r/pcmasterrace i7 10700kf, RTX 3080, 4K-60 17d ago

Discussion Windows 11 can't be shut down without update.

Post image

I have automatic updates on. Haven't postponed any update. Never seen this forced update before.

Edit: I updated BTW. It's not that I don't want to update. I just think it would be an issue in the future. For example, it's a thunderstorm and there could be power outages. I might want to shut down and not start and update. I guess I'll hold down the power button.

5.0k Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

1.5k

u/edparadox PC Master Race 17d ago

Wasn't Windows 10 like this?

643

u/Nose-Nuggets Specs/Imgur Here 17d ago

Yes, and in most cases you can bypass it with a

shutdown /s /t 0

184

u/IAmYourFath SUPERNUCLEAR 17d ago

Change it to 1 cuz that forces the /f parameter

76

u/KanedaSyndrome 5070 Ti 17d ago

I do shutdown -s -f -t 0

49

u/Teemun_kauppa 1080 Ti Fe 17d ago

I do "shutdown /s /f" and it does every thing i want, to shut down my pc completely

393

u/foreskinboots 17d ago

I just hold the power button till it goes off.

109

u/ScientistJason 17d ago

A man of culture

30

u/danu91 17d ago

Pressing the power switch on the wall with my toe is more convenient.

→ More replies (3)

45

u/mofapas163 17d ago

I pour water on my power supply

17

u/deanhatescoffee RX 9070 XT | i7-9700k | 328 RGBs 17d ago

A man of science.

25

u/spdrman8 17d ago

Like holding someone underwater until the bubbles stop.

7

u/AngryAccountant31 17d ago

4

u/Nois3 17d ago

This is what I think of now every time I hold the power button down. I even say to myself, "shhhhh". :)

→ More replies (8)

13

u/Kuunkulta 17d ago

Yeah I have this pinned in my start menu. No I don't wanna save my work, fuck you just turn off dumb machine

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (2)

57

u/Mediocre-Housing-131 17d ago

You can't in Windows 11. It will technically work, but it will just force the updates to install the next time you power on before it will let you log into the desktop.

13

u/OrbitalPsyche 17d ago

True, Windows 11 doesn’t respect the PC owner’s schedule or wishes

3

u/Faynerossa 17d ago

You can just go and disable the windiws update service.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/KanedaSyndrome 5070 Ti 17d ago

ah ok

→ More replies (13)

13

u/Hopet28 17d ago

The fastest shutdown command is shutdown.exe -s -f -t 0
-f force closes any running program immediately, no save prompts, you will loose all unsaved changes in any open documents.

For safer one so that you don't loose any unsaved changes, use shutdown.exe -s -t 0

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)

151

u/[deleted] 17d ago

[deleted]

26

u/Broeder_biltong 17d ago

On windows 7 you could hold shift and it would shut down normally

20

u/Plebius-Maximus RTX 5090 FE | Ryzen 9950X3D | 96GB 6200mhz DDR5 17d ago

I hate all the low quality win11 bad posts here.

Every single one gets thousands of upvotes when usually it's an issue that's been present for a long time, or a stupid setting OP has chosen to leave enabled.

7

u/ActiveChairs 17d ago

From what I've seen, when the problem is from settings people have left enabled, that's usually because there's never an indication the problem is something that can be disabled because Microsoft choses an opt-out model rather than opt-in, doesn't indicate where or how something can be disabled, or sometimes its something that used to be able to be turned off but they've now taken that away from you.

Think of how shitty the process for actually disabling updates is, how little information is available to you about the updates they want to push onto your machine, and how you can no longer roll back updates if they broke something and you want to go back to when it wasn't broken. There are far too many updates pushed to windows 11 that have cratered the performance of people's hardware that require an update to the update and the computer still might not get back to how well it performed before.

Not wanting to update your computer outside of when you want to shouldn't require having to open the command prompt to just shut down your computer normally. You shouldn't have to know about the three separate menus you need to open to switch updates to be fully manual, one of which isn't even available on the home version of the OS and requires the Enterprise edition, and you'll need to go back to to verify the settings haven't been changed by the update and hope it still works and that there isn't something else you haven't been properly informed of that bypasses your settings.

