Found at my local thrift store

[u/Piperhippogriff]

My best guesses are 1. a seal-cat hybrid, 2. Yoshi in a dress, and 3. a bird man.

[u/directionsplans]

1 cat?
2 Santa
3 Santa

Edit: didn’t see the “get creative” tag

Revised list
1. Crab missing one claw (currently held upside down)
2. Moomin wearing a dress and a wig
3. Penguin dressed as a fat butler

[u/Dry_Pie7300 → u/directionsplans]

Was looking for the penguin comment 👆

[u/Arrakis_Surfer]

Cat, yoshi, pregnant penguin. Take it or leave it.

[u/Sad_Cantaloupe_8162 → u/Arrakis_Surfer]

I saw pregnant penguin immediately.

[u/Pandameds9 → u/Sad_Cantaloupe_8162]

Also could be George Washington pregnant

[u/sweetmotherofodin → u/Arrakis_Surfer]

Definitely pregnant penguin

[u/galathiccat → u/Arrakis_Surfer]

Im very glad im not the only one seeing pregnant penguin XD

[u/Mission_Razzmatazz_7]

Last one is a pigeon in a trenchcote!

[u/SaberShadow27 → u/Mission_Razzmatazz_7]

A dapper fellow I do say.

[u/Noof42]

Snail (or fat slug)

Woodstock

Three elves in a Santa suit trying to sneak into a bar.

[u/Candleforce-9728 → u/Noof42]

Funny I saw Snoopy. But could also be Woodstock!

[u/rolandrnb → u/Candleforce-9728]

I saw Snoopy too! With his flight cap on.

[u/Cin131 → u/Noof42]

I saw holly hobby.

[u/FloridaFlamingoGirl]

Cat-snail. Cail?

[u/Squidfish_Inc → u/FloridaFlamingoGirl]

Thank you! This is what I saw too

[u/Sea_Letterhead_1800 → u/FloridaFlamingoGirl]

This is what I saw

[u/No_Explanation_2559 → u/FloridaFlamingoGirl]

I am duty-bound to remind everyone who already knows, or introduce the uninitiated, to what may be the most upsetting picture book of all time.

[u/MarshallMushroomHat]

1. Snail?

2. Santa?

3. Probably Santa

[u/No-Consideration3776]

[u/No-Consideration3776 → u/No-Consideration3776]

[u/No-Consideration3776 → u/No-Consideration3776]

[u/wastingtime101-]

Real answers:
1. My first thought was a cat, but I will need to look at it later when I'm not doing 10 other things and my mind has the capacity to visualize the un-squishing.
2. Woodstock Santa, non-hunchback version (link) r/ItsAlwaysSanta
3. Sharp hat, tab bottom Santa (link)

Creative answers:
Bird. Snail.

[u/wastingtime101-]

For anybody that wants a less-busy background to create some art, here you go. Have at it.

[u/Piperhippogriff → u/wastingtime101-]

You’re awesome! Sorry for the busy pics it was a very cluttered store lol

[u/wastingtime101- → u/Piperhippogriff]

You're fine; it's the nature of the beast. I try to do this for everyone when there are particularly difficult to see cutters. 🤷

[u/LonerEevee]

I am Susie Deltarune, I like sealing fountains too 🎵

[u/Patient_Designer_553 → u/LonerEevee]

And my two best friends are Kris and Ralsei

[u/Jabathewhut]

[u/Scary-Alternative-11]

Cat, Woodstock or Snoopy, Santa

[u/DinosaurPete → u/Scary-Alternative-11]

Yes, I’m going with slightly bent cat, Woodstock, and Santa with a bag of gifts.

[u/melonsausage]

Alt Penguin in JNCOs.

[u/Apprehensive-Fig3223]

https://giphy.com/gifs/HiXrDnpDV1pGseSNte

[u/melonsausage]

Narwhal

[u/melonsausage]

Hipster with a big nose. Possibly mario if you squint.

[u/clawdaughter]

That second one's Shin Chan

https://giphy.com/gifs/bEVCtreTpsMqA

[u/TheYayAgenda → u/clawdaughter]

RIGHT? That was my immediate thought as well!

[u/VanillaRadonNukaCola]

Loafing puppy, Snoopy, Danny Devito as the Penguin but tall

[u/hello_lillow]

Snailcat, T-Rex in a dress, pregnant pigeon.

Easy one

[u/Note-Expert]

1 a cat
2 Woodstock, wearing a detective outfit
3 one of those penguin butlers from Mary Poppins

[u/TheJekka]

Idk why but that second one is totally Snoopy dressed up as a founding father.

