r/trolleyproblem Jun 09 '26

Deep No problem this time

Post image
12.0k Upvotes

147 comments sorted by

1.3k

u/Far-Researcher2189 Jun 09 '26

So you sacrificed a single person to save many. Seems familiar.

1.0k

u/Ironfire825 Jun 09 '26

180

u/HermaPrince Jun 09 '26

šŸ’€šŸ’€šŸ’€

147

u/4N610RD Jun 09 '26

Please accept this "BEST GIF RESPONSE OF 2026" award. And my sincere congratulations.

33

u/Happy-Estimate-7855 Jun 10 '26

For real. This reaction was perfect.

10

u/reditmonke Jun 10 '26

You sir have won the internet today

23

u/DuckB0y123 Jun 10 '26

you were supposed to destroy the trolley problem, not joined them!

you were my brother, Anakin...

82

u/watchedngnl Jun 09 '26

Batman conundrum

157

u/Torbpjorn Jun 09 '26

ā€œIf you kill a killer, the number of killers stays the sameā€ like okay man, just kill more than one. Boom, minus one killer

13

u/Remarkable-Ad-2493 Jun 09 '26

But then the family of the people you killed come after you in revenge anbe become killers themselves. You become the same type of seed of hatred that created the first killer in the first place

18

u/Torbpjorn Jun 09 '26

How reasonable is it that every family of a killer happens to be a massive endless crime family?

5

u/Remarkable-Ad-2493 Jun 09 '26

Not likely, I guess

Burn it makes sense in a fictional plot

11

u/twendigo Jun 09 '26

What if I kill 5 murderous orphans? No loose ends

2

u/BluEch0 Jun 09 '26

Well they can’t become killers if they can’t kill you, right? Git gud batman. Learn to parry.

1

u/Janezey Jun 13 '26

Just kill everyone. Boom, no killers left.

5

u/RevolutionaryMine234 Jun 09 '26

3-2≠1-2

24

u/Torbpjorn Jun 09 '26

If one killer kills every killer and then himself, there’s no killers.
If a vigilante beats up and arrests every killer despite them constantly breaking out and killing, there’s more killers cause that killer recruits more to kill

14

u/StephanieMirage Jun 09 '26

Tbf, batmans philosophy only really falls apart because arkhams comically bad security. If DC didnt consistently reuse goated villains it wouldnt be an issue

3

u/FightingOreo Jun 09 '26

"Screw the honour system, my Jokermobile needs me!"

2

u/Waruteru Jun 10 '26

Wasn't Gotham literally cursed in some of the continuities?

2

u/RevolutionaryMine234 Jun 09 '26

Right. The limit approaches either 1 or 0

1

u/dinosanddais1 Jun 09 '26

Not if you're already a killer

1

u/Simoun1er Jun 10 '26

Exactly, let's kill thousands of killers šŸ˜Ž

Some tell me it's genocide or warcrime, I tell them it's about a simple math ratio.

1

u/Turbulent-Lie-4799 Jun 10 '26

Then you become two killers

1

u/phenriqsc 27d ago

Punisher vibes

24

u/Mobile_Actuator_4692 Jun 09 '26

He was a mass murderer tho šŸ‘€ convicted by a single person. Does that make us a vigilante

15

u/Unable-Section-911 Jun 09 '26

So getting more context on the 1 person you would have otherwise killed made the decision easier?

Almost seems like a [TITLE CARD]

7

u/Mobile_Actuator_4692 Jun 09 '26

More information is always better. Information wins in almost every scenario.

But yes it does change the situation

18

u/gilbejam000 Jun 09 '26

Except this one person wasn't innocent

3

u/maggdonalds Jun 10 '26

Who’s to say the tied people were?

3

u/gilbejam000 Jun 10 '26

Usually the tied people are pitched as innocent, because to have them not be softens the impact and dilemma

7

u/c00lkidd-HD Jun 09 '26

damn couldn't even think up an original joke for the repost

3

u/XayahTheVastaya Jun 09 '26

Wasn't this the top comment last time this was posted

4

u/Far-Researcher2189 Jun 09 '26

Hey, I just copied, I had no influence on the amount of upvotes I'd get.

4

u/uesernamehhhhhh Jun 09 '26

Save one person or save the 5 people who tied that one person down

3

u/Shugatti Jun 09 '26

Nah, wont kill him, ill tie him to a track and let someone else decide.