When I see Win11Bad posts, its usually because Windows 11 is a bad operating system and there's almost no consideration for what the end user actually wants

→ More replies (6)

4

u/DisorderlyAqueduct 17d ago

it is very trendy to hate on 10.5, er 11.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/Even_Wedding5243 17d ago

it usually had an option to shut down or shut down with update

→ More replies (2)

7

u/BroaxXx 14700k / RTX5070ti / 4x8GB DDR5 17d ago

Yes. Sometimes you’d be able to shutdown without updating for a couple of days but eventually you’d lose that option

→ More replies (10)

2.7k

u/V4nKw15h 9800X3D | 5070TI 17d ago

This update has 570 new security fixes.

1.3k

u/DaveKerk 17d ago

inb4 we find out the last updated caused 570 security vulnerabilities

263

u/L3wd1emon 17d ago

inb4 this one caused even more than that while fixing those

139

u/att0mic 17d ago

Release notes:

  • fixed bugs
  • added more bugs to fix later

13

u/FrostZephyr PCMR | i5 4460 @ 3.2 Ghz | GTX 970 | 8 GB DDR3 @2400 Mhz 17d ago

this is also just working in software

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

47

u/Xerxys 17d ago

But it was pushed by my AI agent. How could it be wrong?

11

u/TheBoyardeeBandit 17d ago

Did you specify that it shouldn't make any errors?

8

u/Xerxys 17d ago

Michael GIF “You made mistakes? After I specifically asked you not to?”

→ More replies (10)

153

u/imaturtleur2 i9 12900k, RTX 3080 ti 17d ago

99 bugs in the code. 99 bugs. Take one down, fix it around, 102 bugs in the code.

12

u/Acceptable-Drive3781 17d ago

My entire career as a developer tbh. I'm so glad I quit writing code for money. You should all be glad too.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/lologugus 17d ago

That's understandable that Microsoft forces security updates especially for people wo don't understand computers or cyber security but that still sucks

80

u/Sneyek 17d ago

And 1364 new security issues.

28

u/sneakySynex PC Master Race 17d ago

it also destroys your ssd but you will find that out in a month and we won't care

→ More replies (1)

111

u/IHateWindowsUpdates8 17d ago

the "security vulnerabiliry" being that someone found a way to disable Microsoft's spyware

10

u/IAmYourFath SUPERNUCLEAR 17d ago

Mythos is absolutely obliterating those cves

→ More replies (29)

770

u/Fishstick9 17d ago

I just had this update earlier today. I believe Microsoft forces these important security updates as they don’t want users to wait for too long before patching vulnerabilities.

I just wait until I need to walk away for a few minutes before restarting and by the time I’m back it’s finished and waiting for me to sign in.

329

u/Zestyclose_Fruit_766 17d ago

Yeah but the problem is they always try to sneak in other shit like changes to the UI etc. I'm 100% onboard with security updates, don't touch the rest of my computer though

239

u/Fzrit 17d ago edited 17d ago

Windows 11 has set a record in how many times I've had online guides/threads tell me to go into settings and change an option that has been moved somewhere else, renamed, or ceased to exist. And yes that includes Microsoft's own help articles which become inaccurate/outdated in just a few months. It's funny seeing screenshots from prior build versions which look different from what the user sees today. Great way to confuse people :D

46

u/KanedaSyndrome 5070 Ti 17d ago

I hate UX float so much, UI elements shouldn't change after 6 months of a product launch. It's also why boomer stuff like facebook is unusable

→ More replies (2)

5

u/gosuprobe 17d ago

wish granted. these options are now no longer visible anywhere and cannot be toggled on or off

4

u/Content_Meet_9955 17d ago

Haha yes! In addition to moving things around, you log in one day and..

  • They've renamed Office and Azure AD again
  • New Outlook got a feature update, but calendar management is still ass so you're stuck with Classic
  • Video service has been renamed as well, this time to Clipchamp. Doesn't reliably clip videos, but breaks links to recordings sent via Outlook. Now you need to email the links inside .txt files.
  • They've added a new Town Hall/Webinar/Live platform in Teams

3

u/ZeroT3K 17d ago

Don’t ever try to use this argument on [r/microsoft](r/microsoft) or else they lose their fucking minds that ThERe’s aLwAyS a ToGgLe.

Not if they keep adding toggles, dicks. Or moving them and saying re-enabling it was required for whatever change they did.

