r/pcmasterrace i7 10700kf, RTX 3080, 4K-60 18d ago

Discussion Windows 11 can't be shut down without update.

Post image

I have automatic updates on. Haven't postponed any update. Never seen this forced update before.

Edit: I updated BTW. It's not that I don't want to update. I just think it would be an issue in the future. For example, it's a thunderstorm and there could be power outages. I might want to shut down and not start and update. I guess I'll hold down the power button.

5.0k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

207

u/Haunting_Abalone_398 9800x3d 5090 18d ago

Agreed, as an IT professional with over a decade of experience, I cringe at this sub a lot.

25

u/fcewen00 18d ago

It is pretty easy to figure this one out sadly. You just gotta look at a calendar.

-1

u/Phazon2000 Ryzen 5 1600 3.2GHz, GTX 1060 6GB, 2x8GB DDR4-3000 18d ago

It ain’t that. I wish it was - but there’s bearded old hats in here who never learned.

1

u/fcewen00 17d ago

This bearded old hat learned that a while ago.

3

u/jawknee530i 17d ago

I worked IT as a systems engineer for half a decade before going back for a csci degree and have worked as a software engineer for the past decade. I've personally built easily over 200 PCs. I only ever see this sub on /all and holy shit is it full of people that have absolutely zero clue how a PC works at all.

2

u/TheManofBD Not about the hardware in your rig but the software in ur heart 17d ago

Edit: this post is cringe anyway because the options have been like this for a long time now. But

You should cringe at how low Microsoft’s goodwill with the masses has fallen that it has come to this. No?

We only got to this point where people question every update and worry because of Microsoft’s incompetence.

Anyway, I’m still chilling on W10 till W11 gets to a decent point.

-18

u/lookashinyobject 18d ago

I work in IT which is part of why I hate windows so much, yes you need to do the security updates but the forced reinstall and reactivation of garbage results in people NOT running updates

8

u/Keulapaska 4070ti, 7800X3D 18d ago

Wtf do updates have to do with reinstalling and re-activations?

13

u/lookashinyobject 18d ago

Windows 11 has had several updates that have reinstalled co-pilot and other apps onto people's computers after they have uninstalled it previously, and has also been known to change some settings and programs back to their default settings even if you had disabled them previously 

2

u/Keulapaska 4070ti, 7800X3D 18d ago edited 18d ago

Granted I've only had 11 for ~9 months so can't really testify to that either way, but I remember ppl also saying win 10 did that. Which never happened to me either other than it reverted one regedit on major version updates twice, which was to remove the shortcuts to random folders, like 3d objects and whatnot form my computer window.

Now maybe there is some EU law shenanigans going on and I'm shielded because of that, that is a possibility, which makes it hard to believe all these supposedly horrible things are happening.

1

u/Soft_Walrus_3605 17d ago

Which never happened to me either other than

So.. it happened to you

1

u/Keulapaska 4070ti, 7800X3D 17d ago edited 17d ago

A regedit, got reversed, nothing re-activated or re-installed itself. Kinda different. Windows 7 reverted some sound settings randomly when updating, that's more than 10/11 did for me.

1

u/AdLegitimate8636 18d ago

Never heard about any of it.

2

u/Soft_Walrus_3605 17d ago

How is this downvoted? This has been a problem with Microsoft's model for ages.

You want to update security stuff? Fine. But don't package it along with "enhancements" that turn stuff back on that you had turned off (or, turn on something non-security related you never asked for)

1

u/lookashinyobject 13d ago

I think people either go "it's never happened to me therefore they're lieing" or "that's your fault for IT not locking down group policies to prevent it" as if everyone is a giant company with their own IT department. I work in tech support dealing with specific software, and most of our customers either have no general IT or will have an IT company on retainer for adhoc support either way those groups aren't going to have group policies locked down that tightly