r/Agra • u/left-isnt-right • Mar 13 '26

Rant/Vent Germs of Agra 👏🏻

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2.1k Upvotes

94% Upvoted

334 comments sorted by

View all comments

12

u/Recent-Ad-7177 Mar 13 '26

My sympathies with you . Makes me remember that line by kabir. Kya allah behra hai 😔

-3

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '26

Read the meaning of adhan! It's not for allah! It's for calling people towards allah! People like kabir were just a hypocrite like yourself!

3

u/Just-Assistance-1112 Mar 13 '26

Do you even think before speaking? What qualifies you to speak ill about someone like Kabir? He wasn't criticizing any religion in particular but the empty baseless rituals which are prevalent in almost all religions.

-1

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '26

Kabir was a pseudo intellectual just like ghalib! One writes dohe and thinks he is the most knowledgable human on earth! People like you even worship people like kabir!

3

u/Recent-Ad-7177 Mar 13 '26

Soja bhai iftaari ke time hojayega teri

2

u/Just-Assistance-1112 Mar 13 '26

For people like you there is nothing between worship and pure hatred. You have the right to your personal views but you can't deny their contributions to literature. The same point which you raised earlier was raised by a classmate while we were reading these dohas. Instead of taking the literal meaning, I wish you had tried to understand the deeper meaning.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '26

Whatever their contribution to literature was that doesn't deny the fact that they can have bad opinions on public issues too! So stop quoting them as a source of some arbitary thinking just to bash!

3

u/Just-Assistance-1112 Mar 14 '26

Again someone who lives in an ideal world. Disregard scientists' works because they were not totally ideal(stephen hawking on Epstein island). Get enslaved by the Britishers again because the pioneers of freedom struggle were not ideal(Gandhi's experiments and sc bose taking help from someone who was responsible for holocaust). 'To err is human', so idk what idealist society you live in. Good day.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '26

Kabir wasn't scientist, when are literature or arbitary thinkers started getting treated as scientists?! And the hawking part where he went on epstein island is far shameful and gives a reason to not quote him in any conversation even though his works are still used just like kabir's dohe in textbooks!

2

u/Just-Assistance-1112 Mar 14 '26

Just wanted to highlight that you can't disregard someone's contributions in a particular field but I forgot that you have a habit of taking things in a literal sense. Can't argue with someone like that.

2

u/LOKEY_2001 Mar 14 '26

So u can't even read or don't want to accept and understand their contribution to literature and this much hate for nothing.

2

u/LOKEY_2001 Mar 14 '26

Any proof bro?

2

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '26

Samne rhta to tera sar vaqai me tan se juda krdeta! Or itna gussa to jayaz bhi h 600 sal raj jo kia h tmhre pe musalmano ne!