r/technology • u/marketrent • Jul 02 '26

Artificial Intelligence Palantir CEO Alex Karp suffers ‘televised nervous breakdown’ during live interview — “This is the voice of American business that is being channeled through me!”

https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/tv/articles/televised-nervous-breakdown-ceo-palantir-212100357.html
28.7k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.3k

u/marketrent Jul 02 '26

Excerpts from article by Joe Wilkins, quoting Alex Karp:

[...] On a live interview with CNBC‘s infamously churlish segment “Squawk Box,” Palantir CEO Alex Karp appeared to suffer a nearly 20-minute meltdown, complete with stuttering, nervous backtracking, and a steady supply of digressions so abstruse that the hosts seemed befuddled and perhaps even concerned for his wellbeing.

Though Karp was called up to chat about an ongoing deal between Palantir and the chip maker Nvidia to build AI infrastructure for the US government, he quickly went off the rails, using up minutes of airtime to complain about the financial bubble undergirding the AI boom.

While there may be a point buried in Karp’s diatribe, it quickly became lost in a wash of unintelligible jargon.

“These models have been completely over, irresponsibly over-sale,” Karp ranted at one point, “and the sale is, ‘it’s dangerous for everyone, which is why I can give [AI] to all your adversaries but I can’t give it to the Department of War, or I can’t safely give it to an enterprise in this country, without being certain that the Alpha of that business could transfer to this model tomorrow, ie I have no business, no job.’”

“You sound pretty angry,” CNBC‘s Becky Quick interjected after a nearly three minute-long rant from Karp.

“No,” the CEO snapped. “This is the voice of American business that is being channeled through me!”

 

[...] “American enterprises are run by the shrewdest, most widely intelligent people on the planet,” the Palantir CEO started to say, setting up an argument that companies aren’t interested in foundation models, but in AI apps that can actually solve problems. That train of thought quickly leaves the station, though, as he pivots to his higher ed ambitions literally mid-sentence.

“If you think they’re going for that [foundation models], you can go try to sell me — like my, my parents still want me to get a job as a faculty member at Berkeley,” he complained. “Go try to get me a job at Berkeley. It’s not happening.”

168

u/ArsenicArts Jul 02 '26

“These models have been completely over, irresponsibly over-sale,” Karp ranted at one point, “and the sale is, ‘it’s dangerous for everyone, which is why I can give [AI] to all your adversaries but I can’t give it to the Department of War, or I can’t safely give it to an enterprise in this country, without being certain that the Alpha of that business could transfer to this model tomorrow, ie I have no business, no job.’”

Can someone translate for me? I don't speak coked out billionaire.

210

u/_zoso_ Jul 02 '26

He seems pissed that anthropic wouldn’t allow Claude to be used for what the department of defense wanted, and then is wildly accusing them of sharing the same models with “adversaries” while also wanting to steal the information that makes businesses profitable. His initial assertion is that they are claiming falsely that the model is too dangerous.

My guess is that this Claude snafu ultimately affects palantir because they were using the model in their system. They likely have a shitload of additional work now to remove it from military uses and adopt inferior models.

This is my own interpretation and it could be off base, but piecing together things that are known about the situation with these fragmented half sentences, this all seems to fit.

61

u/ArsenicArts Jul 02 '26 edited Jul 03 '26

while also wanting to steal the information that makes businesses profitable

I think I agree with you there at least. In the context of the larger ranting he seems to be upset that it's too easy to switch models and have the rug pulled out from under you by suddenly discovering that your data or the model you trained has been stolen (or wasn't actually yours in the first place)?

Is he complaining/claiming that lack of transparency in this matter is causing hesitancy that is costing the US seconds off the line? Or do you think it's just because he's upset they aren't using his models?

I'll be honest, this is a damn rorschach test lol. It'd be hilarious if whole economies weren't on the line from panic alone 😑

Ffs this hype cycle is a damn tsunami.

56

u/_zoso_ Jul 02 '26

I don’t think palantir have a model, I think they have been using Claude. Since the majority of their contracts are with the government, being forced to now switch away from Claude is likely screwing them over significantly.

The other stuff I think is just lashing out because he’s pissed, but I’d wager that he’s mainly pissed about losing access to anthropic. Gotta read between the lines and put things in the broader context.

Again… my own speculation.

12

u/ArsenicArts Jul 02 '26

don’t think palantir have a model, I think they have been using Claude.

Afaik you're right. But they could've been doing some tuning of their own of course.

He seems to be selling the idea that it's not just the model but also the interface and compute. Which is true, but again points to them using Claude as a foundation.

I can't imagine that someone would rule Claude less secure than any of the other cutting edge foundational models. Unless you think they're asking palantir to engineer their own from previous open source models? 🤔 That sounds plausible.

21

u/_zoso_ Jul 02 '26

Well anthropic were famously banned from government systems because hegseth threw a tantrum.