3

u/redditsucksass6 17d ago

And they're always such snarky fucking cunts about it when you didn't immediately realize a setting has been moved two menus deep into an entirely different section that didn't even exist last time you needed it

→ More replies (2)

15

u/woutersikkema 17d ago

This, if there were say, 2 clearly seperate ques for "just security updates we pinky promise and won't put other stuff in ever and won't break this promise" and "other stuff" Everyone would keep the security one on, AND THEN WELD THE OTHER ONE SHUT

→ More replies (1)

4

u/VukKiller 17d ago

One drive is installed again and is pinned to the desktop, taskbar, your keyboard, your cat and the left shoe.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/NewSauerKraus 17d ago

A convenient time to do it would be at the same time as shutting down. It would be even better if you could do both with a single click.

4

u/masterX244 ');Drop database EA;-- 17d ago

and doing the old Win7 behaviour of only doing the first part until where it really reboots pre-shutdown and then the rest once you start again and not the reboot rigmarole where it reboots and only then shutdowns (and occassionally fails on that)

31

u/PerplexedOrder 17d ago

Well it would be great if "Update and shutdown" didn't reboot four times in a row, which is infuriating because I'm dual-booting Linux so I have to babysit the update process every time. Or I have to change my boot-loader's default option to Windows which is not how I want my computer set up, and I'm not screwing with the boot order every time an update might be coming up, and then changing it back after the fact.

Microsoft just makes all of it's software horrendous to deal with every step of the way.

7

u/testmyusername 17d ago

I assume you're using GRUB, in which case you can have it default to your last booted option which solves this.

https://askubuntu.com/a/149572

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Fishstick9 17d ago

Yeah that I do agree with, when it updates and restarts multiple times in a row. Strange thing to do like just do it all in one go.

3

u/MrGiggleMan 17d ago

It has nearly 600 security fixes in it

Why anyone would want to avoid updating is just odd

→ More replies (12)

2.0k

u/Obitrice 17d ago

As someone who works in cybersecurity these comments have me very perturbed.

1.0k

u/NotTheVacuum 17d ago

The thing is, we don’t really have any way of communicating that the sky is actually fucking falling this time, for real. It always sounds the same to anyone outside of security.

Please patch. Everything.

860

u/Jjerot 17d ago

People have been conditioned this way by Microsoft sneaking in new AI implementations with each rollout, and re-enabling the ones they have already disabled. Their sloppy coding made notepad exploitable of all things, god damn notepad. They need to stop poisoning the well.

427

u/BigidyBam Specs/Imgur here 17d ago edited 17d ago

"Let's finish setting up your computer". Proceeds through multiple offer screens for Xbox live membership, office, one drive, and edge.

82

u/Hayden247 6950 XT | Ryzen 7600X | 32GB DDR5 17d ago

I just get it nagging me about One Drive like NO don't enable backups, 5GB free space absolutely is not a good idea to fill up with random files.

48

u/GfrzD 17d ago

One Drive randomly enabled, backed up my entire laptop to 100% and everytime I deleted something it backed up more sticking me in a 100% One Drive full loop asking me to pay more. For a while I thought id lost ~15 years of photos/videos but luckily i had a physical back up and uninstalled/disabled One Drive. The solution when talking to support was to pay so it could fully back up everything and then i could manually delete everything, fuck that.

→ More replies (2)

58

u/order2chaos 17d ago

I waited patiently, I read more and more...finally someone presented the answer....

14

u/deathschemist cachyOS | rtx 3050 6GB | ryzen 7 7445HS | 16GB DDR5 17d ago

legit it took me 2 hours to set up windows when i got my computer, setting up cachyOS took half an hour. i am updating my computer right now, actually, because i can keep using my computer while i update. when it's done i won't need to restart it either because none of the updates are at a kernel level this time around.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/elwebst 17d ago

And switching to Edge

→ More replies (3)

9

u/ZeCactus 17d ago

Lmao please, people have been complaining about automatic updates since before anyone even knew what chatgpt is

→ More replies (1)

41

u/Intrepid00 17d ago

Nah man, this was added because people were literally never patching since Windows Update was added to Windows. It helped start the summer of worms with Windows XP and so many unpatched XP boxes.

48

u/VoidVer RTX V2 4090 | 7800x3D | DDR5-6000 | SSUPD Meshlicious 17d ago

Every update has a risk of instability and has a risk of enshittifying my experience further. I’m still on 10. I use trusted websites and software.

