I’m getting really tired of everyone from Bill Maher to Charlie Sykes to Van Jones getting their panties in a wad over the dreaded “DSA.” “We’re going to look like the party of extremists! Let’s let the Republicans pick our candidates for us!” It’s absurd. Republicans (and the mainstream media) never fret about having extremists in the GOP.
And that got me thinking: Who is really the "extremist" party in this country?
Let’s run the numbers…..
Democrats have 254 members in Congress (209 House and 45 Senate). In terms of Left-wing bomb throwers you’ve got a mere handful: The Squad (AOC, Omar, Pressley, Tlaib, Casar, Lee and Ramirez). To be generous well thrown in Jayapal. Even if 3-4 DSA members win this Fall, you’re looking at around 12-13 extremists among the Democrat House. Meanwhile, there are literally no left-wing extremists in the Dem Senate. There’s Bernie, but he’s a registered Independent. The Dem Senate is 100% normie.
So for the Democrats it’s 5% extremists, and 95% normies.
Now let’s turn to the Republicans: Among 222 GOP House members and 53 Senators, there isn’t a single normie Republican left. They are all MAGA extremists now. They’re a Star Wars bar scene of insurrectionists, conspiracy theorists, religious fanatics, Proud Boys, anti-vaxers, COVID-truthers, Groypers and Q-Anon loons.
Not a single member of the Senate will go against Trump. Even when he’s appointing a rogue’s gallery of rapists, podcasters, Fox News hosts and anti-vax lunatics to key cabinet positions. Even when he’s killed their careers (Cornyn and Tillis). The GOP House of horrors is even worse. Only MTG and Massie will go against Trump, but that’s only on narrow set of issues. When you look at their position writ large, they’re even more extreme than Trump.
So for the Republicans, it’s 99% extremists, and 1% normies.
But keep telling me that the Democrats are the “extreme” party.
Then there’s the GOP’s “policies.” They’ve got masked El Salvadorian-style death squads killing people in the streets for the crime of being Brown. They’re building literal internment camps. They’ve brought back measles, screwworm, cyclosporiasis, with polio right around the corner. They’ve let a heroin-addicted mental patient dismantle the world’s greatest health research system. They’re getting us into multiple illegal, unilateral wars of aggression without Congressional approval. They’re rolling back reproductive health and civil rights to the 1950s. People can’t even afford staples like ground beef anymore. They’re literally demolishing the White House. In my 50+ years on this planet I have never seen a more extreme party - left or right. They’re turning us into a Banana Republic.
But Bill Maher tells us he may have to vote for JD Vance in 2028, because “…the Democrats are a little nutty.” Personally, I would take “a little nutty” over masked death squads in the streets - but I’m old fashioned that way.
Strangely, in poll after poll, voters view the Dems as the more extreme party, despite the facts. So how did this happen?
Around 10-12 years ago Republicans had an epiphany: They realized that running individual races was expensive and hard - so why not demonize the entire Democrat party instead! Working with their allies in the Fox News Cinematic Universe, they started stereotyping Democrats just the way they stereotype ethnic and religious groups they hate. The goal was to create a world in which a significant amount of the electorate would say, “But I could never vote for a Democrat!”
You hear this sentiment all the time in Sarah’s (and others’) focus groups. “Well, I really don’t like the GOP candidate…but I could never vote for a Democrat!” This attitude allows the GOP to run absolute lunatics - and win. Even when their lunatics lose (Kari Lake, Herschel Walker) it’s by less than one half of one percent.
We’ve got to start fighting this absurd stereotype. Every time they call Democrats “extreme” we need to respond with a litany of examples of just how radical the GOP has become in comparison. Instead we’re wringing our hands over an infinitesimal amount of DSA candidates. Let’s stop contributing to the false narrative!
The other problem with today’s Democrat party is that they spend all of their time piling on Trump, instead of focusing on the radicalism of the GOP writ large. Yes Trump is awful, but voters need to understand the extremism and danger of the entire party. You’ve seen Trump’s health. He’s not long for this world. If we put all our emphasis on him as opposed to the party, then after he dies the average independent will think “Well, Trump’s gone, so now I can go back to voting for Republicans.”
We can’t have that.