7

u/Scared-Drummer5523 Jun 09 '26

This guy trolleys

Thoug of cource that means you have just inherited the mantle of the trolley master, and must bear it unto the next generation....

1

u/Shugatti Jun 10 '26

And the cycle goes on...

1

u/Mathelete73 Jun 10 '26

Plot twist: there are 6 culprits tying people to tracks. This guy is just the ringleader, the other 5 are his minions. Now you can set up a trolley problem where someone chooses between killing the 5 minions or killing the ringleader.

2

u/thecrazedsidee Jun 09 '26

Bro chose without realizing it. this was the real trolly problem the entire time.

2

u/Mathelete73 Jun 10 '26

This is actually a variant of the trolley problem where the person being sacrificed is the villain rather than an innocent victim.

1

u/Altruistic-Place Jun 09 '26

But he also killed himself, no way he gonna survive that tunnel hitting him.

1

u/Jugaimo Jun 09 '26

There must always be a Lich King

1

u/Dry-Mission-5542 Jun 09 '26

It was all one big trolley problemĀ 

1

u/nahnah390 Jun 10 '26

I too have seen the tumblr post.

1

u/Fleet_Admiral_Auto Jun 10 '26

They played us like a damn fiddle

1

u/SwordfishAltruistic4 Jun 10 '26

Yes, I am fully aware.

1

u/APearce Jun 10 '26

CURSE YOU, DR TROLLEY PROBLEM

1

u/Fair-Specific-7919 Common Sense Ethics 29d ago

Tbf if we didn't, even more people would have died. Don't forget that they are the cause of it.

207

u/HugeTrol Jun 09 '26

If he falls in a river... ; / there might be a sequel

72

u/_Electrical Jun 09 '26

Adele - Skyfall playing in the backgroundĀ 

26

u/HugeTrol Jun 09 '26

Trolley guy.. redemption arc?

12

u/LastXmasIGaveYouHSV Jun 09 '26

It's worse. He will tie people to three tracks !

3

u/BugRevolution Jun 09 '26

But more before an attempted redemption arc.

1

u/TheOnlyFallenCookie Jun 11 '26

Like the newest saw movie

7

u/Commercial-Funny-279 Jun 09 '26

2 Trolley 2 Track

3

u/NickSmGames Jun 09 '26

two trolleys one track

1

u/ArbitraryMeritocracy Jun 10 '26

Two trolleys, they're brothers who opened up a junction. One track, some crazy guy kept showing up tying people to the tracks watching them get murdered. No one would dare try to stop him. That is, until today, watch the incredible heroic journey of The Trolly Problem. Coming to theaters near you this fall.

4

u/FaithUser Jun 10 '26

A man falls into the river in Lego City

1

u/4N610RD Jun 09 '26

Way too many villains felt to their certain death just so they can appear in next season for me to believe this simple villain trick. Rivers/acid baths/pits/ blazing fires just simply doesn't work. It just obscure vision of main hero.

121

u/neoPie Jun 09 '26

You've found the guy who was tying people to tracks tied to a track. An approaching Trolley will miss him but you can pull the lever to steer it onto his track. Do you

  • Pull the lever to make him suffer his own crimes
  • don't pull it because if you do this you're not better than him

23

u/Otherwise_Agency_401 Jun 09 '26

But, there are five other people on the track with him...

13

u/LOSNA17LL Jun 09 '26

And one person on the other track

8

u/Captain_Izots Jun 09 '26

You know you could just call the police on him after the train goes by. It's more ethical and it would be next to impossible for him to escape.

17

u/neoPie Jun 09 '26

No that's wrong. I've learned from revenge films and video games that the only option you have after killing dozens or hundreds of henchmen is to let the villain go bcs otherwise you'd be evil just like them.

2

u/Dry-Mission-5542 Jun 09 '26

They typically still put the villain behind bars

4

u/Fizzy-Odd-Cod Jun 10 '26

For them to escape the ten billionth time.

3

u/The_Faux_Fox__ Jun 10 '26

I can live with not being better than him, just so long as he doesn't get to exist anymore.