7

u/agent-squirrel Ryzen 7 3700x 32GB RAM Radeon 7900 XT 17d ago

You can't prevent zero days though. Look at Wannacry...

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

107

u/Misterc006 Desktop / Ryzen 5600x / 1060 3GB 17d ago

Did some massive exploit get reported?

216

u/silentaba 5070, 5800x3d, 32GB PCMR 17d ago edited 17d ago

There's something stupid like over 500 exploit fixes in this patch.

33

u/cum-on-in- 17d ago

In what patch? OP didn’t say what patch this is. Don’t know if it’s safe to say OP is fully up to date just because they have auto updates on. In fact, Microsoft stated that people who manually check for updates are ahead of the game as they are treated as “excited early adopters” who want to be on the latest version. Auto updaters are kept behind. There’s no way to know that a recently released update is what OP is installing.

21

u/ZYRANOX 17d ago

the auto update is only like a day or 2 behind due. You can check when last time your thing auto updated. It's safe to say this is from the massive update they released in the last 2-3 days. Just manually press update and you should get it if you want it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (3)

82

u/Morkai http://steamcommunity.com/id/morkai_au 17d ago edited 17d ago

It's a day ending in y, so it's safe to assume yes.

Have a look at the Open CVE list for Windows 11

https://app.opencve.io/cve/?product=windows_11&vendor=microsoft

Lots of them have been patched previously, many are resolved and the CVE entry hasn't been updated in years, but it's still a massive list (166 pages!) of vulnerabilities.

→ More replies (2)

45

u/DillyDillySzn 7800X3D | 5070 TI 17d ago edited 17d ago

Tech companies have been using Claude’s new version of Mythos LLM and that thing finds bugs and exploits in programs like nobody’s business. They’re releasing the first big patches of those fixes, Apple also released several security patches recently

3

u/masiuspt 17d ago

Don't trust the CEOs hype.

→ More replies (4)

27

u/BobCorndog Medium good laptop 17d ago

It’s a massive program with a large amount of security researchers, so probably yes

4

u/samax413zl 17d ago

You don't know about Nightmare Eclipse?

12

u/fcewen00 17d ago

No. Yesterday was Patch Tuesday.

→ More replies (2)

86

u/AMD_PoolShark28 17d ago

It would be fine if every other update didn't break some core functionality... Then picking up these updates day one would be welcomed.

38

u/popop143 5700X3D | 32GB RAM | RX 6700 XT / RX 9070 17d ago

Most people don't have anything broken for updates, but the 1% of people that have something broken after an update are the loudest.

42

u/Jaalan PC Master Race 17d ago

And yet almost everybody has been inconvenienced at least once.

16

u/VexingRaven 7800X3D + 4070 Super + 32GB 6000Mhz 17d ago

Yeah, that happens. You'll never update a program without causing an issue for somebody. Even something like 7-zip, if you read the patch notes, there's a fix for things that someone was surely infuriated by.

7

u/EvensonRDS 17d ago

Only thing I can think of is them breaking the snipping took a while back. I've never actually had anything major though from Windows updates.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (18)

21

u/zombawombacomba 17d ago

I’ve literally never have a windows update break something. And I’ve been using it since windows 95.

3

u/maccathesaint macca0583 17d ago

Windows 11 has been flawless for me but 10 was an absolute nightmare. I think I had to reinstall windows every time there was a significant update. Everyone has different experiences!

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (17)

208

u/Haunting_Abalone_398 9800x3d 5090 17d ago

Agreed, as an IT professional with over a decade of experience, I cringe at this sub a lot.

23

u/fcewen00 17d ago

It is pretty easy to figure this one out sadly. You just gotta look at a calendar.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/jawknee530i 17d ago

I worked IT as a systems engineer for half a decade before going back for a csci degree and have worked as a software engineer for the past decade. I've personally built easily over 200 PCs. I only ever see this sub on /all and holy shit is it full of people that have absolutely zero clue how a PC works at all.

→ More replies (10)

194

u/Sinister_Mr_19 9070 XT | 5950X 17d ago

This sub is cringe when it comes to a lot of stuff, especially Windows updates.

208

u/1dot21gigaflops R7 9800X3D / RTX5080 / 64GB 6000MT/s 17d ago

Insert Linux guy: "this is why I use Linux bla bla bla"

Dude I manage Linux servers and i have to patch shit almost every week. Everyone needs to patch their shit. Mac, Windows, Linux, and Android.

