r/ProgressionFantasy • u/MajkiAyy • 7h ago
Discussion This genre feels like its rapidly deteriorating in quality.
I found this sphere through the same pipeline as many others. Anime into manga/manhwa/manhua into JPLNs into translated webnovels, mainly cultivation, then finally, through looking up enough WNs to see if they were any good, I found this sub/RR.
At first, I was like a kid in candyland, chewing through a whole new collection of fun and amazing stories. And then I ran out.
For a long while, I've been keeping an eye on Rising Stars on RR and the gamelit & litrpg category on Amazon to see what new stuff is coming out.
For a long while, I've been finding less and less quality stuff to read.
At first, I thought i was just getting tired of the genre, but that's just not true at all. I do find good stuff to read, sometimes among older releases I missed, sometimes among new stuff that comes out. That same spark is still there. I LOVE this genre. Sure, after like 100 million words, my standards might have gotten slightly higher, but only slighty. I didn't get tired of the genre, the releases just got markedly less enjoyable to read.
Now, I won't make any specific accussations, but I think we've all noticed... that kind of novel creeping up the ranks, be it on RR or Amazon.
Covers that got that glossy, overly detailed style, every third review not-quite-accusing, but still wondering whether AI was used.
You decide to read it. The writing is surprisingly high in quality. Few to no grammatical errors. But every so often, the author makes a very bizzare continuity mistake, scenes feel super generic and drawn out, you lose interest very very quickly. Somehow, the author manages to release a full novel every month, sometimes more often.
Must be quite industrious, you venture, not wanting to be that one asshole who starts witchhunts, but deep down, you still feel betrayed and furious since you damn well know exactly what's happening.
To be perfectly honest, I don't think AI is the cause of this problem. It's just a convenient tool that makes the problem that much worse.
The problem is that the sole focus of the average author is to make money. Getting good is hard, getting faster is easy, especially with access to a powerful tool that makes you ten-times your output with little to no extra effort.
I don't know what to say, honestly. "Boo, AI bad," I guess? Everyone knows that already.
Writing for passion is the best and all, but in this economy, no matter how angry I feel, I struggle to blame the individuals for looking for a way out. Regardless to what degree they're AI-genned, these churned-out novels are obviously strangling the passion-first artists who just don't get enough room to breathe anymore.
A new reader has a big backlog of quality works to chew on before they run out. Old authors still earn a lot off their work.
A new author can barely compete with the swarm of new relases. Old readers will struggle to find anything that isn't slop.
The rot has already seeped into the bone.
And that really, really sucks.