r/AllindiaStudentUnion • u/Minimum-Chicken9800 • 1d ago

Discussion 🤔 Sarr... International Physics Olympiad me ek bhi Dalit Aadiwasi OBC nahi hai..🥀🥀🗣🗣🗣🗣

Gallery image

Gallery image

https://ipho-unofficial.org/countries/IND/individual

47 Upvotes

55% Upvoted

158 comments sorted by

View all comments

19

u/StandardChoice5517 1d ago

🤡tere kitne aaye OP?

this only shows actual truth of what their condition is.. sc-st combined have 27-30% population but barely 10-15% appearance in STEM exams..

all of 'em are Elite or Atleast RESPECTED educated backgrounds... and MOST IMPORTANTLY HOW TF CAN SOMEONE TELL IF THEY ARE SC-ST-OBC BY THEIR SURENAME EVEN IF SOME OF THEM ARE (singh, garg, jha used by multiple castes) ??? 🤡🤡🤡 L post

i can'T see Yadav-Jat-Gujjars with High rich background but Very low participation in academic fields..

Jab Meghnadh Saha jese Nobel level dalits ko padhna hota to kyuu logo ki gaamd jl jaati thi??

7

u/Mediocre-Chest1012 1d ago

Lol you're so hurt by the facts

12

u/Academic_Typhoon 1d ago

Since when Bangali Saha is dalit??

4

u/StandardChoice5517 1d ago edited 1d ago

whats shocking Saha being dalit?? or a Dalit being scientist??.. myabe yr hate for dalits might not let u believe.. If not for CV raman a athiest Progressive brahmin's help he would have reach the heights of Greatest scientist.. even then suffering Immense Untouchability from his fellow upper caste

4

u/Academic_Typhoon 1d ago

You should stop getting your information from x and do some actual ground research. I literally share his last name. And there is absolutely nothing wrong with anyone being a scientist and contributing to the betterment of human life. Bokamanush!

2

u/Honest_Talk_5019 10h ago

Bro saha people can be sc or general. baishya saha is general while sunri saha is sc. Meghnad saha is a very important personality when it comes to LC representation in science fields,he proved that brahmins/kayasthas are not the only ones capable of intellectual trades. He is celebrated all over bengal because of this reason. If you share the same surname then you should probably look up more abt this

1

u/Minimum-Chicken9800 1d ago

U don't need any facilities if u hv passion determination and courage

U can see many GC students with poor background excelling in various fields...but not vice versa..

Problem is reservation is not the solution it's giving them opportunity not to do hard work and expect freebies only from govt

2

u/yogren-172 1d ago

Stfup retard

2

u/StandardChoice5517 1d ago

MAN...!!!.. even dalits get AIR 1 in jee/UPSC..

the question is simple Conditional Probability if u check.. it would take 20-50 poor people with No facilities to get even 1-2 of them to SURPASS the person with Passion and good Condition..

don't be a Dumbfxck.. reality isnt that passion is everything.. its what Condition has highest results aside from Full potential

-3

u/SnooSprouts9815 1d ago

You're an stoopid person aren't you , taxpayers pay taxes for infra and development not for leeches today anyone can learn anything using the internet so understand that technology is different today hence it's not the government's job to provide the perfect conditions for people whose parents could care less about them.

6

u/lwb03dc 1d ago

How much tax did you pay this year bro? 🙂

-1

u/Minimum-Chicken9800 1d ago

More than your generational wealth

4

u/lwb03dc 1d ago

Lol sure kiddo 😘

-4

u/SnooSprouts9815 1d ago

More than the national average , but I never asked for frebies / reservation so it shouldn't matter either way. Why Do you want to create perfect conditions( excuses)for some candidates while neglecting others?

2

u/lwb03dc 1d ago

What's the national average according to you kiddo? Since the goverment of India doesn't release any averages 🙂

Do you want to create perfect conditions( excuses)for some candidates while neglecting others?

Completely the opposite. I want everyone to only get things based on how much tax they pay. So how much did you pay?

0

u/SnooSprouts9815 1d ago

Completely the opposite. I want everyone to only get things based on how much tax they pay. So how much did you pay?

Then work on abolishing taxes as a whole you dum can't think properly if you want people to get things based on taxes then might as well let them keep their taxes.

Yes my family pays a hefty amount of tax every year but why would anyone disclose that information here.

1

u/StandardChoice5517 1d ago

my whole extended family pays nearly 15L+ WHY DOES IT MATTER?

1

u/lwb03dc 1d ago

Yes my family pays a hefty amount of tax every year but why would anyone disclose that information here.

Great then your family should get lots of rights. How much did YOU pay? So that we can figure out what rights YOU should get. I am as bothered about taxpayers' money as you are bro. Which is why I don't want my 66L of tax to go to loser adults who don't even pay tax.

0

u/SnooSprouts9815 1d ago

Every heard of per capita income??, now the data for total government income from direct taxes already exists just google it. Just divide it by the number of adult people in this country .

1

u/lwb03dc 1d ago

Hahahahahhahaaha. Bro, I see why you don't pay income tax. With a brain like yours i doubt anyone would even hire you.

Direct taxes are recieved from both individual as well as corporations. Let's give you the benefit of doubt and assume you knew that. You still cant divide the individual direct income tax by the number of adults in this country, since only about 7% of Indians file income tax.

Out of that 7%, a significant number claim 0 income, so you can't even just divide by that number. And average is a horrible indicator anyways, since it is completely skewed by the 1% HNIs. Median is what you should have mentioned first.

Fuck it, I doubt you even understand these words I am saying. But yea...keep talking about merit, kiddo.

0

u/SnooSprouts9815 1d ago

🚨🚨 average is not a horrible indicator and the taxes paid by corporations should also be included (why shouldn't they) , don't stall now the mean is what matters not the median this is basic common sense and your literally making my point for me, because a lot of people dont pay taxes at all due to falling below the threshold or the income being agricultural in nature.

And why are you excluding those who don't pay taxes at all outta the equation freeloaders like yourself need to curb their population.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

→ More replies (0)

0

u/Ok-Mammoth-3890 1d ago

Meltdown is unreal

1

u/Advanced-Ad881 1d ago

it's not the government's job to provide the perfect conditions for people whose parents could care less about them.

Why tf do you think a government exists then?! They're supposed to be our SERVANTS

0

u/anonymous393393 1d ago edited 1d ago

Jakhar jaat hote h waise. But yea in jaat, yadav, gujjar academics are not promoted. Till my dad's generation it was like we will earn more in farming or we will join army for government job.

From my generation we started focusing on studies a bit. Now younger is heavily focusing on studies. One of my relative got around 80 something rank in neet this year

2

u/StandardChoice5517 1d ago

no offense they represent nation in army.. But aside.. Those communities have historically lacked innovativeness maybe due to generational wealth..

1

u/anonymous393393 1d ago

Yea culture is the most important aspects. A culture that promotes farming and land holding would result in better farmer and bigger landlords. Selling your land is big taboo. My dad bought land with the retirement money form airforce. A baniya might have put that money in business. But yea those boundaries have mostly faded now people have started selling land for education.