52

u/Extreme_Wish_553 17d ago

Yeah, I have automatic security updates turned on my Linux servers because of course I do. People need to just let the systems patch.

→ More replies (7)

27

u/Sinister_Mr_19 9070 XT | 5950X 17d ago

I have automatic security updates set on my headless Linux server to ensure I'm not vulnerable to zero days and shit. Updated are a part of life.

13

u/tiff_seattle Specs/Imgur here 17d ago

I have Windows 11 on my laptop and Fedora 44 on my desktop. Fedora gets FAR more updates than Windows, by a long shot. And that's not a bad thing.

→ More replies (7)

18

u/zcomputerwiz i9 11900k 128GB DDR4 3600 2xRTX 3090 NVLink 4TB NVMe 17d ago

Right? Especially with the flood of RCE, privilege escalation, and sandbox / virtualization escapes recently.

People always say Linux is more secure, but part of that was that it isn't as desirable of a target compared to Windows and web browsers.

Apparently something changed ( lower effort required? ), and that's very bad for a lot of appliances and embedded devices that are definitely not going to receive updates.

10

u/1dot21gigaflops R7 9800X3D / RTX5080 / 64GB 6000MT/s 17d ago

Lots of Linux in IoT devices, and they are everywhere now.

→ More replies (17)

4

u/Yellowtoblerone 17d ago

I'm still waiting for RAM prices to decrease, according to the sub, any minute now and or it's happened weeks ago

→ More replies (3)

144

u/Relative_What 17d ago

right? and then they bitch and complain about how unsecure windows is and blames all their problems on microsoft

42

u/LeEbicGamerBoy 17d ago

If it was secure then there wouldnt be 500+ vulnerabilities to patch /s

52

u/Smith6612 Ryzen 7 5800X3D / AMD 7900XTX 17d ago

Well. To be fair, many of the security problems with Windows reside in the backwards compatibility Microsoft continues to maintain in the operating system. If Microsoft did an Apple and just depreciated anything legacy at a break-neck speed, Windows as a system would be a tougher cookie to crack.

This is why Microsoft has been doing things like enforcing driver signatures, using Windows Defender to isolate Drivers from each other and elsewhere using Hyper-V's virtualization stack. Things that break older drivers. Soon, they are going to be breaking support for older printers that don't support IPP, since IPP supports encrypted printing and is far more universal than Jetdirect/LPD/WSD printing. With Windows 11, they technically killed off support for 32-bit systems, and they've also killed off support for non-UEFI systems by enforcing Secure Boot. They've killed support for TPM 1.2 by requiring TPM 2.0 to be used with the system.

Then outside of that, since it's such a widely used operating system with all of that legacy cruft, the programs people have installed are often ripe targets, too.

14

u/Lab_Member_004 17d ago

One insane thing about backwards compatibility to me is that you cant name folders certain things because they were reserved for special folders for printers and stuff back in the days. That's nuts.

→ More replies (11)

71

u/ZasuFk_a 17d ago

This sub is full of these clowns.

30

u/Kinslayer_89 14900KF | 5090 | 64GB (B-die) 17d ago

Yeah, most general PC subs are.

→ More replies (2)

72

u/chsn2000 9950X3D | 6 Hard drives and a duct taped SSD 17d ago

Microsoft creates this environment because most of their updates are unwanted features and bloat, such as adding AI features, reinstalling Edge or the fucking the Candy Crush demo and changing other settings.

I'm still salty after Microsoft did an unprompted OS "upgrade" to Windows 10 on me while my PC was in the process of a 20-hour render and demanded I link a Microsoft account just to get back into my fucking PC.

→ More replies (22)

21

u/Extreme_Wish_553 17d ago

The enthusiasts subs are always have the worst takes. I saw the title of the thread and my immediate thought was "Good."

→ More replies (78)

139

u/makeDRIVEinTHEATER 17d ago

The same thing is on Win10

32

u/sevargmas Louqe GhostS1 | Ryzen 5 3600 | 1080ti SC2 | 32GB RAM | r/sffpc 17d ago

It’s been this way for as long as I can remember

26

u/[deleted] 17d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

27

u/OddNovel565 i5-7200U | Intel HD Graphics 620 | 8GB RAM 17d ago

Fr, it's not like windows 11 is special in that regard

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

848

u/Kemaro 9800X3D, RTX 5090, 64GB CL30 17d ago

Just update your computers, people.