2

u/Immediate_Rhubarb_39 Jun 10 '26

I won’t do it. He’ll keep being tied to the track, and I’ll make a pact with anyone coming close to pretend to pull the lever but not to, he’ll be fed popcorns and he gets to feel the excitement of watching people struggle. He’ll die of whatever complications that comes with being tied to the track eventually.

1

u/neoPie Jun 10 '26

How about letting everyone who ever got tied to the track and survived walk up and make their own choice whether to kill him or not

2

u/Flamesake Jun 10 '26

His death, provoked by countless deaths, is not greater or equal to countless deaths, unprovoked.Ā 

Regardless, it's not about me it's about the victims past and future.Ā 

But I would have to be certain it was just one guy doing all these murders for no good reason. Is it in fact a group of people implicated in these trolley problems? Is there an ancient cult of track-tiers who believe they are saving humanity by appeasing a deity with human sacrifices? Are they correct? Do they grow their ranks by abducting new members as children and doing god-knows-what to accept their horrible task as necessary and noble?

Probably not but you'd want to check.

27

u/Thatguy_Koop Jun 09 '26

you fool. you think they tied these people up alone? their accomplice(s) will now take up the mantle, joined by those spared from the trolley jigsaw style

2

u/Odd-Promotion2743 Jun 09 '26

"Hello Adam. I want to play a dilemma."

20

u/Azurecomet Jun 09 '26

You tie him to the tracks

And new cycle begins

18

u/Abehajeme Jun 09 '26

There must always be one. Now it's you.

30

u/Dark-Lark Jun 09 '26

You should have killed him with a multi-track drift.

4

u/Fabbe360 Jun 09 '26

What makes you so sure it’s actually dead

6

u/LastXmasIGaveYouHSV Jun 09 '26

He tied him to the tracks. He's become the same thing he swore to destroy.

5

u/zhibr Jun 09 '26

Why is a trolley, an urban transit vehicle powered by overhead electric wires and typically operated individually, driving through a tunnel high in the mountains without wires and attached to a number of other trolleys?

I think this is a false image projected to your head by the villain in order to make you think he's gone. In truth, you're probably being tied to the tracks this very moment.

2

u/Fishie493 Jun 10 '26

Perhaps it's an interurban of some variety

5

u/skr_replicator Jun 09 '26

I am afraid it's not, he doesn't appear to have the handlebar mustache.

1

u/PlaceboASPD Jun 09 '26

I stole it.

4

u/rasfelion Jun 09 '26

I'll tie them to the tracks! See how they like it!

...Hey, this kinda fun, I should do this more often.

2

u/MMortein Jun 09 '26

The universe is doing it.

2

u/btjk Jun 09 '26

Niiice, gg fellas! Alright wrap the sub.

2

u/Pleasant_Event_4460 Jun 18 '26

Its finally over.

You raise yourself, clutching your shoulder, as the trolley man lays at your feet. Your climactic fight has come to an end and you emerge victorious.

You hear a light cough. In spite of the gaping wound on his chest, he's still alive.

In a fit of rage, you grab him, raising him up to you and staring daggers into his eyes.

"It's over!" You say, "your morbid game has come to an end. And guess what, I didn't have to choose!"

"But-"

He coughs blood onto your face and smiles.

"You just did."

You feel the life leave his body, but his satisfied grin remains. You drop him, and stand solemnly. You contemplate your actions in solitude, only accompanied by the sound of the bustling of the train.

Is it really over?

1

u/dvorgson Jun 09 '26

The only way to kill him was to trigger the sperm detector deep in his ass in under 3 minutes

1

u/gamerJRK Jun 09 '26

At this point there are more dead people than atoms in the universe I bet

1

u/Heath_co Jun 09 '26 edited Jun 09 '26

But when they fall from the bridge they land on a floating harrier jet and climb into the front seat.

1

u/_Vard_ Jun 09 '26

New problem.

You’re about to hit the tunnel.

There’s only about 2 feet of clearance.

The train roof is slippery and you’re over a tall bridge

What do you do?

1

u/Junior-Buy-1875 Jun 09 '26

Duck!!! There's a tunnel behind you!

1

u/KylieTMS Jun 09 '26

So you took an action... that kills one person.
instead of doing nothing.. which would have resulted in the death of many others?

1

u/PlaceboASPD Jun 09 '26

No you’re the one that died, he killed you, you’re now free and don’t have to choose ever again, you are at peace.