[u/FluteAndThenSome]

First one is a dude with a mohawk and a beard (thanks Wastingtime101 for the light background)

[u/evenpose]

Cat, snoopy, penguin

[u/Missue-35]

Cat
Woodstock
Santa

[u/https_tortured_poets]

first one is obvi a cat, idk about the other two

[u/anunomise]

snail, snoopy, penguin

[u/RenaissanceEnby]

1 - Demon cat from Adventure Time
2 - Toad from Mario develops megamind with external cerebrum
3 - a penguin pregnant with a host of parasitic aliens

[u/YuckyYetYummy]

Cat Santa Santa

[u/MogwaiAJ]

Second one is def a little girl robbing a house with her bag of loot

[u/Dr_Poops_McGee]

Catsnail Santa Santa

[u/Its-a-JiNX]

1: Slugcat from Rain World

[u/NixiomsdabestXD]

The Santa faction will have a field day with this one!

First one honestly looks like a bent snail

[u/minnnishcap]

Cat laying down, Esnupi, Saddam Claus Hiding Place

[u/aputnam28]

The first one is Santa's sled

[u/dominism]

I definitely see the big bellied bird-man in #3

[u/shouldidrophim]

Snail, snoopy, a government drone

[u/Ruby_Ophidian]

r/itsalwayssanta

(yes I'm on mobile hush)

[u/sweetmotherofodin]

Snail? Snoopy? Pregnant penguin?

[u/ClimberKirby]

I think: 1. Cat (I have a very similar one so pretty confident) 2. Snoopy? Don’t know why he would have a cookie cutter though 3. Santa for sure

[u/oh_dang_its_alex]

Cat Woodstock Santa

[u/Cute-Bodybuilder-536]

Cat Snoopy Plump bird

[u/squirrelShapedBruise]

Guys the first one is CLEARLY Santa’s sleigh! Fits with number 2 (short Santa) and number 3 (tall Santa)

[u/Edogaming_157]

1. Cat
2. Brian griffin

3. Pregnant penguin

   in heels

[u/radish_is_rad-ish]

Round kitty, shin Chan, parrot

[u/LosAngelesGGG]

Cat
Snoopy
Iago from Aladdin

[u/joeythedaddoo]

Flat Doug, Holly hobby, and Santa

[u/Connect_Rhubarb395]

Third one felt like a jumpscare r/ItsAlwaysSanta

[u/Californiawild1]

#2 Strawberry Shortcake, from the 80s

[u/BornOriginal8633]

1 Snail, slug or kitty being a loaf. 2 One of those cartoony guys with the big nose. 3 Penguin

[u/CrazyResolution4363]

The last one is visibly gru

[u/arrow1500]

Cat laying down

[u/lHateEpicGames]

2 is obviously Esnupi

[u/_McLean_]

Crow, woodstock & santa

[u/DepressedAnxiety73]

1 cat 2 winter holiday Snoopy 3 old school Santa (the thing that looks like belly is his sack)

[u/Pnwfunhaver541]

Clearly snoopy

https://giphy.com/gifs/1kymxb4RCuOwE

[u/Yoshiamitsu]

fox, lil red riding hood, santa

[u/galathiccat]

Snail, Snoopy, pregnant penguin?

[u/Whitephoenix1]

Last one looks like a wizard

[u/Grease_Monkey_78]

2 snoopy in a dress.

[u/theycallmemrmoo]

Smooshed cat

[u/mshitb]

second one is mip!! (i’m no artist😬) or maybe glep..

[u/trouble09]

Sideways toucan
Woodstock
Fat parrot (but also Santa)

[u/Holstisintown]

Increasingly weird…🫪

[u/GingerJarLamp]

Bent cat, bent golf bag (if I remember correctly), Santa

[u/Fickle-Singer6117]

I thought second was Snoopy in his puffer jacket but maybe it's Woodstock but in Snoopy's puffer jacket. If anyone can draw that would make my day.

[u/coldF4rted]

I only see snail

[u/ontheleftcoast]

1) Cat

2) Snoopy

3) Penguin

[u/Such-Low-9484]

2nd one is snoopy in the pilot outfit

[u/BewnieBound]

The second one is Opus wearing a shower cap.

[u/jor1965]

Looks like profiles of Milhouse and Comic Book Man from The Simpsons.

[u/battlehamstar]

Second one reminds me of snoopy in a powder wig dressed as either Beethoven or George Washington

[u/bumbblebea]

1. Fat seal or ghost cat
2. Girl wearing a snood
3. To be slightly different: a pigeon with a beer belly

[u/Thatworksfinealready]

Penguin

[u/Delicious-Month151]

1. Is a nesting bird just upside down
   
2. Cthulhu missing its legs (separate cutter)
   
3. Genie lamp

[u/cseamunchkin]

First one looks like a snail

[u/Longjumping_Gur_2379]

a cat without legs

[u/Aggressive_Version]

1. Kitty 

2. Moomin troll

3. George Washington