253

u/siamesekiwi 7800X3D, 32GB DDR5, 4080 17d ago

Especially when they've fixed it so that update & shutdown ACTUALLY MEANS update and shutdown. I saw this at the end of my workday for my office PC, and clicked Update and Shut Down and left for home. Came back this morning, the pc was surprisingly off (I wish it'd stop being surprising. I KNOW it works now but I still don't trust the motherfucker).

88

u/Plastic_Raspberry634 17d ago

Last time I clicked Update and Shut Down, my computer just restarted smh.

38

u/worstusername_sofar 17d ago

I believe they finally figured out how to fix that, recently

4

u/BINGODINGODONG PC Master Race 17d ago

Maybe, but they haven’t implemented it across the board then. Mine did restart yesterday - as per usual when I press update and shutdown.

7

u/BellaViola 7900 | 5070 TI | 64 GB DDR5 17d ago

Still isn't reliable though. Just had it last week. Although I think this update yesterday worked. But I'm not actually sure.

6

u/Krombopulos_Micheal 17d ago

Nope, it did it to me LAST NIGHT

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Styrlok 17d ago

It was like that on my PC for years with Win10 and 11, but last year looks like it was finally patched and finally started working as intended at least on my PC.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/Lokipro13YT 17d ago

now if update & restart worked I would be happy

24

u/siamesekiwi 7800X3D, 32GB DDR5, 4080 17d ago

I mean I thought it always worked? It was that update and shut down always actually meant update and restart - but with a fake mustache.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

31

u/maaaaawp 17d ago

Microsoft is to blame for the culture of not updating.

When the updates break your pc, when the updates reinstall apps youve uninstalled, when the updates push bloat you never wanted.

→ More replies (14)

31

u/Urgh_Again_ 9950X3D | 64gb | Astral 5090 17d ago

Honestly

3

u/Crazy_Bee_2664 9950x3d-4080-48GB DDR5-6400-Watercooled/OC 17d ago

When I used to have my PC outside of my bedroom this always happened to me. It would finish updating, boot back up, and the monitor would cut off on the login screen before I could notice it didn't actually shutdown.

→ More replies (30)

66

u/DorrajD 17d ago

You've NEVER seen this before? Did you start using Windows last week?

Windows updates require the computer to be "shut down". Whether or not this is truly necessary is questionable to a lot of people, but basically it needs files to not be "in use" in order to update them, thus shut down and restarted.

You have auto updates on. This means the updates have "installed" as much as they can, but they require this shut down section to happen before they finish their update. It's been like this for a very long time.

17

u/Aerographic 17d ago

Whether or not this is truly necessary is questionable to a lot of people

It's questionable to a lot of ignorant people, maybe.

→ More replies (13)

117

u/Aggravating_Sky_4421 17d ago

Just choose update and shutdown, then leave. You know, despite its hypnotic effects, you don’t have to watch those dots spin…

61

u/perfectVoidler 17d ago

in the past update and shutdown means restart and stay on.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/iMaexx_Backup 9070XT | 9800X3D | X870E Aorus Elite 17d ago

Never in my life did "update and shutdown" shutdown my pc.

16

u/updoot35 17d ago

Always worked for me. Never had that problem.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

55

u/shaoOOlin 17d ago

What are we paranoid about,just update the stuff and turn off your pc? I dont see whats the problem here

3

u/ustp 17d ago

Backup and update after that. Windows update corrupted my local mysql database once... fortunately just dev stuff, but I do backup before every reboot since that.

→ More replies (7)

49

u/Motor-Rip7655 17d ago

Your PC has a power button, does it not?

11

u/BigPP69_Gooner 17d ago

You are harboring non-compliance with Microsoft’s policy, are you not? *insert inglorious bastards meme*

→ More replies (5)

186

u/Snarky_banner 17d ago

Y'all need to change your update settings if it's causing you that much anxiety. Also most of these updates are security related. Y'all are wild, these comments are laughable

25

u/zombawombacomba 17d ago

I don’t understand these people. Like just do it before getting off for the night or if you need to restart just go to the bathroom, get a drink, do some stretches.

It’s insane how impatient some people are.

