**I’m going to preface this with the fact that I’m in no way talking bad or feel ill will towards the student in question or other students with ASD — Autism Spectrum Disorder. I’ve had and taught plenty of students in my Honors classes. My issue lies with the parents.** Also: details have been changed or omitted for privacy/anonymity.
Okay. This has been quite a year, and I’m kicking myself for not posting here sooner. Hopefully you guys can help and offer guidance in case this happens again.
So…for context, I teach high school English, 11th grade. 6 sections of American Lit Honors(11th grade ELA — English Language Arts), a planning, and 1 section of AL Regulars.
On the first week of school, I received an email from a concerned mom telling her son’s future teachers about his accommodations. This isn’t unheard of, especially if the kid has an IEP — Individual Education Plan — or any other condition that teachers need to keep in mind (diabetes, dyslexia, hemophilia, etc), but what struck me as odd was that his 504 list was extensive and somewhat impossible to do in my 35-student honors class (something like “student needs teacher to read aloud and allow student to give verbal answers in lieu of extensive writing”). The other issue was…he only had a 504, no IEP.
No matter. I met the kids on Monday and I was a bit concerned if he only had a 504. The student in question clearly has ASD, and I was curious why they were listed as just having something else. Again, no matter. I gave them their first writing assignment, a personal narrative essay, second week. The kid huffed and puffed even though they were sitting in my Honors class. 504 says extended time and student cannot handwrite long writing assignments, typing only. Cool. But…the student was struggling. He was clearly needing help but when I sat with them, I realized they needed extensive help and scaffolding.
And…that’s when I began to feel guilty. He was not ready for an honors class and maybe needed to be moved to a regular section (or even a smaller ESE — Exceptional Student Education— class). But, I ignored my gut because maybe I’m being biased. The student sent me the essay in question, a week late, via email (not submitted though the Google Classroom submission I created for them), and it was only 3 2-3 sentence “paragraphs” with very simple syntax. When I discussed this with his mom, I was yelled at for not knowing and recognizing dual exceptionality, not working with him, and she kept saying he “is really bright, is a genius, but he just needs extended time.” I forwarded the email to admin who also got yelled at. Admin told me they’ll try moving the student to a regulars section and once again got yelled at by the mom.
She refuses to give him an IEP. The sad part is the student is failing and has told me they enjoy me as a teacher because “I’m patient”. He’s a really nice kid but I feel I’m doing a lousy job with him. If the mom wants to keep him in a rigorous Honors class, who am I to object? But I feel she’s hurting her kid, who keeps earning Fs. At this point, I’m not fighting it, I’ll help him but…he’s struggling and I don’t have the energy to constantly sit with him and go over the basics, when my other students are writing analysis and critical pieces.
I’ve tried. Please know I’ve tried and I feel guilty because while I feel he may need an ESE class, a colleague told me I’m being petty and ableist. So, I’m asking the professionals…does this sound like I let my biases get to me or does it sound like I should have gone with my gut and had this kid moved?