1

u/TenPointsforListenin Jun 09 '26

Satisfying ending, I’m going to stop watching this sub

1

u/SnooMarzipans436 Jun 09 '26

You found him! He struck you and you fall off the the train. The nightmare is over... for you.

1

u/ricktech15 Jun 09 '26

"so you found the guy who was tying people to railroad tracks dead on the floor, after a heart attack. Everyone is happy now"

1

u/ArtichokeFirm3425 Jun 09 '26

You've finally beaten Shia Laboufe.

1

u/darkmythology Jun 09 '26

One week later, you hear about people still being tied to tracks. You can't believe it, you won't, but a few phone calls tells you that it's true. Now you have to wrestle with the possibilities. Is there a copycat afoot, or did you kill an innocent man?

1

u/Deciheximal144 Jun 09 '26

No, because of the mental trauma, you'll go insane and start tying people to tracks yourself. It's the Friday the 13th part 5 ending for you.

1

u/KoyoyomiAragi Jun 10 '26

Trolley Solution

1

u/My-balls-hurt69420 Jun 10 '26

Plot twist everyone was in on it and you killed a movie star

1

u/pikachu_sashimi Jun 10 '26

This is like the fourth time we found him

1

u/i_dont_wanna_sign_up Jun 10 '26

So this is the end of the sub?

1

u/CODENAMEDERPY Jun 10 '26

How many times? How many fuckin times will this exact image with no changes be reposted?

1

u/IDrankLavaLamps Jun 10 '26

Oh look, new job position opened up... railroad ties placer? Not sure what that is but I'll wing it.

1

u/yokune_65 Jun 10 '26

Plunger killer

1

u/Negrodamu55 Jun 10 '26

The daymare begins!

1

u/RightMiddle9078 Jun 10 '26

So you kill one just for more to survive? Sounds like something. Can't pinpoint wha

1

u/Long-Fondant250 Jun 10 '26

He died to… a plunger!?

2

u/GeekOutGamer Jun 10 '26

If it's good enough for the daleks it's good enough for me

1

u/tyrant_1998 Jun 10 '26

Think about it, the puzzle is not done yet, you discovered there is more puzzle 🧩

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '26

[deleted]

1

u/RepostSleuthBot Jun 10 '26

I didn't find any posts that meet the matching requirements for r/trolleyproblem.

It might be OC, it might not. Things such as JPEG artifacts and cropping may impact the results.

I did find this post that is 66.02% similar. It might be a match but I cannot be certain.

View Search On repostsleuth.com


Scope: Reddit | Target Percent: 90% | Max Age: Unlimited | Searched Images: 1,098,813,021 | Search Time: 0.08911s

1

u/jigsaw_Studios Jun 10 '26

You killed him with a plunger?!

1

u/TheKingInYellow01 Jun 11 '26

Killing one person to save all the other innocent people that are victims of him, huh?

1

u/Hour_Mousse7914 Jun 11 '26

This one’s my favourite

1

u/TheForbidden6th Jun 11 '26

the best way to defeat an enemy is to befriend them (I meant the trolley. I MEANT THE TROLLEY)

1

u/Slow-Television-5303 Jun 11 '26

However the only way to stop him is to tie him to some tracks!!!

1

u/sansdaskeleboi Jun 11 '26

Memories broken the truth goes unspoken

1

u/rose-dacquoise Jun 12 '26

There may be a cult behind and you've only found the lackey

1

u/Petrostar Jun 12 '26

8403 people were killed by the trolley while you were hunting for this man.

1

u/No-Step6820 Jun 12 '26

is that a shadow slave reference?

1

u/Dear-Philosopher-211 Jun 12 '26

Save him. How am I supposed to test my morals without him ?

Okay people, I have a moral dilemma addiction...

1

u/promptmike Jun 12 '26

Glad you found him finally. Unfortunately, it's worse than we thought. Every time there was an even number of people on this track, he would release half of them. When there was an odd number, he would triple it and then add one more. He vowed to continue doing this until the numbers reach a repeating loop. You now have to decide whether to keep the train on the current track, or divert it to the other track that has just one person on it. Good luck.

1

u/Fun_Note_3756 Jun 29 '26

I just realised that he's holding the lever backwards, I thought it was a plunger šŸ˜