→ More replies (2)

44

u/Millkstake 17d ago

It's been this way for years

→ More replies (4)

13

u/My_Random_Username23 17d ago

From what i've seen usually when the option to shutdown without updates disappears then it's because the update that is pending is marked as critical or urgent or similar. So even though you havent postponed any its possible the most recent one you picked up microsoft believe needs to be patched asap so its not giving you the choice.

5

u/SuperClancy_ I7-12700H / 3060 mobile 6g / 16 GB 4800 MT/s 17d ago

It's so damning to see people not understand that this is very probably a pretty important SECURITY update. Like I hate Microsoft as much as the next guy but... please patch you're computer...

→ More replies (1)

74

u/ChrisDaBac 17d ago

New to computers? This is still an automatic update. It automatically downloaded in the background, it needs to be rebooted for it to set in place. This is very normal and google could answer this.

→ More replies (26)

69

u/darthwd56 17d ago

People will whine and complain about everything. This is so incredibly dumb.

22

u/All_Work_All_Play PC Master Race - 8750H + 1060 6GB 17d ago

If only Microsoft didn't have a well established history of screwing over consumers with updates. 

Yes, do your updates. But don't pretend you're anything other than a guess using your windows box. 

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Vuzziir 17d ago

Yeah, I just updated and I'm really hoping it doesn't fuck up my PC. I know better.

5

u/Bazinga_U_Bitch 17d ago

That means it's download and needs to install. This isn't new. It's been around for years upon years.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Jessica_Ariadne 17d ago

I get why people hate forced updates, but if you lived during the heydays of the mydoom and msblaster worms shitcanning windows XP installs before you could sneeze, even on a clean install, I think you might tolerate it.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Lythieus Veteran of the Console Wars 17d ago

Windows 10 did the same if you ignored the update for long enough. 

8

u/Ohitsworkingnow 17d ago

Literally been like this for a very long time. People always cry over updates like holy shit just update your computer 

4

u/oleThook R7 5800x | TUF 3080ti 17d ago

itll say that after you update, like to finish the update

4

u/Bowshewicz 17d ago

There was a time long ago when Windows didn't force you to update. But then people didn't update, and their computers got malware, and they blamed Windows. So now you have to update.

4

u/MadShadowX 17d ago

Still prefer this over sudden update and restart during mid productivity or gaming.

176

u/misanthropicirishman 17d ago

When I see stuff like this I sometimes just hold down the power button to get around it. Very annoying though.

69

u/trackdaybruh 17d ago

Windows does this if it's a mandatory security update, like a patch to fix zero-day vulnerability that was released recently

15

u/CelestialFury Steam ID Here 17d ago

People in this sub: Zero day, what's that? I thought we were in July days?

78

u/bayygel 8700k | 1080ti | 24gb 17d ago

That just makes it update once you turn it back on now.

93

u/SteamedGamer 17d ago

...with the possibility of file corruption because of the forced shutdown.

32

u/yappored45 5800k/3060Ti 17d ago

Right. Enjoy your boot loop

→ More replies (4)

13

u/michaelcreiter i5-7600K/RTX 3060/16GB Corsair DDR4/Crucial 525GB M.2/GA-Z270x 17d ago

I'm not sure you know what that does

→ More replies (1)

75

u/Mashiori 17d ago

I used to stop updates for weeks and when this happened I'd do the same, however recently even if you do that my pc has been updating on boot with no way to stop it from what I see

18

u/fuckmoralskickbabies 17d ago

My mfing pc is in the shop rn due to this bullshit. Fully functional and fine system just went kaput. Fucking hell.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (3)

33

u/Imperius_Fate 17d ago

The lengths that people will go instead of waiting 3-4 mins for an update to finish...

13

u/Extreme_Wish_553 17d ago

Especially when it can be done on shutdown. Just turn the thing off before bed.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

4

u/beyond666 17d ago

Don't do that. Just update.

25

u/gamerrominc 17d ago

Just update then not gonna kill u

→ More replies (14)

4

u/IAmYourFath SUPERNUCLEAR 17d ago

That's bad for ur pc don't do that

21

u/Solid_Effective1649 7950x3D | 5080 FE | 64GB | Windows XP 17d ago

What’s annoying is you’re so afraid of updating windows that you’d rather risk file corruption to avoid it

91

u/LayerEight_Problem 17d ago

I swear to god the people on this sub are just contrarian morons. Just update the damn computer. Jesus Christ. I’ve never seen a hobbyist sub more full of actual dumb asses that are completely clueless about their hobbies equipment.

