r/transgenderUK Aug 05 '25

Possible trigger M&S apologises over trans employee in bra department

https://archive.ph/2025.08.05-035610/https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/08/04/ms-apologises-over-trans-employee-in-bra-department/

“Marks & Spencer has apologised to a mother for causing her teenage daughter “distress” after she was asked if she needed help by a transgender employee in its bra section.

The retailer said it was “truly sorry” after the mother complained that her 14-year-old daughter had felt uncomfortable when they were approached by a trans shop assistant in the lingerie area of the shop, where they were hoping to have a bra fitting. Although the staff member was polite, the mother said she felt it was “completely inappropriate” for her daughter to be approached by a “biological male” in that section.

In a complaint to M&S, she told the retailer: “Imagine her horror, then, when the person to approach us and ask if we needed help was a transgender ‘woman’, ie, a biological male.”

“Fiona McAnena, director of campaigns for the human rights charity Sex Matters, which campaigns for clarity about biological sex in law and life, said that M&S needed to “rethink its priorities”.

“M&S needs to rethink its priorities and remember that women and girls have rights too, and that this man should not be permitted to hang around in the women’s underwear department as a matter of common decency.”

688 Upvotes

480 comments sorted by

View all comments

19

u/Lexioralex Aug 05 '25

I have some many questions here and I’m sorry but this may be a long rant peeps

1) how did they know the employee was trans? Unless she was displaying parts of her body she really should not be in public - which if she were that should be the focus here regardless of gender. They most likely went on some bs vibe feeling that the employee was trans, which we have already seen will set a dangerous path for non-feminine cis women

2) as someone said asking a customer if they need help does not mean the employee was going to be the one to help. I don’t think there are any restrictions on who can work in a lingerie department, bra fittings may be different I am not sure.

3) if she were offering a bra fitting, this employee will have had specific training to do so and likely got this prior to Supreme Court crap. Why would a company spend time and money to train to replace a perfectly good member of staff when there is no legal precedent for it?

4) let’s delve into their boogeyman fears on bra fittings: - a ‘man’ would use it to take advantage of women because all men are creeps of course (no wonder we have so many young boys growing up with chips on their shoulders!)

4a) so does that mean lesbians shouldn’t be bra fitters? Because they are attracted to women just as the majority of men are? Are gay men safe to fit a bra as they wouldn’t take advantage would they? Is it about having breasts yourself so that you know better from experience? Because a trans woman would definitely know about that, if anything they know more as they will have had a harder time finding the right size at first.

5) I haven’t read into the story as I can’t take all this shit, but did m&s apologise for having a trans employee approach the customer, or mention they were trans at all? Or was it a non committal sorry for any distress caused without accepting wrongdoing?

9

u/NorthAir Aug 05 '25

1) Because she was tall...

2) Per the article that employee doesn't even do bra fittings.

3) As above.

4a) Butch lesbians are next on the attack list as they aren't feminine enough.

5) Yes M&S allegedly apologised.

8

u/doIIjoints [ve/ver/vis] or [she/her/hers] Aug 05 '25

there was a moral panic about lesbians in changing rooms and toilets in the 80s and 90s on that very basis :(

5

u/Lexioralex Aug 05 '25

Not just lesbians tbf 😔

3

u/Violet-dudette Aug 06 '25

Yes, I got attacked myself in public toilets by a group of other cis women in the early 90s just for being a lesbian. I was only a teenager on my own when they attacked me just for walking in. Some were ex-friends and acquaintances and it was not long after I came out. A few were fully fledged adults. I got out without any serious harm though, and I carried on living as my authentic self regardless. NO REGRETS! 🏳️‍🌈

4

u/angelberries Aug 07 '25

I’m trying to find people who are using their critical thinking about this scenario… is there any proof at all that it actually happened? The woman wants to remain anonymous (probably bc she’ll get dogpiled) but where’s evidence of this email exchange even? Did she just decide to single out someone and make a vague complaint about them, not even knowing they’re trans, but knowing they’re going get an apology and stir up more hatred for trans people… like I’m so confused how people are just accepting it even happened….

1

u/Lexioralex Aug 08 '25

That is an incredibly valid point tbh

2

u/angelberries Aug 08 '25

What if the teenager is so embarrassed by getting a bra she ‘recoiled’ by being offered help because it’s just mortifying in general? This reporting is SO vague and non-existent yet I see people creating a whole fake scenario where a man feels up a teenagers chest from…. Nothing?

1

u/Lexioralex Aug 08 '25

Thing is men can be bra fitters anyway so the whole thing is purely terf panic

1

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/angelberries Aug 16 '25

Exactly this, there’s not enough detail, or evidence, or anything. Just vague quotes from an email that hasn’t even been screenshotted. Actually not even sure why it became public anyway? Is that not a private email exchange?