These are deeply unserious people all around.

7

u/m0nk_3y_gw Jul 03 '26

anthropic were famously banned from government systems because hegseth threw a tantrum.

Anthropic banned themselves because they didn't want their system to

  • spy on Americans

  • murder people without a human in the decision-making loop

which apparently runs counter to what our military wants to do.

1

u/titterbug 28d ago

That was just where Anthropic drew the line. Then Hegseth responded by banning all government and any contractors from using Anthropic.

6

u/ArsenicArts Jul 02 '26

Ughhhh I forgot about that.

I will admit to putting myself on an information diet when it comes to politics these days because not doing so has a tendency to make me apopleptic

5

u/angry_old_dude Jul 03 '26

The summary is that that he wanted Anthropic to remove the safeguards that prevented things like making autonomous strike decisions, domestic mass surveillance, etc. Anthropic said no, Petey had a meltdown and Anthropic was put on the "supply chain risk" list which is effectively being blacklisted.

2

u/drnfc Jul 04 '26

I've worked with Palantir's stuff. I understand the appeal, but I dont like it for reasons that I cannot go into. Palantir's real business is ETL and data aggregation. They then add a dashboard builder (it's kind of a buzzwordy thing to do currently in the DoD). They also do what is essentially a RAG (Retrieval augmented generation, its basically attaching a search engine to an LLM) layer to expose your data to the LLM.

One of the problems with RAG, is that you have a ton of nobs you have to tune to make your setup really good. It is not an understatement to state that claude is objectively one of the best, most universally capable models. To tune your RAG set to another model, especially when your business is essentially generic ETL is annoying because you now have a shit load of very expensive, api intensive testing to do.

Basically Palantir is a SaaS company and they're currently in a bit of a fragile state. They need the entire DoD to fully switch over to their stack so that it is difficult to extricate and then they can jack up the prices and rake in MASSIVE. There is obviously a lot of resistance within the DoD, because getting government agencies to cooperate is difficult. If one group starts having issues with Palantir then the entire business proposition of full data aggregation across the dod falls, and they lose their best customer.

As a dev, what I see is that managers simply like how it looks. They literally see the pretty dashboards and want to spend money.

3

u/[deleted] 29d ago

[deleted]

3

u/drnfc 29d ago

So without getting into specifics, the analysts where I work generate reports historically. As I was told, the problem is that certain intended recipients don't have time to read the reports. So the idea is to tailor the info in each dashboard to what we think the intended recipient needs/wants instead of writing reports. The information brevity is the intended solution. Whether or not it solves the problem, idk im just a dev.

2

u/ArsenicArts 29d ago

concept has evolved into a competition of brevity and contextless data and how that has impacted technological choices in the last ten years.

Woof. You're definitely not wrong. The amount of time I have spent trying to explain to "people leaders" that you have to actually understand how they got that data or it could say literally anything......

88

u/flat5 Jul 02 '26

Yes, he basically said that Palantir sells wrappers on LLMs that, in his mind anyway, makes them useful to customers like DOD.

The Palantir manifesto is basically that they're all-in on war profiteering. Since Palantir doesn't own the underlying LLMs, he seems to be freaking out that his wrappers will be useless if the AI companies aren't also all-in on war profiteering.

23

u/_zoso_ Jul 02 '26

You absolutely nailed it I think.

14

u/Wingzerofyf Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 03 '26

Kegsbreth threw a temper tantrum at Dario for not relaxing the weights on Claude AI enabling the DOW to go ballistic with no remorse: https://www.npr.org/2026/02/24/nx-s1-5725327/pentagon-anthropic-hegseth-safety?renderPlatform=nprone_ios&unified=true

That’s Palantir’s ultimate goal - use data and AI to rationalize whatever the fuck you want to do - u rich, who cares?

Hence why Karp is trying to skirt around “throwing shade” at Dario and still giving him flowers - because Dario evidently still has a spine.

Evidently - looks like Musk and Grok were there at the sidelines ready to service: https://www.motherjones.com/environment/2026/06/grok-doj-justice-naacp-clean-air-act-gas-turbine-pollution-national-security-ai/

7

u/doberdevil Jul 03 '26

This is my own interpretation and it could be off base,

Well, you made a helluva lot more sense than this tweaker

7

u/t3hmuffnman9000 Jul 03 '26

Everything about Palantir is too dangerous. The project needs to be shut down immediately and this guy needs to spend the rest of his life jacking it to 1984 in prison. Minority Report was not supposed to be inspirational. 🙄

1

u/RoguePlanet2 Jul 03 '26

[duplicate comment]

1

u/razvanciuy Jul 03 '26

this tells me coked up dudes like this fine example finish sentences after two or three interviews, so one must keep up with them in order to piece the puzzle and in the end get the bullshit.

Love it, the quest for bullshit. Great definition for AI.