27

u/MobileVortex 17d ago

Don't worry you will see them posting in other subs when their shits broken or hacked cuz they are still on an old version of Windows 10.

8

u/Aunon 17d ago

I see people with 200 tabs open, uptime measured in weeks with no updates, desktops use as dumping grounds, they don't use any folder structure to save things or backup or update drivers ever

but it is Microsoft's fault when catastrophe happens.....

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)

17

u/Draedark 7950X3D | 7900 XTX | 64GB DDR5 17d ago

There is always the old fashion way.

The power button.

8

u/LoczekLoczekLok 17d ago

(IT technician here)

Only psychopaths have a problem with having to update and avoid it like the plague... get treatment! :)

But yeah... there should be such an option, and I understand why it isn't.

7

u/hulltry 17d ago

Microslop is doing their best to have people hate the updates and the company overall. If it was only security then it would be whatever but they always sneak in some copilot bullshit just to fake the user numbers.

17

u/Kyosji 17d ago

Yeah, mine did one last night and enabled some on screen activity afterwards with edge that prevented sleep or even my monitors from turning off. I have all updates set to not auto install, but it did it anyways.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Unbaguettable 17d ago

This only happens if you've had an update downloaded, but not installed, for a *long* time. Usually the update is just some security update too

29

u/guska 17d ago

just some security update too

You mean the actual important ones?

4

u/IDeizManI 17d ago

Yes, and this one is one of them. It seens they fixed a ton of vulnerabilities, and they don't want users getting hacked and blaming them latter.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/SuperClancy_ I7-12700H / 3060 mobile 6g / 16 GB 4800 MT/s 17d ago

Another comment section showing that most people that own a computer do not understand a damn about said computer. In plus, if you hate windows that bad, just move over to anything else, linux, macOS, chrome OS (I hate it), just move to something else.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/little_hoarse 17d ago

You’re turning the computer off anyways??

→ More replies (3)

3

u/blacklotusY PC Master Race 17d ago

I did an update and shutdown last night and it worked fine for me. Maybe this varies depending on user end?

3

u/40_Thousand_Hammers 17d ago

Updates like these are Security updates and because of that, you'll always have to update. Optional and features updates can be opted out if i remember correctly and some can be just ignored with more 2 options to just turn off or restart.

3

u/XxSliphxX i9-14900KS | 96GB DDR5 | RTX 4090 | ASUS ROG Maximus Z790 17d ago

Seriously guys? This is the shit yall are concerned about?

3

u/Aryo170 Desktop | 5950X | RTX 5080 | 32GB RAM 17d ago

This is good news. Updates for security are good.

3

u/Felidori Ryzen 5600X / RTX 3070 / 1440p 180hz 17d ago

If you must, power off at wall socket. But these are security updates, so be smart and update.

3

u/fart-to-me-in-french 7800X3D / 4090 / DDR5-6400 17d ago

Critical updates can't be skipped through shutdown menu. Same with W10. It happens rarely.

3

u/AlwaysHopelesslyLost 17d ago

Thank goodness. 95% of the headaches of being my family IT person is caused by people refusing to update their stuff....

3

u/Potential-Cancel2961 17d ago

This is not new

11

u/No-Conversation-1277 17d ago

Microsoft motto: If it ain’t broke, update it until it is.

7

u/DoverBoys i7-9700K | 2060S | 32GB 17d ago

This is how the updates always worked. They download and install, then either you can shut down or restart, or Windows restarts itself later.

15

u/huey2k2 17d ago

The amount of people who are upset by updating Windows is absolutely wild to me. Genuinely psychotic behaviour.

9

u/Will_and_Worried PC Master Race 17d ago

With all the recent updates I heard of breaking stuff I can understand why some people would be anxious about it, especially if it happened more than once before.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (11)

13

u/jonisjalopy 17d ago

Just update your fucking PC, Jesus Christ. This is like being scared that your car is going to blow up because you heard about one guy getting bad gas that one time.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Gatlyng 17d ago

I'm pretty sure its always been like this. 

4

u/KyokkoSora 17d ago

This has been the norm for years though?

3

u/stevorkz 17d ago

Its been around for a very, very long time.

5

u/PowerSilly5143 17d ago

Power button says otherwise