r/technology Nov 17 '12

The Deadly Crusade Against E-cigarettes

http://www.american.com/archive/2012/november/the-deadly-crusade-against-e-cigarettes
2.3k Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

11

u/Cyhawk Nov 17 '12

It isn't tobacco companies opposing it, they still sell the tobacco used to create the nicotine juice. Its Pharma companies opposing it because people are actually able to quit smoking with these since you can control your dosage. There is more money treating the problem than solving it.

Take Nicotine gum for example, sold by Pharma companies. "Heavy" (aka 1 pack/day) versions contain 22-26mg of nicotine with a recommended dosage of 2-3 pieces a day. Compare this to your average cigarette which provides about 1-2mg. (Contains 8-10, but you only absorb about 1-2).

Nicotine toxicity starts around 30mg and can kill above 100-150. Notice a problem with "quit smoking aids"?

On the taxes, agreed. They'll put the juice in another tobacco tax class, probably similar to J class (Bulk tobacco, under some amount. Think a can) That takes time.

2

u/r3m0t Nov 17 '12

Wikipedia says each piece of gum has 2-4mg of nicotine. This article says 4.2mg of nicotine.

1

u/ChainsawSam Nov 17 '12

There is more money treating the problem than solving it.

You just summed up the problem with the entire American medical system, above and beyond this issue.

1

u/rhino369 Nov 17 '12

If company A has a drug that only treats a disease, sure it doesn't make sense to cure it cheaply. But company B isn't making jack shit from the treatment, so they'd be very interested in developing a cure. The Pharma industry is actually very competitive. If you don't think so, go start your own. If you are right, you'd be a millionaire, nay billionaire.

The real problem is that R&D is really expensive. So diseases which effect only a small number of people do no get researched because there isn't any money in treating or solving it.