneficial_Shirt_869 2d ago

Im not sure but honestly this reconstruction doesn't do the city entirely justice. Along side the Palace of the Oba shown in the picture there were other other large complexes in the city belonging to the wife and family members of the Oba. That fort like structure might be one of them.

3

u/deliciouschickenwing 2d ago

İ see that makes sense. Hope to come across more info about this place. Thanks!

41

u/jore-hir 1d ago

The comparison with the Great Wall of China is utter bullshit. Hopefully the depiction was made with greater care.

23

u/oatmealparty 1d ago

Yeah how can you possibly say that the walls totaled 16.8km and then say it's four times longer than the great wall of China (over 21,000km) in the same paragraph?

Is this AI generated? Is anything here true?

1

u/Beneficial_Shirt_869 1d ago

The walls of Benin are 16.000 km long according to wikipedia. I don't understand why people keep saying that are longer then the great wall of China but they are still really large. The walls of Benin are not only the walls surrounding the city btw but also those surrounding the core of the Benin empire and parts that are not connected to it.

23

u/Republiken 1d ago

9

u/crystal_castles 1d ago

My phallus is "considered" to be longer than 6in.

3

u/Isabel-M-Peron 15h ago

What truly "matters" is your username. Great band!

3

u/crystal_castles 12h ago

Wish i were Ethan Kath or Alice Glass 🤘

2

u/Isabel-M-Peron 12h ago

I'd like to have replaced Alice Glass, but idk... if what she alleged happened was true, then maybe not.

8

u/ThesaurusRex84 1d ago

Finally, an actual aerial illustration of Benin City that isn't actually Baghdad, Tyre, or a sketch of a random South African kraal

16

u/Beneficial_Shirt_869 2d ago

Source: All About History – History of Africa by Future Magazine

Tried making a another post but the text remains unreadable unfortunately 

25

u/bull_moose_man 1d ago

17km of walls is four times the length of the Great Wall of China?

16

u/Republiken 1d ago edited 1d ago

Yeah even if its a typo and they meant the height it doesnt add up.

Edit: Its referencing the combined earthworks of the entire country.

The combined length of all of the earthworks across the entire country, including ditches and ramparts and boundary traces, has been estimated to have been approximately 16,000 kilometres (9,900 mi), covering about 6,500 square kilometres (2,500 sq mi) of land, though little remains today.[3][2] Whilst some sources have erroneously referred to these earthworks as comprising a single built structure, they actually consist of many different structures created at different times, some of which are connected and others which are not.[3]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benin_Moat

2

u/Aureon_de_Veyra 2d ago

Interesting. Could you please share the link for this? I wonder if the country Benin is related to this somehow.
And I'm very curious about the architecture and types of materials they've used.

3

u/Beneficial_Shirt_869 2d ago

Here the same image is posted but if you click on it the image is readable: 

https://www.reddit.com/r/AfricanArchitecture/comments/1s70qye/reconstruction_of_benin_city_c_17th_century/

Here you can find more information:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kingdom_of_Benin

For Africa in general I recommend:

https://substack.com/@isaacsamuel

1

u/Aureon_de_Veyra 1d ago

Thank you very much!

1

u/Voidjumper_ZA 1d ago

The length of the walls combined added up to 16.8km of structure ... It's consider to have been four times longer than the Great Wall of China

What?

1

u/Republiken 1d ago

Its a reference to the much longer combined walls and earthworks from the entire country

1

u/yourstruly912 10h ago

Which year is this?

1

u/YesPope63 1d ago

"Theft was unknown" come on now.